Boasting "Zero Delivery Fee," While Shifting Burden onto Franchisees
Franchisees Face Tens of Millions of Won in Penalties for Unauthorized Purchases

A franchise headquarters that implemented a "0 won delivery fee" policy to attract consumers, while unilaterally passing the resulting cost burden and risk onto franchise owners, has been severely sanctioned by the Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC). It was also revealed that the headquarters imposed excessive penalties amounting to several million won and even suspended supply of goods to franchise owners for purchasing food ingredients worth about 5,000 won through unauthorized channels.

Youth Pizza Menu. The Asia Business Daily Database.

Youth Pizza Menu. The Asia Business Daily Database.

View original image

On August 5, the KFTC announced that it had decided to issue corrective orders and impose a penalty of 197 million won on BSB Food Co., Ltd., the franchisor of "Youth Pizza," for violating the Franchise Business Act. The violations included price-fixing, imposing excessive penalty clauses, and failing to comply with disclosure requirements.


According to the KFTC, since March 2021, BSB Food signed agreements with 445 franchise owners, including a special provision that required them to set the delivery fee displayed on delivery apps to "zero won." While this provision was partially modified—such as setting zero won for deliveries up to 1.5 km and charging an additional 100 won for every 100 meters—the policy continued until January 2025. BSB Food conducted inspections to ensure compliance with these provisions, and pressured non-complying franchisees by sending certified mail stating that breach of terms could result in contract termination or refusal to renew contracts.


The KFTC determined that these actions lacked any legitimate justification. Not only did they violate standard market practices, where consumers are expected to pay a certain delivery fee, but they also concentrated the burden of delivery app charges and delivery costs on franchisees, further worsening their operating profit. The franchisor, seeking marketing effects and public credit, ultimately shifted the real cost onto franchise owners.

5,000 Won Unauthorized Purchase Led to 20 Million Won Penalty...Total of 1.1 Billion Won Imposed

The headquarters’ excessive penalties against franchisees were also found to be extreme. Since 2018, BSB Food established new penalty clauses for unauthorized purchases (franchisees purchasing designated essential items through non-designated channels) and mid-contract cancellation. The penalty amounts were continually increased: 10 million won in 2018, 20 million won in 2020, and 50 million won in 2021.


In practice, from July 2021 to November 2024, penalties amounting to as much as 1.11 billion won were imposed for a total of 26 incidents, including 19 unauthorized purchase violations. If a franchise owner failed to pay the penalty, the headquarters suspended supply of goods or initiated civil litigation to compel payment, actually collecting about 120 million won in the process.


Even though the value of unauthorized purchases by franchisees was small, ranging from 5,100 won to 114,000 won per case, the actual penalties collected ranged from 3 million to 20 million won. According to the KFTC, these penalties were excessively high compared to the losses incurred by the headquarters. In addition, there were other violations, such as signing contracts with six prospective franchisees less than 14 days after providing the necessary disclosure documents, in breach of legal procedures.



The KFTC stated, "This case is the first to prove that a zero-delivery-fee special provision, promoted as a way to boost franchise sales in a market highly dependent on delivery platforms, in fact amounted to unfair practices that reduced franchise owners' operating profits." The Commission also emphasized, "The imposition of excessive penalties without considering the degree of violation is clearly an unfair business practice."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing