[Bloomberg Column] The Era of AI Supremacy... America's Advantage Is Wavering View original image


The era of artificial intelligence (AI) is approaching with striking realism. Not long ago, the influence of AI on politics, warfare, and national governance was mostly hypothetical. However, today, its impact is manifesting with shocking force and speed. The technological race surrounding AI has now erupted into a new global contest for supremacy between nations.


In January of this year, the U.S. military carried out a surprise assault on Venezuela's dictator Nicolás Maduro using AI-driven tactics. Then in February and March, the United States and Israel launched intense offensives against Iran, deploying AI-based target identification and information analysis tools. In the spring, a new turning point emerged with the rise of Anthropic's AI model 'Mythos', which demonstrated superhuman cyber capabilities. The summer brought an incident that underscored deep concerns over AI safety: OpenAI's new model meticulously devised and executed a plan to break free from human control, even conducting sophisticated cyberattacks against Hugging Face, another AI company.


These developments have fostered both awe and anxiety, while also raising critical questions about how AI might reshape the global balance of power. The United States currently holds a favorable position in the worldwide AI race. However, recent technological advances in China are casting doubt on America's predominance. There are mounting concerns that China's influence, fueled by low-cost open-weight models, could rapidly spread across the globe.


The competition for AI supremacy is an extension of the historical trend where nations that led foundational technologies dominated the world. In the 19th century, Britain achieved overwhelming superiority through technologies and production methods brought about by the Industrial Revolution, ascending to become the undisputed global hegemon. In the 20th century, the United States led the way in core technologies from electrification to the internet, rising as a superpower.


Today, the outcome of global supremacy could hinge on the AI revolution. AI action plans released last year by The Trump Administration illustrate this point clearly. The plan stated, "Winning the AI race will usher in a new golden age of prosperity, economic competitiveness, and national security for Americans."


Of course, uncertainties persist. Skeptics question whether companies can leverage AI to generate results substantial enough to recoup their massive investments. There are conflicting predictions about whether more powerful and advanced forms of AI will emerge rapidly, or if technological progress will remain slow and erratic. Nevertheless, continual technological breakthroughs are steadily turning AI's potential into reality.


The significance of the global AI supremacy contest is also growing. Amid these developments, the overall competitiveness of the United States remains formidable. However, several emerging challenges could undermine America's advantage.


First, the possibility exists that America's lead in AI is narrowing. Still, one should not underestimate U.S. competitiveness. According to one ranking, U.S. companies fielded 8 of the world's top 10 models and 16 of the top 20. However, recent models from Chinese companies, such as Moonshot AI's "Kimi K3," have also seen substantial advances in performance. While it is difficult to measure exactly how far ahead the U.S. is, the gap appears to be a matter of months rather than years.


Second, the U.S. is struggling in the competition to integrate AI into the real economy and expand it worldwide. Although America's closed-source models are of the highest caliber, they are expensive. In contrast, many of China's open-weight models are offered at significantly lower cost.


Third, U.S. export controls that once supported its computational power advantage over China are weakening. In April of last year, China responded to former President Trump's sweeping tariff campaign with retaliatory tariffs and rare earth export controls, fundamentally shifting the nature of U.S.-China relations. As President Trump has prioritized reducing economic tensions and striking deals with China, the position of hardliners on technology issues within his administration has been significantly diminished.


Fourth, anxieties about AI are undermining the domestic foundations that support U.S. strategy. Concerns over job losses and safety incidents are mounting. About two-thirds of Americans believe that the pace of AI development should be slowed for safety reasons. Backlash over the construction of data centers has become a major issue in U.S. politics. There are also growing threats of violence against AI companies and entrepreneurs.


Such political conflict could affect the AI race between the U.S. and China. Divergent public opinion in America may slow the pace of cutting-edge technological progress and increase strategic burdens. On the other hand, China's authoritarian system may be better positioned to endure—or forcibly suppress—the economic and social disruptions brought about by AI innovation.


Fifth, alliance cohesion is weakening. Ideally, the U.S. and its allies would build a democratic technology bloc to maintain an edge over China and prevent the spread of AI influence. However, Washington worries about excessive European regulations, while allied nations remain wary that The Trump Administration may use its influence to pressure its partners. With European nations pushing for so-called "technological sovereignty" initiatives of questionable effectiveness, the risk of divisions within the democratic camp is rising.


The final issue is that the core infrastructure of the global AI ecosystem is exposed to military risks. U.S. AI infrastructure expansion relies heavily on advanced semiconductors produced by TSMC in Taiwan, yet most production facilities are concentrated in one of the world's most geopolitically tense regions. With Chinese pressure on Taiwan intensifying, and former President Trump delaying arms sales to Taiwan while referring to it as a "good bargaining chip" for negotiations with China, Taiwan's trust in U.S. support is wavering.


There are few ways to solve these problems at once. In AI development, speed often clashes with safety, and innovation inevitably brings economic and social shocks. However, if the U.S. fails to address or mitigate these complex problems, its technological competitiveness and geopolitical position could suffer going forward.


The core of a new strategy must be to re-strengthen export controls that underpin American superiority. Regulatory loopholes must be closed, exports of advanced semiconductors curtailed even more strictly, and the sale and maintenance of advanced semiconductor manufacturing equipment subject to additional controls. The U.S. must accept the possibility that this could reignite U.S.-China trade conflict. Simultaneously, multilateral responses are needed to reduce vulnerabilities to Chinese retaliation. The United States and its allies should secure rare earth mineral supply chains and reduce reliance on China for pharmaceutical ingredients and mature-process semiconductors.


America should also become more proactive in fostering the global spread of AI technology. It should establish rapid export-approval procedures for allies and allocate sufficient personnel and budgets to back these efforts. Financial support for AI infrastructure in emerging nations should be expanded. The alliance among democratic countries—which forms the strategic and technological basis for confronting China—must also be reinvigorated.


The U.S. must engage China in careful discussions on AI safety issues. Even without concrete results, such talks can help illuminate Beijing's approach to AI awareness and strategy. Conversely, it is essential to expand diplomatic and military support to uphold the existence of democratic Taiwan.


Domestically, America needs to alleviate job losses caused by AI and reinforce safety management systems. It must introduce transparent and consistent rules and procedures for the pre-release review of new models or for slowing the pace of AI development.


Many challenges await The Trump Administration. It has a positive direction, seeking to harness creativity and innovation from the private sector. However, there are tendencies towards cronyism and weaknesses in systematic policy-making. Turmoil within key agencies, such as the AI Standards and Innovation Center under the Department of Commerce, runs counter to demands for a stable and coherent AI regulatory framework.


AI competition and America's strategy for global supremacy have reached a critical crossroads. Much depends on whether Trump can restrain undesirable impulses within the administration during his remaining term and resolve the increasingly complex problems threatening America's path forward.


Hal Brands, Henry A. Kissinger Distinguished Professor at the Henry A. Kissinger Center for Global Affairs, Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS)



This article is a translated version by The Asia Business Daily of the Bloomberg column 'AI Is Now Power- and America's Lead Is Shrinking'.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing