Samil PwC Releases Fifth Volume of the Board of Directors Guide

As employee performance bonuses have become a significant factor in corporate capital allocation, experts are suggesting that boards of directors should oversee not only CEO compensation but also employee performance incentives as a whole.


Samil PwC: "Employee Performance Bonuses Should Be Addressed as a Board Agenda Item" View original image

On July 31, the Samil PwC Governance Center announced the publication of the fifth volume of its “Board of Directors Guide” series, which contains expert advice for the boards of domestic companies in its “Governance Focus Issue No. 37.” In this issue, Professor Shin Jaeyong of the Seoul National University Business School contributed a column titled “Compensation is Strategy, Not Money,” highlighting the board’s role and oversight principles for executive and employee compensation.


According to the column, the fundamental question boards should ask regarding compensation is not about who receives it or how much, but rather, “Which behaviors should be rewarded to encourage those actions?” The purpose of compensation must be clearly defined, choosing among three goals: talent acquisition, talent retention, or motivation.


He also noted that benchmark groups (peer groups) for evaluating compensation competitiveness should not be selected solely based on size. Professor Shin stated, “A broad range of factors—such as business model, business complexity, global market presence, and labor market—must be considered.” He added, “Instead of comparing companies with similar revenues or assets, it is more appropriate to benchmark firms that compete for talent in the same labor market.”


The column advised against excessive reliance on short-term financial performance indicators for performance evaluation. Solely using financial metrics cannot fully explain a company’s competitiveness; reducing research and development investment to boost short-term profits can undermine future competitiveness. Professor Shin explained, “Leading companies use non-financial indicators that reflect strategic execution alongside financial performance. Representative examples include customer satisfaction, product quality, innovation outcomes, safety, retention rates of key talent, and organizational culture.” However, he cautioned, “The crucial point is that non-financial indicators must be directly linked to the company's strategy.”


He also emphasized that short-term incentives (STI) and long-term incentives (LTI) should be considered complementary, not substitutes. While short-term incentives are effective in driving annual management targets, long-term incentives contribute to consistently increasing corporate value. He proposed designing compensation timing to promote long-term performance by assessing the sustainability of results. Additionally, he suggested that companies should utilize clawback policies that allow the reduction or cancellation of bonuses for executives or employees who cause loss or damage to the company’s reputation.


Professor Shin reiterated that employee performance bonuses also fall under the board's supervisory responsibilities. He emphasized, “Employee bonuses based on profit-sharing are key capital allocation decisions for a company. The basic principles and philosophy of calculating employee bonuses, their financial sustainability, and the balance between shareholders (capital) and employees (labor) must all be monitored by the board of directors.”


He further asserted that CEO compensation and employee bonuses should be approached within a unified compensation system. He explained, “If the CEO is tasked with driving long-term growth while employees are only rewarded for short-term performance, the organization will move in different directions. Companies that apply consistent principles to both management and staff achieve alignment between strategy and corporate culture.”


Shin Wangun, Head of the Samil PwC Governance Center, stated, “Compensation is a key governance issue that determines a company’s long-term value,” emphasizing, “Boards should take a more systematic and professional approach to executive and employee compensation.”



Meanwhile, Samil PwC publishes a monthly “Board of Directors Guide” series, composed of contributions from both academia and practitioners. More information can be found on the Samil PwC Governance Center website.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing