"Performance-based Bonuses Are Profit Sharing...
A Reasonable Solution Is Needed"

After Samsung Electronics and SK hynix introduced performance bonuses based on a fixed proportion of operating profit, similar demands have been made at other major companies. In this context, the amended trade union and labor relations act, commonly known as the Yellow Envelope Act, is being criticized for causing greater confusion on the industrial front. Lawmakers and experts point out that supplementary measures are needed, such as revising guidelines that broadened the scope of labor disputes to include managerial decisions.


Woo Jaejun, member of the People Power Party, is speaking at the discussion forum titled "Issues of the Yellow Envelope Act Viewed Through the Debate on Operating Profit n% Performance Bonus" on the 4th. Courtesy of Woo Jaejun's office

Woo Jaejun, member of the People Power Party, is speaking at the discussion forum titled "Issues of the Yellow Envelope Act Viewed Through the Debate on Operating Profit n% Performance Bonus" on the 4th. Courtesy of Woo Jaejun's office

View original image

On August 4, Woo Jaejun, a member of the People Power Party, held a discussion forum at the National Assembly building titled "Issues of the Yellow Envelope Act Viewed Through the Debate on Operating Profit n% Performance Bonus." The forum was attended by lawmakers Ko Dongjin, Kim Yongtae, Kim Hyoungdong, and Yoo Yongwon of the People Power Party, as well as independent lawmaker Han Donghoon.


The event was organized against the backdrop of debates over performance bonuses expanding beyond individual companies' wage negotiations to become a broader social conversation about wage systems and performance compensation principles across industries. The purpose was to discuss how far the scope of collective bargaining should extend, how to strike a balance between corporate management autonomy and workers' rights and interests, and how to design a sound wage system for the industrial sector.


Woo Jaejun explained, "At the time of passing the Yellow Envelope Act, thorough discussions were held with the intention of closely examining what might specifically arise from its enactment. Despite these efforts, the bill was ultimately passed very abruptly under the sponsorship of the Democratic Party of Korea." He went on to add, "In fact, the clause making managerial decisions subject to industrial action was inserted on the very day the bill was passed, and we are now facing the consequences."


Woo Jaejun also voiced his concerns, saying, "(With strikes being prepared across various sectors) I seriously question whether our country is economically prepared. There's a sense of fear," predicting, "We could see an economic storm within a month or two." He further noted, "(President Lee Jaemyung) has mentioned that the interpretation guidelines on performance bonuses might need to be revised, which is at least one positive development. We need to find a rational solution."


On this day, Professor Park Jisun of Korea University Law School delivered a presentation titled "Problems and Solutions of the Yellow Envelope Act and the Debate on Management Performance Bonuses." He pointed out that the expansion of labor disputes to include managerial decisions, like the distribution of performance bonuses, has led to cases where such matters are mistakenly seen as legitimate subjects of industrial action. He emphasized the need to establish clearer legislative and interpretive standards to define the boundary between working conditions and managerial rights.


Professor Park explained, "Performance bonuses are a post hoc distribution of business results and constitute a form of profit sharing. They do not fit into any wage, benefit, or other compensation categories, so current law makes it clear that they should not be a subject of labor disputes. In principle, the authority to decide on this lies with the company's board of directors or the general meeting of shareholders, and excessive profit sharing may pose various liability issues for management, which is why institutional checks are necessary."



Representative Kim Hyoungdong also noted, "The Yellow Envelope Act was not intended to reduce polarization or duality in the labor market, but seems rather to be widening the gap, which is regrettable," and stressed the need for institutional improvement. Representative Ko Dongjin added, "While I completely agree with the importance and necessity of union activity, it must operate within the bounds of balance and moderation in a democratic society. This is not the right direction."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing