Tricking Consumers with "Free Gifts" Leads to Triple Overcharges
Settlement Acceptance Could Expand Relief to Non-Participating Victims

An alarm has been sounded over the so-called “funeral service bundled product” sales tactic, in which customers are misled into believing that electronic appliances are provided free of charge when signing up for a funeral service contract, only to discover that they are saddled with installment payments far exceeding the actual value of those goods. Following an investigation by consumer dispute authorities, an official ruling has been issued stating that not only the funeral service provider but also Lotte Rental—the company supplying the electronics and managing the installment contracts—cannot be exempt from liability for improper sales practices.

“Free Gift” Turns Out to Be Triple-Priced Trap... Lotte Rental Ordered to Cut Installment Payments by 30% for Improper Sales Practices View original image

On August 2, the Consumer Dispute Mediation Committee of the Korea Consumer Agency announced that, in relation to Lotte Rental's pre-paid installment (funeral service) linked electronics purchase agreements, it had issued a group dispute mediation decision requiring Lotte Rental, the vendor in question, to reduce consumers’ total installment payments by 30%.


The incident began when consumers entered into contracts after believing sales staff who claimed, “You’ll receive electronics for free when you sign up for the funeral service.” In reality, however, the structure involved Lotte Rental separately arranging high-cost installment contracts for electronics—up to three times higher than their market prices—separate from the funeral service contract. As a result, 221 affected consumers applied for group dispute mediation and demanded compensation.


During the investigation, Lotte Rental argued that it bore no legal responsibility because it was “not involved in guiding customers to believe appliances were free or providing verbal explanations at the sales site.”


However, the committee took a different view. The committee recognized the two agreements as closely linked based on several factors: the installment purchase contracts explicitly referenced “funeral service” in the product name, and consumers could not purchase the electronics separately without also signing up for the funeral service. The committee also noted that Lotte Rental, having delegated sales tasks under a business management contract and holding authority to supervise and monitor customer confirmation calls (“happy calls”), should have been fully aware of the risk of improper sales practices but failed to prevent them. This constituted a grave responsibility.


Nevertheless, the committee factored in that consumers had already received and used electronic appliances worth more than 1 million won, as well as the need to promptly resolve the dispute, and decided to mediate by reducing Lotte Rental’s claims for installment payments by 30%.



This decision is expected to have a significant impact on the entire distribution and rental industry, as it sets a clear precedent for the management and oversight responsibility of product suppliers and rental companies in cases of improper bundled product sales. If both parties accept the mediation proposal within 15 days of receiving the decision notice, the agreement will have the same legal effect as a settlement in court. Should Lotte Rental accept the mediation proposal, the same reduction in payment obligations may be applied to other victims who did not participate in the current group mediation process.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing