Possibility of Simultaneous Nomination for Noh Taeak's Successor

With Supreme Court Justice Lee Heunggu set to retire on September 7, four candidates have been shortlisted as his potential successor: Kim Moonkwan (62, 23rd Judicial Research and Training Institute class), Chief Judge of the Busan District Court; Kim Seongsu (57, 24th class), Presiding Judge at the Seoul High Court; Kim Yeyoung (51, 30th class), Presiding Judge at the Seoul Southern District Court; and Kim Jeongjung (60, 26th class), Presiding Judge at the Gwangju District Court.


On the 4th, at the Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul, participants including Chief Justice Choi Hee-dae and Minister of Justice Jung Sung-ho were engaging in conversation at the Judicial Selection Committee. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

On the 4th, at the Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul, participants including Chief Justice Choi Hee-dae and Minister of Justice Jung Sung-ho were engaging in conversation at the Judicial Selection Committee. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On August 4, the Supreme Court Candidate Recommendation Committee recommended these four out of a pool of 28 candidates for nomination to Supreme Court Chief Justice Chohidae. Chairperson Park Eunjeong stated, "We made every effort to recommend candidates with not only high expertise as legal professionals and the ability to make rational and balanced judgments, but also a strong commitment to the rule of law and judicial independence, upholding basic rights of the people, a belief in protecting the underprivileged and minorities, insight into the changing times and social expectations while embracing diverse values in our society, as well as meeting public standards of morality and integrity."


Chief Judge Kim Moonkwan of the Busan District Court is originally from Busan. He graduated from Busan Baejeong High School and Seoul National University's Department of Public Law, and began his judicial career in 1994 as a judge at the Seoul Criminal District Court. He has served as a research judge at the Supreme Court, presiding judge at the Busan District Court, and senior presiding judge at the Busan High Court, before being appointed as Chief Judge of the Busan District Court last year. Presiding Judge Kim Seongsu of the Seoul High Court was born in Hampyeong, Jeollanam-do. After graduating from Gwangju Inseong High School and Hanyang University's Department of Law, he began his judicial service in 1998 as a judge at the Gwangju District Court. He has served at the Haenam Branch of the Gwangju District Court, Seoul High Court, as Ethics and Audit Deliberation Officer at the National Court Administration, presiding judge at Jeju District Court, senior presiding judge at Cheongju District Court, and chief instructor at the Judicial Research and Training Institute.


Presiding Judge Kim Yeyoung of the Seoul Southern District Court was born in Seoul, graduated from Daewon Foreign Language High School and Seoul National University's Department of Law, and began her judicial career in 2001 as an associate judge at the Changwon District Court. She has served as a judge at the Uijeongbu District Court and Seoul Central District Court, and also chaired the Representative Council of Judges, where she voiced calls for judicial reform and progressive change. Presiding Judge Kim Jeongjung of the Gwangju District Court is originally from Naju, Jeollanam-do. He graduated from Seoul Baemoon High School and Seoul National University's Department of Judicial Studies. He began his judicial career in 1997 at the Southern Branch of the Seoul District Court, and has since served as a research judge at the Supreme Court, head of the Gangneung Branch of the Chuncheon District Court, and Chief Judge of the Seoul Central District Court, before being appointed as Presiding Judge at the Gwangju District Court last year.


Chief Justice Cho plans to disclose the major rulings and previous work history of the candidates and, by August 7, collect opinions from inside and outside the judiciary before selecting a single nominee. The nominee will then be recommended to President Lee Jaemyung for appointment. There is also a possibility that a nominee to succeed former Supreme Court Justice Noh Taeak may be recommended at the same time; although Justice Noh stepped down in March, a successor has not yet been nominated. While the Constitution grants the authority to nominate Supreme Court justices to the Chief Justice, it is customary for the Presidential Office and the Chief Justice to collaborate before finalizing the nominee.


If a successor to the Supreme Court Justice is appointed at this time, it will mark the first appointment since President Lee Jaemyung took office in June last year. In legal circles, there are expectations that, in the process of recommending two candidates simultaneously—one as Justice Lee Heunggu's successor—the judiciary and the Presidential Office may attempt to strike a compromise by exchanging nominations. On this day, Chief Justice Cho told the Candidate Recommendation Committee, "You made excellent recommendations last time, and I am very sorry that they're not yet finalized. Going forward, I will do my utmost together with everyone."



This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing