Blunt Assessments from "No-Shows" to Unexcused Absences
Platform Turns into Channel for Sharing Negative Reputations
Existing Evaluations Made Private Amid Growing Controversy
Procedures for Sharing Personal Data with Third Parties Also Und

It has come to light that Albamon, a job search and recruitment platform, enabled its business members to share evaluations of job applicants and employees, raising concerns that the service could be misused as an "Albamon blacklist" that hinders job seekers’ employment opportunities. On August 3, Yonhap News reported that Albamon introduced a "Recommend" service in August last year, allowing business members to evaluate the work period and job performance of part-timers they had previously employed. This feature has become the subject of controversy over its potential use as a blacklist.

The 'Recommend' screen of Albamon business members whose subjective evaluation feature has been removed. Screenshot from SNS

The 'Recommend' screen of Albamon business members whose subjective evaluation feature has been removed. Screenshot from SNS

View original image

Initially, the service was designed so that business owners could write subjective reasons for their recommendations, which could then be referenced by other business members during the hiring process. While the intent was to share positive hiring experiences, critics argue the system effectively transformed into a channel for recording and sharing negative attendance records of job seekers, such as interview no-shows or unexcused absences.


From the perspective of business owners, some expressed that it is necessary to verify applicants’ past hiring records to mitigate losses caused by repeated interview absences and unreported absences. However, concerns remain that business owners’ subjective evaluations could be used in future recruitment processes without verification. In particular, if a business owner leaves a retaliatory comment following disputes over wages, statutory holiday allowances, or job duties, it is often difficult for job seekers to dispute or correct these claims. When unverified assessments influence hiring decisions, job seekers risk losing job opportunities without even realizing it.


Online, users have responded, asking: "Can the platform verify the facts if an employer posts a malicious review after an argument about delayed wages or holiday allowances?" and "If a business owner's unilateral evaluation is factored into the hiring process, it is essentially no different from a blacklist." As the controversy grew, Albamon suspended the subjective evaluation feature of the "Recommend" service on July 27. Previously written comments were also made private so that neither job seekers nor corporate members could view them.


According to Albamon, job seekers whose evaluations had been submitted could view the content from their resume management menus and raise issues via a reporting function or customer center if they had objections. Experts, however, said that it is not enough to merely suspend the feature; the platform must also publicly disclose how evaluation information is collected, shared, and how previously collected data will be handled.



Kim Sunghee, Director of the Industrial Labor Policy Research Institute, stated, "Even if it is a feature intended for the convenience of business owners, if negative assessments are accumulated and used, this will exacerbate information asymmetry in the labor market." Kim stressed, "Since it can unjustly restrict job seekers’ chances of employment, an official apology and corrective action to prevent recurrence are necessary." Kim Kibum, attorney at Workplace Gapjil 119, said, "If negative reviews are collected and shared to exclude specific job seekers from hiring, this could qualify as employment obstruction under the Labor Standards Act. There are also procedural issues to consider when providing personal data to third parties." He further emphasized, "Job seekers should be able to view their own evaluations and request corrections or deletions of false or malicious content. Platforms must disclose who wrote the evaluation, the extent of disclosure, and the retention period for such information, while also ensuring adequate procedures for job seekers to explain their side." A representative from Albamon stated, "We will continue to review user feedback and improve our service to provide a trustworthy job search and recruitment environment in line with relevant laws and operational guidelines."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing