Governance Forum Criticizes Stock Price Suppression Tax Reform as Disappointing... 'Exemption' for Low-PBR Companies
"Most large and mid-sized companies will be exempted."
The Korea Corporate Governance Forum expressed regret over the government's proposed tax reform aimed at addressing the so-called "stock price suppression" practices, stating that the plan fails to achieve its intended purpose of normalizing the capital market. The Forum argues that the proposal effectively grants exemptions, as it is structured to allow most low price-to-book ratio (PBR) companies to avoid being subject to stricter scrutiny.
On August 4, the Forum issued a statement regarding the Ministry of Economy and Finance’s tax reform draft, released the previous day, titled "Improvement of Valuation Methods for Listed Shares corresponding to Stock Price Suppression." The key points include: ▲ for KOSPI-listed companies, those with a PBR in the bottom 25% of their industry over the past six years; ▲ for KOSDAQ-listed companies, those in the bottom 10%; and ▲ companies with a damaged enterprise value due to overlapping listings or other reasons in the past year, and whose market value has declined by more than 30% compared to its market cap over the past three years, are identified as companies suspected of stock price suppression. For these companies, the method of assessing shares for inheritance and gift tax purposes will be tightened.
Specifically, for low-PBR companies designated as engaging in stock price suppression, the taxable value for inheritance will be determined based on the higher of either: the "average stock price over the past 6 months to 6 years and 6 months," or "1.3 times the current standard stock price." For companies whose stock price has plummeted due to enterprise value impairment, the "average share price over the past 6 months to 3 years" will be applied.
The Forum criticized, "A detailed review of the proposal brings about reasonable suspicion that some listed companies suspected of stock price suppression may employ corporate and tax law experts — using mostly minority shareholders' money — to circumvent the new tax reform plan." The Forum added that this does not align at all with President Lee Jaemyung’s recent call to accelerate the passage of laws preventing stock price manipulation as a part of capital market normalization efforts.
According to the Forum's estimates, based on the new proposal, there are about 84 to 87 KOSPI-listed companies and 43 KOSDAQ-listed companies—around 130 companies in total— where the PBR over 12 out of the last 13 quarters ranked in the industry’s bottom 25% (KOSPI) or 10% (KOSDAQ). This is substantially fewer than the roughly 200 companies the government projected when announcing the tax plan. The average PBR of the target companies is calculated at 0.27 for KOSPI and 0.29 for KOSDAQ.
The Forum pointed out, "The new proposal merely highlights legal technicalities and will have a negligible effect on preventing controlling shareholders from infringing on minority shareholders’ rights." It continued, "Most large and mid-sized enterprises will fall outside the scope. Notable companies include Lotte Holdings, GS, DL, Taekwang Industrial, Hanwha Life, Daishin Securities, and Emart." The Forum also noted, "Even with a 30% premium applied, using the figure for the 84 to 87 KOSPI companies, the average PBR only rises from 0.27 to 0.35. One has to wonder how much thought the Ministry of Economy and Finance put into the objectives of this reform."
In particular, the Forum criticized the abandonment of a general methodology that identifies the bottom 25% of all KOSPI and KOSDAQ companies, in favor of subdividing companies into 11 industries using the GICS classification—something used mainly by overseas institutional investors—and then selecting the bottom group within each industry. "There are differences in PBR by industry, and as seen in the recent fluctuations in semiconductor stocks, PBR can change with industry cycles. Still, considering that the median PBR for 10 out of the 11 GICS sectors in Korea (except IT) is far below 1, targeting the bottom 25% of each industry rather than the entire market effectively gives a free pass to many low-PBR companies," the Forum emphasized.
The Forum also noted that the proposed reform fails to fully reflect the intent of the recent Commercial Act amendment, which calls for "protecting the interests of all shareholders and treating all shareholders fairly." The Forum stated: "The current administration achieved the Commercial Act amendment over three phases to strengthen shareholder rights, yet paradoxically, the proportion of companies trading below a PBR of 1 (meaning market capitalization is lower than net asset/book value) has expanded to 70%. Investors had high hopes for the government’s tax reform, but it is now perceived as a step back from ambitious reforms."
Furthermore, the Forum asserted, "If a company's PBR is below 1, this means its stock price is lower than liquidation value, regardless of industry. For a listed company supposed to pursue the interests of all shareholders through efficient capital allocation, this is a fundamental flaw and such a company should not have been listed in the first place." The Forum went on to urge, "Rather than devising various technical legal devices to appease the inevitable tax resistance of controlling shareholders, the government should instead focus on measures to restore market order by tackling practices that distort the capital market and the national economy through tax evasion. This should be pursued from a macro perspective, including rationalizing inheritance and gift tax rates, and introducing a financial investment income tax."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.