Lee Taegyu: "Kim Yongbeom, Who Actually Led the Policy, Avoids Responsibility"

Park Wonsuk: "Oh Sehoon's Situation Could Become a Game-Changer for Jang Donghyuk"

■ Broadcast: The Asia Business Daily "So Jongsup's Current Affairs Show" (Mon–Fri, 4–5 PM)

■ Host: So Jongsup, Political Specialist ■ Producer: Ma Yena, PD

■ Guests: Park Wonseok, former Justice Party member of the National Assembly; Lee Taekyu, former People Power Party member of the National Assembly (August 3)

※ When quoting content from this article, please make sure to cite “So Jongsup’s Current Affairs Show.”


So Jongsup: Hello, everyone. Welcome to So Jongsup’s Current Affairs Show. Today, I’m joined by Park Wonseok, former member of the Justice Party, and Lee Taekyu, former member of the People Power Party, for a lively discussion on various hot issues. Gentlemen, welcome.


Park Wonseok & Lee Taekyu: Hello.


So Jongsup: Foreign media outlets have been putting a spotlight on the "rage of the ants," referring to retail investors' anger.


Foreign Media Spotlight on "Rage of the Ants"

Park Wonseok: The KOSPI has been fluctuating in a manner similar to a gambling table, triggering circuit breakers—meaning trading halts for 20 minutes if the price falls by 8%. There have been 14 such incidents on our stock market, 7 of which occurred this year, and 4 of those happened in July. As a result, investing in the KOSPI itself has become almost like gambling, at least psychologically. One identified cause is the launch of single-stock leveraged products. It seems the financial authorities did not sufficiently consider the risks of these products from a policy standpoint when they were first introduced.


Unlike the US or other countries, our market structure is heavily concentrated on semiconductor stocks—essentially just two. In fact, one could almost say the entire KOSPI is tantamount to a single semiconductor stock. If you combine the top 200 KOSPI listings, they make up about 66% of the entire market. When leveraged ETFs based on these securities are created, it works well when prices rise, but when stocks fall, the situation becomes uncontrollable. Moreover, regulation on these products has been lax, and their introduction is now a major driver of volatility. The government has rushed out two countermeasures, but will they actually work?


Trust has broken down, and tens of trillions of won in losses have already been incurred. While investing is a matter of personal responsibility, the government has painted a rosy outlook for the stock market and encouraged the public to invest. Yet, they released high-risk products with virtually no regulation. Can investors really have confidence? At this point, it feels as if foreign investors are just toying with us.





So Jongsup: President Lee Jaemyung’s approval rating has hit its lowest point since taking office, at 45.9%. Would you say this is related to investor disappointment?


Financial Supervisory Chiefs Are Only Helpless

Lee Taekyu: Not entirely, but real estate issues in particular have played a significant role in dragging down the president’s approval ratings. The government’s perception and attitude towards these issues are even more problematic, in my view. Even though investors have suffered massive losses, the government treats the matter as if it’s someone else’s problem. You can see this in the attitude and statements made by the heads of the financial regulators when summoned to the National Assembly—they just come across as utterly helpless. No one really knows what the actual plan is. In particular, Kim Yongbeom, the policy chief who spearheaded the leveraged ETF products, has taken no responsibility whatsoever.

Investors might be more forgiving if there was even a hint of humility from those in charge, but right now, the criticism is justified.


When the president’s aides or ministers in charge fail to come up with responsible solutions for such major issues—or evade responsibility altogether—all the political consequences and burdens ultimately fall back on the president. If his aides or the ministers responsible try to hide behind him instead of taking ownership, how can such an administration succeed? The Economist in the UK used extremely provocative language, describing Korea’s stock market as the testing ground for an extreme fusion of state capitalism and market speculation. In other words, they called it the casino floor of state capitalism.


Last time, when the issue of Kim Yongbeom’s responsibility for single-stock leveraged ETFs was raised, all the authority was his, but none of the responsibility. He led the design and introduction of the product, and even set the direction by saying there would be no delisting. Yet, instead of addressing the matter, the Financial Services Commission and the Financial Supervisory Service chiefs were summoned by the Assembly and left to handle it. Is this really normal governance? President Lee Jaemyung needs to think seriously about this.


Some Even Suggest This Is a New Form of Bureaucratic Control

Park Wonseok: The market isn’t something the president can control. I do think the government did well to remove obstacles regarding corporate transparency and governance by amending the commercial code and improving the market. However, the government has become excessively interventionist—trying to revive or boost the stock market even through rhetoric, or by hastily introducing high-risk derivatives like leveraged ETF products, without thorough policy consideration. This has caused the current problems. That’s why some are suggesting this is a new form of bureaucratic control.


All these policy attitudes are now backfiring. I believe the government should refrain from making statements that sound like direct market intervention. There is considerable public opinion that someone should be held accountable for the leveraged ETF controversy. But will Kim Yongbeom actually be held responsible? I’m not sure. Regardless, both the Blue House and the policy chief seem to be overstepping their roles. The same is true regarding real estate. The Blue House policy team should be focused on macro-level planning or coordination, not execution.


Yet, the Minister of Strategy and Finance has been nowhere to be seen. Perhaps the status of the Deputy Prime Minister for Economic Affairs has diminished since the Budget and Planning Office was spun off. These days, you hardly ever hear a clear direction from the Deputy Prime Minister on major economic issues. So it feels like the Blue House policy chief is functioning as the economic control tower, which is not ideal. Such a system could easily become distorted, and I believe the president needs to step in and adjust roles as appropriate.





So Jongsup: The Democratic Party’s national convention is now underway, with Kim Minseok and Jeong Cheongrae emerging as the two main contenders. What are your thoughts on how things are playing out?


Park Wonseok: The two candidates are basically tied. While there are minor differences, nothing is particularly meaningful. Unexpectedly, in the first regional primary in Chungcheong, Jeong Cheongrae was expected to win or at least have the edge—some even said Kim Minseok could overturn the results if he could keep the gap within 7%. But Kim Minseok won there. In Busan, Ulsan, and Gyeongnam—which are traditionally strongholds for the pro-Roh and pro-Moon factions—Jeong Cheongrae’s organizational strength was expected to give him the advantage, but the race was much closer than anticipated. Kim Minseok’s background has evidently worked in his favor.


Strong Likelihood of Kim Minseok Gaining Support in Honam

Next week, the primaries head to Honam and the Seoul metropolitan area, where roughly 68% of party members are concentrated. According to opinions within and outside the Democratic Party, Kim Minseok is expected to perform strongly in Gwangju and Jeonnam and is likely to secure more than half the votes. Jeong Cheongrae’s support seems unlikely to be as high as expected. Meanwhile, the reaction in Gwangju and Jeonnam to recent repeated messages from author Yoo Si-min is reportedly not very positive. North Jeolla is said to be more competitive, with Jeong Cheongrae possibly leading by a narrow margin. When you consider the situation in the capital area as well, the momentum appears to be shifting slightly toward Kim Minseok, especially given the presence of a preferential voting system….


Lee Taekyu: The decisive factor in the Democratic Party’s leadership election this August will be how the party’s dues-paying members interpret the president’s intentions. Because President Lee Jaemyung has provided tangible economic benefits to Honam, I believe this will translate into strong support for Kim Minseok in the convention. Unless Jeong Cheongrae dominates in the early stages, it will be hard for him to maintain a favorable position throughout the race.


So Jongsup: There’s been talk that the so-called “pro-Jang Donghyuk” faction is consolidating power within the People Power Party.

On the 4th, Jang Donghyuk, leader of the People Power Party, is walking towards the press conference venue regarding the real estate tax reform. Photo by Kim Hyunmin

On the 4th, Jang Donghyuk, leader of the People Power Party, is walking towards the press conference venue regarding the real estate tax reform. Photo by Kim Hyunmin

View original image

Park Wonseok: It’s been two months since the local elections. Immediately afterward, party leader Jang Donghyuk faced calls to resign, and then the electoral commission scandal broke, with allegations of poor management. Jang fully engaged with the crisis, regrouped outside the party, and reorganized his base. The party then began to implement disciplinary politics. In contrast, the internal movement that had pushed for Jang Donghyuk’s ouster got bogged down with too much calculation and lost momentum.


Meanwhile, floor leader Jeong Jeom-sik changed his stance—from an initial position that Jang Donghyuk’s resignation was inevitable to a more withdrawn view that consensus was lacking. He now appears to be leaning toward letting things remain as they are. Kwon Youngjin, who had served as the de facto leader of the “Alternative and Future” group, saw the group’s clout diminish after becoming embroiled in a physical altercation. Several lawmakers aligned with the Han faction—such as Jin Jongoh, Park Junghoon, and Bae Hyunjin—are reportedly being considered for disciplinary action. As for Han Donghun’s return to the party, many senior members currently oppose it, so there’s little central cohesion at the moment.


If Things Continue, It Will Be Hard to Block Jang Donghyuk’s Attempt at a Second Term

By contrast, Jang Donghyuk’s core supporters have now completed their preparations for a new offensive, including the announced creation of a public official evaluation committee. What does this mean? His term technically ends in August next year, so he would have no say in the next general election nominations. By forming this committee, he is signaling his intention to secure the nomination authority for the next election. He also plans party reform measures that would increase the influence of rank-and-file members—essentially preparing to challenge for another term. As a result, more party members are now watching Jang carefully. At this rate, the decision of when to end his term will rest solely with him, and there may be no way to prevent him from running for reelection.

 

If Jang Donghyuk and the so-called “Yoon Again” faction secure the next leadership, I don’t think the People Power Party stands a chance in the next general election. Any hopes for Han Donghun’s return or internal reform—especially now, when Mayor Oh Sehun is at significant legal risk—appear to have dissipated since the local election.


So Jongsup: Support for the People Power Party rebounded to pre-local election levels. Isn’t it fair to say their current actions are failing to win public approval?


Lee Taekyu: The People Power Party’s support isn’t rising due to anything they’ve done well; rather, it’s simply a response to various flaws and issues in the Lee Jaemyung administration. Under current circumstances, Jang Donghyuk’s term is entirely up to him—there are simply no political mechanisms or momentum within the party to force his resignation against his will. First, if he refuses to step down, there is no political structure or energy in the party to remove him. Second, with President Lee Jaemyung’s approval rating falling, there’s a sense that the party just needs to wait things out for another chance—with this view growing mainly in Yeongnam. There is no responsible driver of conservative reform and renewal. The party’s chronic tendency to do nothing unless it serves personal interests is eating away at its own potential. And finally, it’s the Lee Jaemyung administration that continues to provide Jang Donghyuk with the justification to hold on to power.


Potential for Oh Sehun’s Appeal Outcome to Become a Variable

Park Wonseok: But there is one potential variable.


So Jongsup: A variable? What do you mean?


Park Wonseok: If the Supreme Council members resign, the party leadership collapses. After the local election, both Supreme Council members Kim Jaewon and Shin Dongwook faced a lot of pressure. Shin Dongwook, in particular, appears to be considering a run in the next Seoul mayoral election if Oh Sehun loses his position. If so, there isn’t much time left. To enter a primary, Shin would need to step down to change his image, making his resignation likely. Kim Jaewon would then be the only one remaining. Even while he has continued as a senior official, Kim Jaewon has made comments suggesting flexibility. In other words, depending on their moves, the leadership could collapse at any time.



So Jongsup: That's all for today’s discussion with Park Wonseok, former Justice Party lawmaker, and Lee Taekyu, former People Power Party lawmaker. Please take extra care in this hot weather. Thank you both for your insights.

[Current Affairs Show] Park Wonseok, Lee Taekyu: "Momentum Shifts Toward Kim Minseok" View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing