VIP Asset Management: "Fundamental Incentives for Stock Price Suppression Must Be Eliminated"

Need for Assessment Based on Current Net Asset Value... "Procedures Should Also Be Streamlined"

Claiming to Prevent Stock Price Suppression, But Using COVID-Era Prices as the Standard?... Loopholes Abound View original image

The government's newly announced tax reform plan includes provisions for what's being called the "Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act." However, critics argue that the plan’s excessively detailed conditions may actually create loopholes for evasion through clever tactics. They point out that a fundamental solution is needed to eliminate incentives for driving stock prices lower.


On August 5, VIP Asset Management stated that incorporating stock price suppression prevention measures in the new tax reform is a step forward, but suggested the government plan should be supplemented by adopting the net asset value at the time of inheritance or gift as the minimum valuation standard.


Inheritance and gift taxes on listed stocks are calculated based on the average stock price over the two months before and after the time of inheritance or gifting. The lower the stock price, the lower the equity valuation and related tax, so major shareholders planning corporate succession have an incentive to keep the stock price artificially low.


The new government measure applies either an amount 30% higher than the current valuation or the highest average stock price within a period spanning from six months up to six years and six months in the past. This means that for companies whose shares were higher in the past, their valuation will increase, partially blocking the effect of reducing tax by temporarily driving down stock prices.


However, for companies whose stock prices have been suppressed over longer periods, the historical average is also low. Even adding a 30% premium to a depressed share price may be insignificant—akin to placing one more weight on an already tilted scale. VIP Asset Management noted, "A brief dip in stock price can be corrected with this method, but its impact on stocks that have been depressed for lengthy periods is limited," adding, "This approach claims to prevent price suppression, but then uses the depressed price as the baseline."


Past Stock Prices Are Not Fair Value... Cannot Reflect Industrial Changes

The government's idea is that current stock prices are artificially lowered in anticipation of ownership succession, so extending the valuation period into the past would correct this. However, this approach assumes that price suppression is a temporary measure around the inheritance or gift. In reality, companies with low price-to-book ratios (PBR), often managed with succession in mind, tend to have perpetually suppressed stock prices. Simply averaging the already depressed prices over the years does not represent true fair value.


The six-and-a-half year evaluation period presents another issue. During such a long period, there can be fundamental corporate changes—industry shifts, business structure transitions after a merger or acquisition, and new main business lines emerging.


For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, demand for diagnostic kits soared and related companies experienced sharp, short-term stock price surges. If those companies now face inheritance or gift taxes, it is unreasonable to use the special pandemic-period stock prices as the basis. Similarly, using today’s prices to value Samsung Electronics or SK hynix six years into the future during the current semiconductor boom would be equally inappropriate. VIP Asset Management pointed out, "Stock prices from six and a half years ago are not fair value—they are already 'expired.'"


Net Asset Value at Present Should Be the Standard... Simplification of Evaluation Methods Needed


VIP Asset Management emphasized that tax assessments should be based on the company’s actual net asset value at the time of inheritance or gifting, not on past stock prices. In other words, the system must be designed so that lowering the price would not reduce tax liability. As a fundamental solution to eliminate economic incentives for stock price suppression, the amendment proposed by Assemblymembers Lee Soyoung and Lee Hoonki would require that if the market value does not reach at least 80% of net asset value, the minimum valuation for listed companies be set at 80% of net asset value, consistent with methods applied to unlisted stocks.


Kim Minguk, CEO of VIP Asset Management, said, "We often hear from personnel in listed companies about the time and cost burdens of applying methods used for unlisted stocks," noting, "Nevertheless, the solution is not to give up on proper valuation, but rather to streamline procedures—such as allowing book value to be used for subsidiaries that are of negligible importance."


For instance, subsidiaries whose net asset value represents less than 5% of the parent may be allowed to use book value at their discretion. In business conglomerates such as SK Group Holdings, which have many subsidiaries, accurately valuing only the key companies—like SK Telecom and SK hynix—would capture most of the group’s enterprise value.


An Effective Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act Can Ease Stock Market Polarization


VIP Asset Management argues that while the government’s plan relies on screening and correcting the stock price for "suspect companies," the amendment proposed by Assemblymembers Lee Soyoung and Lee Hoonki takes a fundamentally different approach—eliminating the tax benefits that come from price suppression in the first place. To effectively change market practices as a whole, not just catch a few companies after the fact, the law should be revised to introduce a minimum valuation standard independent of stock prices.



CEO Kim emphasized, "The Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act must not end as a mere patch to inheritance and gift tax laws," adding, "It should become a turning point that corrects the paradoxical situation where large shareholders reduce taxes by devaluing their corporations."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing