A court has ruled that the tax authority's imposition of corporate tax on a one-person company's CEO—who processed a bonus payment amounting to 18 times his annual salary as a business expense, in order to reduce tax liability and secure cash—is justified.


On May 28, the 5th Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge: Lee Jeong-won) delivered a partial ruling in favor of the plaintiff in a lawsuit (2024GuHap76201) filed by Company A against the head of the Samsung Tax Office seeking the cancellation of the corporate tax assessment. Of the approximately 3.8 billion won tax imposed by the defendant, only about 200 million won was canceled.


The Asia Business Daily Database

The Asia Business Daily Database

View original image

[Facts]

Until around 2022, Company A had not generated significant profit. However, as a result of business investments, the company received approximately 10.5 billion won from Company C, and an additional 25 billion won from Company D as an advance service fee for development projects in 2022. In total, Company A received about 35.5 billion won that year.


On August 19, 2022, Company A paid a total of 11.75 billion won as a special bonus to CEO B—who owns 100% of Company A’s shares—and other executives and employees, and recorded this as an expense. Specifically, CEO B received 8 billion won, Deputy CEO F received 3.1 billion won, and G and other remaining executives and employees received a total of 650 million won. In addition, from April to August 2022, Company A paid CEO B a total of 7.1 billion won, spread over eight occasions, under the pretext of loans. In around March 2023, B also received 3 billion won as a dividend.


The Commissioner of the Seoul Regional Tax Office, prompted by a criminal complaint from the police, determined that "these bonuses and loans are actually distributions of the company's profits and do not qualify as deductible expenses under the Corporate Tax Act." It was also ruled that Company A failed to fulfill its withholding tax and payment reporting obligations. Accordingly, on March 11, 2024, the defendant, head of the Samsung Tax Office, imposed approximately 3.8 billion won in corporate tax (including penalties for underreporting), along with about 300 million won in earned income tax on Company A.

A Bonus 18 Times the Annual Salary? Court Rules "Not Legitimate Compensation... Subject to Taxation" View original image

[Court's Ruling (Summary)]

The court found that the taxes imposed on the bonus payments to CEO B and Deputy CEO F were justified, whereas the tax imposed on bonuses paid to G and the other employees was unlawful.


- The bonuses paid to CEO B and Deputy CEO F amounted to 18 and 11 times their annual salaries, respectively. Based solely on the evidence submitted by Company A, it is difficult to recognize these bonuses as legitimate compensation for job performance. Therefore, the bonuses paid to them constitute distributions of corporate profits rather than deductible expenses.


- The defendant, Samsung Tax Office, also concluded that the bonuses paid to G and the other employees were not compensation for work performed. However, the basis for the defendant's decision applies only to B and F. The defendant did not provide arguments or evidence showing that the bonuses received by the other employees constituted a distribution of company profits. Thus, it cannot be conclusively determined that the bonuses paid to G and the other employees exceeded legitimate compensation for their job performance.


- As for the payments made to CEO B under the pretense of loans, in substance, they were identical to bonuses distributing corporate profits. Consequently, the failure by Company A to withhold taxes and submit payment reports in relation to these bonuses provides grounds for imposing penalty taxes.



Mina Han, The Law Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing