[Rosy 'Debt-Fueled' Investing] ① When Bursting Dreams Destroyed Families
Review of 726 Rulings: Crimes Evolve Into Organized Structures
Investment Failures and Debt Pressure: Targets Start Close to Home
"Economic Frustration Can Strengthen Motive... Manifesting as Violence"
On the 3rd, employees are monitoring the stock market and exchange rates in the dealing room at the Hana Bank headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Jo Yongjun
View original image#Deeply engrossed in stocks, Mr. A turned to the mother of his common-law spouse for help. He borrowed as much as 780 million won by even taking out a mortgage loan. However, the investment failed, leaving him with debts surpassing 1 billion won. His relationship with his sister-in-law, who pressed him to repay the money, also became strained. While the family was away, Mr. A strangled and killed his sister-in-law. Even after being sentenced to 30 years in prison in the first trial, he appealed. The Seoul High Court’s Criminal Division 3 upheld the original verdict in April last year.
#Resentment from losses first shattered close relationships. Mr. B had been caring for his cousin and the cousin's mother for years. After failing at stock investment, he fell into the delusion that “caring for my cousin’s mother kept me from managing my stocks.” He began quarreling with his cousin, who was like a brother, and ultimately resorted to violence with a weapon. In September last year, the Criminal Division 1 of the Seongnam Branch of Suwon District Court sentenced Mr. B to four years in prison for attempted murder.
Behind the stock trading frenzy, distorted desires for profit and frustration are spreading into various crimes. Fraud schemes promising high returns have evolved into organized operations, leading to “second-wave victims.” Furthermore, failed investments and debt pressure have damaged relationships—even with close family. It is now pointed out that failed investments are escalating from individual financial setbacks to social harm that threatens both property and lives.
726 Court Verdicts Show: Investment Fraud Escalates to Serious Crimes
On August 5, The Asia Business Daily conducted a comprehensive analysis of 726 court verdicts from January last year to June this year, drawn from criminal cases across the country where the motive for the crime was “stock investment” or where investment-related offenses were involved. Seven out of ten cases were linked to fraud. Notably, investment-related crimes were found to be not just simple personal scams or one-off offenses; they have become more organized, involving the use of telecommunications and division of labor.
By offense category, fraud, attempted fraud, and fraud aiding and abetting (including offenses under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes) accounted for 515 cases (70.9%), the highest among all crimes. Violations of the Telecommunications Business Act followed at 67 cases (9.2%), and organizing or joining criminal groups were 32 cases (4.4%). Charges under the Telecommunications Business Act indicate that tools such as burner phones were mobilized in the crimes. Charges related to criminal organizations mean that these offenses were carried out in an organized manner, complete with command structures and division of roles. This shows that a portion of investment-related crimes have evolved beyond simple deviation or fraud, developing into organized crime syndicates.
Although their absolute number was small, crimes where the impact was most serious were classified as violent and serious offenses, totaling 18 cases (2.5%). These included not only the five major violent crimes (murder, robbery, rape, theft, assault) but also a variety of offenses such as injury, intimidation, arson, unlawful confinement, and abetting suicide. Many of the conflicts that surfaced during investment or loss phases led not only to financial harm but also to crimes threatening life and physical safety.
Of the 726 cases, sentences of guilty verdicts were delivered in 703. Among these, incarceration accounted for 472 cases (65.0%), suspended sentences 177 (24.4%), and fines 54 (7.4%). Combined, prison sentences and suspended prison sentences made up 89.4% of all cases. This suggests that the courts did not take the severity of most cases brought to trial lightly.
Sense of Despair from the 'Broken Ladder' Fuels Aggression
When stock prices were rising, equities were seen as a ladder to expanding one’s assets. However, as sharp declines struck, the problems became more obvious. Overlapping pressures to recover losses, the sense of deprivation from others’ success, and disputes over debt and responsibility have shattered relationships, with some cases escalating into crime.
It is difficult to dismiss cases of lashing out at family or those close to the investor following investment failure as mere exceptions. Although there is no direct analysis yet linking stock investment to crime, research does show that rapid economic hardship can lead to increased violent crime. Professor Woo-Seok Yoon of the Police Administration Department at Keimyung University conducted a study, “Verifying the Relationship Between Economic Crisis and Crime Occurrence,” analyzing economic indices and occurrences of the five major crimes from 1995 to 2005 using time series data.
The analysis showed that for the entire study period, there was no significant relationship between economic crises and the five major crimes. However, focusing specifically on the financial crisis years, surges in unemployment were found to increase occurrences of murder, robbery, and assault. The conclusion of the study was that, although economic difficulties do not universally increase all forms of crime, they can sufficiently intensify the motives behind certain violent crimes such as murder and assault.
Experts agree. Professor Sangkyun Kim, of the Police Studies Department at Baekseok University and former president of the Korean Association of Criminal Psychology, noted, “When people fail to achieve their goals or feel a sense of frustration, it can manifest as aggression. If someone feels especially defeated during an investment boom like this, it could certainly turn into violent behavior.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Regarding the fact that many victims of serious crimes were close relatives or acquaintances, he explained, “When frustration builds up, conflicts are more likely with those around you whom you see frequently. If financial issues enter into such disputes, violent tendencies can be further intensified.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.