[Inside Chodong] Government Justifies Targeted Tax Hike as 'Normalization' View original image

"All of the President's priorities are reflected here."


This is how tax experts assessed the second-year real estate tax reform plan of the Lee Jaemyung administration announced on August 3. President Lee, during last month's National Grand Debate, stated, "By not distinguishing between homes for residence and for speculation, something significant has happened through a small loophole," expressing his intent to create a market centered on residential use. Earlier this year, in January and February, he signaled his stance by posting on social networking services (SNS), "It's advantageous to switch to a single high-quality home; if it's not for residential use, it's not worthwhile," indicating that high-priced, non-residential homeowners would be disadvantaged. He also criticized the long-term capital gains special deduction (Jangteuk Gongje), saying, "It blocks properties from being put on the market and instead encourages speculation." These remarks have now materialized in the reform plan, widening the scope of regulation to include even extremely high-priced, non-residential single homeowners, and resulting in increased taxation. Thus, describing these changes as 'the President’s priorities' is no exaggeration.


The Ministry of Economy and Finance, which oversees tax policy, repeatedly emphasized the term "normalization of taxation" in its briefing on the reform plan. It labeled homes priced above 4 billion to 5 billion won, which face a steep increase in comprehensive real estate holding tax (Jongbu tax) liability, as falling within the "zone for normalization of taxation." Eliminating the 80% holding deduction for capital gains tax was described as the "normalization of capital gains tax." Reducing the basic deduction amount for non-residential homes and for multiple-property owners was explained as "normalizing excessive benefits." But what is the government's true intention in using such political rhetoric as "normalization of taxation" while intensifying the tax burden on specific classes or regions—namely, the top 0.4% nationwide, some 65,000 households?


The comprehensive real estate holding tax is a so-called "wealth tax" paid only by the top 2% to 3% of homeowners. Last year, of 15.9 million homeowners, only 480,000 paid this tax. From its inception, it was designed as a punitive tax. Drawing on the ideas of Henry George and his "Progress and Poverty"—which argued for the recapture of unearned real estate income in the public interest—the tax was born after dozens of study groups on "the public concept of land ownership." Because of this, it has even been criticized as being ideological.


The top tax rate is exceptionally high by international standards, conflicting with the tax principle of "broad base, low rate." In France, the only country in the world to have introduced a real estate wealth tax, the top rate is 1.5%. The comprehensive real estate tax’s top rate is 5%, three times higher. With this reform, even individuals owning one non-residential property will be subject to the same 5% rate as multiple-property owners, exacerbating the distortion. The tax burden has become even more heavily concentrated at the right tail (the top 0.4%).


Nevertheless, the government’s repeated appeal to "normalization of taxation" appears to be intended to justify targeted tax increases on ultra-high-priced, non-residential single-property owners—those who are the "President’s priority." If the government truly wished to normalize an abnormal tax system, it should have pursued a universal tax increase, revising property taxes as a whole, rather than focusing on targeted taxes for the top 0.4%, a bracket with low tax resistance. In Korea, property tax is excessively light in the lowest price bands. In reality, an apartment worth 200 million won in a regional city faces a property tax of 100,000 won, less than the 520,000 won automobile tax on a 2,000cc car worth 50 million won.



The reason the effective property tax rate in South Korea, as mentioned by President Lee, is so low compared to advanced economies also lies in this abnormality of a "narrow base, high rate." The government is certainly aware of this issue but, fearing the tax resistance of 15 million people, has repeatedly postponed true tax reform. Tax reform should be carried out according to the principle of fair taxation—not the President’s priorities or the authorities’ agendas.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing