[Economy Pulse] Solution Needed for Single-Stock Leverage Products View original image

The stock market has plunged into panic. The KOSPI index, which had been approaching the 10,000 mark, has dropped to the 6,000s within just one month. The market even triggered circuit breakers, which temporarily halt trading, for two consecutive days. The causes are the fluctuations in the global semiconductor cycle and shifts in earnings estimates. With the market searching for a correction after a short-term surge, even minor issues are amplified. The structural limitation that Samsung Electronics and SK hynix (commonly called 'Samjeonnix') together make up over half of the total market capitalization is a major factor. However, the fallout has spread to single-stock leveraged products.


It is possible to measure the extent to which single-stock leveraged products increase volatility. Utilizing market microstructure theory, one can calculate the impact on price movements from the buy and sell flows and rebalancing demands caused by leverage. However, isolating these effects is no easy task. An indirect comparison can be made by looking at stocks with similar business structures, such as Intel or Micron. Samsung Electronics’ volatility was 4.53% per day before leveraged products were introduced this year, and 7.59% after. In comparison, Intel’s volatility was 5.51% before and 5.67% after. SK hynix’s volatility was also similar to Micron at 5.29% before, but soared to 8.92% after leverage was implemented. While leverage is not solely responsible for the surge in volatility, it is clear that an urgent solution is needed.


The financial authorities promptly raised the deposit requirement to 30 million won in cash. Soon after, they announced a second-stage response, which also limited investment proportions. Nevertheless, both the political community and the market are demanding even stronger measures. Delisting leveraged products is not an option, since they do not meet the formal criteria and numerous laws and regulations would need to be revised.


To immediately contain the crisis, suspending trading would have a significant impact and is worth considering. According to the stock exchange’s listing regulations, this is permissible “to serve the public interest, protect investors, and manage the market.” Trading can resume once the market stabilizes. If necessary, Listing Regulation Article 115 (Designation as Managed Stock) and Article 153 (Trading Suspension), as well as Implementation Guidelines Article 94 (Designation as Managed Stock), can be revised. The precedent here is the creation of delisting conditions for leveraged products under Guideline Article 95, Paragraph 2. For example, if the proportion of leveraged trading to underlying stock trading exceeds a certain threshold for a certain period, it can be designated as a managed stock and thus suspended from trading. Additionally, a static volatility interruption mechanism (VI), based on trading proportion, could allow for temporary intraday halts. However, protecting investors during any trading suspension remains a separate challenge.


The more fundamental issue to address is trading value and turnover. To reduce trading value, inflows of new funds need to be curbed, assets under management (AUM) should be maintained, and the scale of rebalancing must be reduced. To lower turnover, measures that disadvantage high-frequency traders are needed.


To control new fund inflows, further increases in deposit requirements are under consideration. To maintain AUM, the premium or discount rates can be widened and the aggregate quantity controlled. Decision-making on such deviations should be left to investors. To reduce rebalancing size, tracking ratios should be made more flexible: if the market surges or plunges, the leverage ratio could be capped at below 2x, and when stable, raised to above 2x, so as to average out to 2x over time. This is distinct from the “emergency intervention authority” under government review or Hong Kong’s “variable leverage” model. However, this approach would inevitably require sacrifice from asset managers and liquidity providers (LPs). Flexibility in enforcing rules is needed. To reduce turnover, either increase deposit requirements for excessive turnover rates, or impose additional fees for short-term trades above a certain frequency.


Single-stock leveraged products are designed more for professional investors than for individuals. By raising entry barriers and strengthening oversight, these products should be limited to their fundamental role—risk hedging—while shrinking their footprint in the broader market. Having gained a reputation as amplifiers of volatility and liquidity black holes, single-stock leverage must now be addressed with effective stabilization policies to put an end to this unproductive controversy.



Professor Lee Junseo, Department of Business Administration, Dongguk University


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing