Supreme Court: "Permanent Assistant Directors Must Receive Regular Employee Wages"
Lower Court Ruling Overturned and Remanded to Seoul High Court

The Supreme Court has ruled that, unless there are special circumstances, freelance workers who are recognized as employees after long-term work at a broadcasting company and are then converted to permanent employment contracts must be subject to the same wage system and working conditions as existing employees performing the same or similar work.

Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

According to the legal community on August 4, the Supreme Court's Third Division (Presiding Justice Lee Sook-yeon) recently overturned part of a lower court's ruling and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court in the appeal trial for confirmation of dismissal invalidity and wage claims brought by Ms. A, who had worked as an assistant director (AD) and in other roles at Chuncheon Munhwa Broadcasting Corporation (MBC) against the company.


Ms. A had worked exclusively on broadcasting production work, including assistant directing, directing, filming, and editing, at Chuncheon MBC under a freelance contract for about 11 years since 2011. However, when the company notified her in January 2022 that "the contract period is expiring," Ms. A filed a lawsuit claiming invalidity of dismissal and unpaid wages, arguing that she was an employee under the Labor Standards Act and qualified for conversion to a permanent contract under the Act on the Protection of Fixed-Term and Part-Time Employees.


Both the first and second trials recognized Ms. A's status as an employee and found the dismissal unfair. The courts held that the notice of contract expiration without written notice was invalid because Ms. A had worked exclusively under the company's direction and supervision. However, the appellate court ruled that Ms. A did not fall under the categories of 'general staff' or 'work staff' according to the company's personnel regulations, rejecting the application of the general staff wage system and ordering payment of only approximately 67.75 million won.


The Supreme Court, however, reached a different conclusion. The court ruled that, when a worker is deemed a permanent employee under the Fixed-Term Employee Act, the workplace's rules of employment and working conditions for permanent employees performing the same or similar work are applied as they are, unless there are special circumstances.



The bench explained the reason for the remand, stating, "The appellate court erred in rejecting the plaintiff's claim for additional wages without sufficiently examining whether there were general or work staff in the same department performing the same or similar work as the plaintiff, and what pay regulations applied to them." However, the determination that the dismissal of Ms. A was invalid was maintained.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing