[Editorial] "N% Rights" Demand "N% Responsibility": Sharing the Rewards of Booms and the Risks of Downturns Together
Buffers Needed in Wage and Employment Management
to Enable Sustainable Performance Sharing
Strengthening the Competitiveness of National Strategic Industries Like Semiconductors
Broader Protection of Managerial Authority Essential for Fut
SK hynix is expected to set aside over 20 trillion won this year for its performance-based bonus pool. This follows a labor-management agreement to allocate 10% of the company’s operating profit to bonuses. Samsung Electronics has also decided to pay 10.5% of the semiconductor division’s business performance as bonuses, with no upper limit. These groundbreaking bonus policies by both companies have sent shockwaves through South Korea’s industrial sector.
All along, The Asia Business Daily has not only examined performance bonus calculation standards, funding sources, and the contributions of partner companies through its 'What N% Bonuses Left Behind' special coverage, but also broadened the discussion to include how labor and management should share performance and risks, where to draw the line between labor rights and management authority, and whether South Korea's labor-management relationships and employment systems are sustainable. Now, this awareness must be pushed even further.
It is only natural for employees who have contributed to a company’s success to demand fair rewards. Management, in turn, must transparently disclose its bonus criteria and take responsibility for any misjudgments. However, if a fixed percentage of operating profit is distributed without an upper limit in good times, then adjustments to performance bonuses, wages, roles, and workforce arrangements must also be open for discussion in downturns. The sharing of performance and the distribution of risk are inseparably linked.
The semiconductor industry is a quintessential cyclical sector, marked by large market swings and rapid technological change. During growth phases, companies must quickly ramp up investment, while in recessions, investment pace, production scale, and workforce deployment must be adjusted flexibly. If funds reserved for future investments are instead irrevocably tied up in current bonuses and the window to adapt during downturns is effectively closed, the competitiveness of this national strategic industry could be undermined.
The latest labor-management negotiations at SK hynix illustrated these problems clearly. Management proposed introducing a flexible wage system to allow temporary wage adjustments in case of losses, but the labor union rejected this as a de facto wage cut. Of course, strict definitions of loss and clear limits on any adjustments must be in place, and management cannot shift the entire burden of business failure onto employees. If the company tries to revise the bonus agreement after just one year, workers have legitimate grounds for resistance.
Nevertheless, an attitude that refuses even to discuss risk-sharing during recessions is difficult to justify. Sharing only the profits while asking companies, shareholders, and partner firms to shoulder the losses cannot be called fair profit sharing. Should large corporate unions continue to fix their entitlements while passing burdens to others, they will only invite criticism for “vested interests and self-serving behavior” as so-called “privileged labor.”
For sustainable performance sharing, there must be buffers in wage and employment management as well. This does not mean easily granting companies the right to fire at will. Rather, it is a call to reorganize roles and redeploy the workforce in line with changing business cycles and technology trends, to adjust a portion of wages flexibly, and to strengthen pathways for reassignment, retraining, and unemployment safety nets. It is simply not possible to maintain both extravagant rewards and an inflexible wage and employment system at once. To continue offering high rewards, companies must also have the leeway to respond to downturns and technological transitions.
The amended law has heightened uncertainty by making “business decisions affecting working conditions” subject to labor disputes—meaning even managerial decisions about operating profit allocation and investment resources may be included in negotiations. Virtually all business decisions, to varying degrees, affect employees’ interests. If investment and plant site selection, business restructuring, mergers and acquisitions (M&A), and R&D direction all become subjects for negotiation and dispute simply because they have an impact, this essentially grants unions veto power over management.
The government must establish rational criteria to distinguish between the business decision itself and its specific effects on working conditions. Decisions on investment scale, production sites, and technology development direction should remain the domain and responsibility of management, while changes to work locations, working hours, safety, and compensation stemming from such decisions can be subjects for labor-management negotiations. In particular, for national strategic industries such as semiconductors, the scope of management rights must be more broadly protected. Working conditions should be earnestly discussed, but key investment decisions must be made promptly by management, who should then be held accountable for the results.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
It is time to establish the principle that “N% bonuses entail N% responsibility.” Employees should bear not just the rewards of boom times but also adapt to changes in downturns, while management must assume full responsibility consistent with their rights. The government should strengthen employment flexibility and social safety nets, while clearly delineating the boundaries of labor-management negotiations. The fundamental issues persist even after the immediate controversy subsides. Discussions about new labor-management relationships and a sustainable employment system must continue going forward.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.