Grammy Submission Rejected Over Creation of "Asian Pop" Category

[Reporter’s Notebook] BTS Boycotts Grammys Over 'Hangul Category' View original image

"I hope that music is heard and loved as it is, not divided by region or language."


BTS refused to submit an entry to the U.S. Grammy Awards this year. The group was protesting the Recording Academy’s creation of the new "Best Asian Pop Music Performance" category. While promoting diversity, the Academy’s idea of grouping only Asian music into a separate category came into question. The distinction—calling it global pop when sung in English, and "Asian pop" when sung in an Asian language—lacks persuasiveness.


The Grammys established this category last month. The eligible works are pop music that either originated from or gained significant recognition in the Asian market, and which meaningfully feature one or more Asian languages. However, K-pop, J-pop, and C-pop each have different industry structures and musical roots. Grouping them by region and language rather than musical genre or tradition, as is done with jazz or country, is inevitably criticized as a Western-centric perspective.


The day after BTS’s announcement, Recording Academy CEO Harvey Mason Jr. explained that entries for the Asian pop category are also eligible to compete in general fields such as Album of the Year, Record of the Year, and Song of the Year, emphasizing there was no intent to segregate music. However, regardless of intent, the message the public receives is different.


BTS has been nominated for a Grammy five times but has never won. From 2020 to 2022, the group performed on the Grammys stage three years in a row, boosting ratings, but never took home a trophy. In such circumstances, the introduction of an Asian pop category may be perceived as a signal to "be satisfied" with a special award rather than a main one.


BTS, however, has little to regret. Their fifth full-length album, "Arirang", topped the Billboard main album chart for three consecutive weeks, and the included track "Swim" also reached number one on the singles chart. Their world tour, spanning 79 performances in 34 cities, sold out stadiums across the United States and Europe, reaffirming K-pop’s status. K-pop is no longer just regional music—it is now a pillar of global popular music.


The Grammys earned their global prestige by establishing trust that transcends nationality and language in evaluating good music. However, if the standards of the awards fall behind the pace of change in the music market, their authority is bound to waver.


This is not the first Grammy boycott by a global pop star. The Weeknd also refused to submit entries in 2021, criticizing the lack of transparency in the nomination process, after which the Recording Academy abolished anonymous selection committees. It showed that systems can change through criticism.



The Recording Academy must thoroughly consult with the Asian music industry and re-examine both the category’s name and eligibility criteria. It must clearly state in its regulations that submissions in the Asian pop category are judged in the general field without any disadvantage, and it must publicly release transparent information on submissions, nominations, and winners. If this category ultimately becomes a substitute boundary rather than a pathway to the general awards, then the criteria should be revised or the category should be abolished entirely. Music must be evaluated for its artistry, not by nationality.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing