KB: "Valuation Standards May Shift If Profit Margins Hold"

Should Semiconductors Still Be Bought at High PER and Sold at Low PER? View original image

A claim has emerged suggesting that the investment yardstick for the Korean semiconductor industry—buying at high PER (price-to-earnings ratio) and selling at low PER—may change after the current downcycle.


According to the strategic report "When Will the Valuation Yardstick for Semiconductors Change?" published by KB Securities on August 5, voices are being raised that the valuation logic for Korean semiconductors needs to be reconsidered.


Mingyu Kim, a researcher at KB Securities, highlighted that the case of TSMC in Taiwan should be referenced when considering changes to semiconductor valuation standards. Kim explained, "In the past, TSMC, much like Korean semiconductors, was also subject to the valuation logic of cyclical industries, where investors had to buy at high PER and sell at low PER—meaning that even when earnings improved, the company traded at a discount. Its profit margins showed the typical volatility of a cyclical industry, with sharp rises and falls until the early 2000s."


Kim went on, "Since 2010, TSMC's profit margin lows have risen and volatility has been reduced. A key factor was when AMD spun off its manufacturing division in 2009, causing foundry demand to be concentrated at TSMC," he noted.


However, he emphasized, "It was not until at least several years later, after 2015, that TSMC no longer applied the cyclical industry's valuation logic of buying at high PER and selling at low PER. The actual PER levels have also changed since then."


He continued, "It is clear that valuation rerating is not simply granted during a boom. While a boom can generate optimism for change compared to the past and drive up share prices, the true shift in valuation logic happens only after experiencing at least one downcycle firsthand."


Kim also pointed out, "During the downturn in the semiconductor sector in 2011–2012, TSMC was able to defend its profit margins. The cycles persisted, but over time, TSMC proved that the floor for margins had risen compared to the past—and its valuation subsequently moved up a notch. This is the process of passing the threshold for rerating."



He concluded, "A downcycle will inevitably come to the Korean semiconductor industry as well. The key question will be whether, in the face of falling prices, companies will see their margins deteriorate as before, or whether they will be able to maintain margins by setting prices through higher value-added products like HBM and new contract structures such as LTA (long-term agreement). This is what we need to watch going forward."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing