Long-Term Study of 5,227 Italian Students
Lower Academic Achievement for Those Starting SNS at Ages 11–12

A recent study has found that the earlier adolescents start using social networking services (SNS), the lower their academic achievement may become later on.


According to the Guardian (UK) on August 3, Professor Marco Gui and his research team from the University of Milano-Bicocca in Italy published a paper in the international journal Nature Human Behaviour, stating that students who started using SNS at ages 11 to 12 consistently scored lower in mathematics and Italian compared to those who started later.


An AI-extracted image showing an elementary school student using a smartphone

An AI-extracted image showing an elementary school student using a smartphone

View original image

The research team analyzed the SNS usage habits and standardized test scores of 5,227 students in Italy. They also examined when the students created their first SNS account, along with their test scores in mathematics, Italian, and English.


The analysis found that students who created their first SNS accounts at ages 11 to 12 scored lower on math and Italian exams taken at ages 13 to 14, compared to students who started SNS after turning 14. This gap persisted at ages 15 to 16, with Italian scores remaining similar, but the gap in mathematics actually widening.


The research team stated, "The difference in grades between the two groups corresponds to roughly six months of learning," evaluating that, "The learning gain among students who delayed SNS use is about half the effect one might expect from costly, intensive private tutoring."


However, there was no significant difference between the two groups in English scores. The researchers explained that this may be because a substantial amount of SNS content is provided in English, naturally exposing students to the language and giving them more opportunities for practice.


This study does not prove that SNS use is a direct cause of lower grades. The team clarified that their analysis took various factors into account that could influence academic performance, including students' prior academic achievement, family composition, and parents’ level of education.


The researchers found that how frequently students checked their phones, regardless of day or night, was one of the key factors explaining the performance gap. They suggested that the habit of continuously checking SNS might decrease the level of concentration required for learning.


Professor Gui said, "SNS accessed via smartphones keeps adolescents in a constant state of alertness," adding, "The urge to keep checking what's happening online prevents them from fully focusing on tasks in real life."


He further explained, "As a result, students become less immersed in real-world spaces like home or school, and cognitively, it may become difficult to focus on activities that require sustained time and effort, such as homework."


This study comes as the UK is pushing for restrictions on SNS use by those under 16. Australia enacted similar regulations last year.


While Professor Gui supported age restrictions for SNS use, he considered an outright ban as a form of "emergency measure." He emphasized the need to make the platforms themselves safer and less addictive, stating, "We should focus on approaches that reduce the social influence SNS holds over adolescents."



Denes Vugrin, a professor of child and adolescent psychiatry at Queen Mary University of London, said that this study adds supporting evidence that the timing of a teenager’s first SNS use may impact academic development. He said, "Rather than imposing blanket bans, it is important for parents, educators, and policymakers to support adolescents in forming healthy usage habits."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing