Assets of the Seven Major Pension and Mutual Aid Associations Reach Two-Thirds of GDP
"Short CIO Tenures, Limited Talent Pool Pose Challenges"
"Vulnerable to External Interference"—Governance in Question
Market Volatility Distorts Allocatio

Editor's NotePension funds and mutual aid associations have long established themselves as key players in the capital markets. While the primary roles of pension funds (securing citizens' retirement) and mutual aid associations (expanding members’ assets and welfare) are fundamentally different, they also stand apart in terms of asset size, investment strategies, and organizational structures. This series provides an in-depth analysis of pension funds and mutual aid associations, which are also major sources of funding for institutional investors at home and abroad.

#Several years ago, a global investment bank decided to exit the Korean asset management sector. Upon hearing the news, the then-chairman of the National Pension Service canceled a scheduled lunch meeting with the bank's senior executives in New York. It could have been considered a significant breach of etiquette. Not long after, the bank’s headquarters dispatched its vice chairman to Korea with an urgent mandate: "Appease the National Pension Service."


This episode demonstrates how the power and influence of Korea’s pension funds and mutual aid associations have grown on the global stage. The National Pension Service manages 1,500 trillion won, Korea Teachers’ Credit Union 85 trillion won, Private School Teachers’ Pension 30 trillion won, Korea Local Finance Association 33 trillion won, Korea Military Mutual Aid Association 24 trillion won, Government Employees Pension Service 12 trillion won, and Police Mutual Aid Association 8 trillion won. As of the end of last year, the combined assets under management (AUM) of these seven major institutions reached around 1,700 trillion won. When reflecting on returns for the first half of this year, the total likely exceeds 2,000 trillion won. This is equivalent to two-thirds of last year’s nominal GDP for Korea, which stood at 2,663.3 trillion won.

[Fund & Mutual Aid Association Analysis]①2000 Trillion Won Mega-Sized K-Money, Governance With a Short-Term Focus View original image

Their investment performance has also set records. Last year, the National Pension Service posted a return of 18.82%—its highest since 2000—and as of May this year, it recorded 26.18%. The other institutions have seen similar results: Private School Teachers’ Pension returns topped 23% in the first half; Korea Teachers’ Credit Union posted an annualized 18.4% in the second quarter; and the Government Employees Pension Service achieved a 15.6% return through May.


However, their absolute size and returns alone do not tell the whole story. Amid amendments to the Commercial Act, expanded proxy voting, and ongoing friction over the appointment of chief investment officers (CIOs), the question of "who makes the decisions" has become just as important as "where to invest." As domestic and global stock markets experience sharp rises and falls, performance gaps between asset classes have widened. The alternative investment market, in particular, has not enjoyed the boom of years past, prompting institutions to reconsider whether to maintain traditional asset allocation ratios or adjust them to fit current market conditions. The share of overseas assets already exceeds half of holdings. As it becomes common knowledge that “good deals in private equity and alternative investments are found on the ground," Korean institutions are increasingly moving their own investment teams overseas, rather than solely entrusting funds to global asset managers.


The Asia Business Daily’s analysis of seven pensions and mutual aid associations reveals that the dominant themes for this year and next are governance, rebalancing, and globalization.


 From Proxy Voting to CIO Appointments... The Growing Importance of 'Governance'

[Fund & Mutual Aid Association Analysis]①2000 Trillion Won Mega-Sized K-Money, Governance With a Short-Term Focus View original image

Governance has become particularly prominent this year. Beginning with the March regular shareholders’ meetings, the National Pension Service broadened the scope of its pre-disclosed proxy voting decisions to include all proposals at companies where it holds a stake of 5% or more. The rate of opposition votes also climbed to more than 23%, approaching triple the domestic asset management industry average of 8.2%. This development by the National Pension Service could influence the decision-making processes of other funds and mutual aid associations. In conjunction with amendments to the Commercial Act mandating cumulative voting, pension funds and mutual aid associations have now become much more than just sources of capital—they are entering a new phase of direct engagement in corporate governance.


Internal governance, too, is under scrutiny. After Jeon Beomsik stepped down as CIO of the Private School Teachers’ Pension to become head of fund management at the National Federation of Fisheries Cooperatives, Baek Juhyun (former CIO at Government Employees Pension Service) filled the vacancy. Former CIOs from various pensions and mutual aid associations comprised a large portion of the candidate pool for the next head of the National Pension Service's investment division. The Police Mutual Aid Association addressed a 2-year, 8-month vacancy by appointing Kang Seungo, previously of Shinhan Investment & Securities, as CIO in June. During this vacancy, the share of idle, short-term cash—uninvested in either stocks or bonds—rose to 21.5%.


Observers note that abbreviated terms and a narrow talent pool are inherent weaknesses. Typically, CIOs at Korean pension funds and mutual aid associations serve for two years, with the possibility of annual extensions based on performance—a system in stark contrast to, for instance, the 24-year tenure of CalSTRS’ former CIO in the U.S., or the 20-year tenure at AustralianSuper.


One private equity firm CEO stated, "Investment decisions are driven not just by financial data, but by information gained through personal relationships and networks. When CIO turnovers are frequent, as is the case in Korea, it can quickly lead to fatigue for asset managers." This concern is not limited to Korea. According to him, "During meetings with overseas asset managers, they often ask, 'Why do the faces of Korean limited partners change so frequently?'" The underlying philosophy for fund management is long-term investment, but paradoxically, those responsible for developing and executing these strategies are only afforded very short tenures.


[Fund & Mutual Aid Association Analysis]①2000 Trillion Won Mega-Sized K-Money, Governance With a Short-Term Focus View original image

The length of terms is also intertwined with investment characteristics. "If the term is short, the investment philosophy breaks down and risk management systems become unstable," he said. "This is especially disadvantageous for asset classes like alternatives, where results can take years to materialize." He later added, "When a successor is appointed, they often overturn their predecessor's strategies before results appear, breaking the continuity of investment execution."


This structure is also seen as amplifying market-wide herd behavior. According to an investment banking source, "Most domestic CIOs are compelled to seek roles at other institutions after their terms, so it’s difficult for them to make creative or independent decisions that go against the prevailing market consensus." He added, "If a decision fails along with others, there’s collective responsibility; but if a CIO makes an unorthodox call and fails alone, the risk of being excluded from the market rises dramatically."


The collective rush by pension funds and mutual aid associations into overseas real estate around 2018, followed by substantial losses, is often cited as a typical example. The source noted, "Although the size and nature of these institutions differ greatly, the basic fund management structures are not all that different."


Some also criticize the appointment processes themselves. Another private equity CEO commented, "Every organization claims to work 'for the people and members' and prioritizes 'performance,' but I still question whether the investment return is truly seen as the top priority. During chairman and CIO appointment seasons, there is always a surge in people seeking political favors." This stands in contrast to the independent, board-centered governance structures at overseas institutions, which are largely immune to changes in political administration. For example, last month, the selection process for the next CIO of Korea Investment Corporation (KIC) was sent back to square one after transparency concerns surfaced. Speculation about predetermined candidates before the interviews caused, for the first time since the agency’s 2005 founding, the open recruitment process to be scrapped.


Principle or Flexibility? The 'Rebalancing' Test Intensifies


This year, the National Pension Service has been at the center of debates over not just proxy voting, but also asset allocation.


In the first half of the year, the National Pension Service temporarily suspended mechanical rebalancing—the automatic selling of domestic equities exceeding target allocations—from January through June. This pause was intended to prioritize returns and minimize market disruptions. Yet, during the same period, foreign investors net sold 154 trillion won of KOSPI shares and took profits, while pension fund net sales were limited to about 9 trillion won. Although investment returns reached record highs, realized profits remained limited.


One private equity CEO remarked, "During the stock market surge in the first half, there was an opportunity to maximize returns through rebalancing while still adhering to principles, but it was not implemented." He also pointed out that "market rumor had it that political events, like the June local elections, influenced decision-making. If so, then rebalancing is not only an operational issue but also a governance one."


The approach to rebalancing differs by institution. The Government Employees Pension Service aims to keep bonds, stocks, and alternatives in a 1:1:1 ratio, but the bull market in equities tilted this to 2:3:1. Restoring the alternative investment allocation in the second half of the year is a key objective. The Korea Teachers’ Credit Union has reduced exposure to real estate equity and senior loans while increasing allocations to infrastructure and bonds. The Korea Local Finance Association decided to mitigate concentration risk by preventing any single asset class from dominating overall performance, thereby reducing portfolio volatility.


Although overshadowed by equity performance, alternatives remain a vital investment area. The Korea Military Mutual Aid Association announced a mid-term plan to increase its allocation to alternatives from 74.8% at the end of last year to 84.8% by 2030. The Police Mutual Aid Association also set a goal to raise the share of alternatives from 51.0% to 64.1% this year.


The Era of 60% Overseas Allocation... Followed by Organizational Relocation

[Fund & Mutual Aid Association Analysis]①2000 Trillion Won Mega-Sized K-Money, Governance With a Short-Term Focus View original image

As of the second quarter of this year, 61.1% (44.6187 trillion won) of the Korea Teachers’ Credit Union’s assets are allocated abroad. This has risen from 55.3% in 2022, 56.1% in 2023, and 58.2% in 2024—far surpassing the domestic portion (38.9%). Other institutions are following suit: the Private School Teachers’ Pension is expanding its overseas alternative portfolio; the Korea Local Finance Association is diversifying into Japan and Australia, planning a phased increase in Asia-Pacific allocations across private credit, real estate, infrastructure, and listed equities; and the Government Employees Pension Service has increased overseas alternatives through joint investments alongside TIAA (Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America).


Just as significant as capital flows are changes in staffing and organizational structures. Moving beyond simply entrusting money to global managers, Korean institutions are now actively seeking deal-sourcing and joint ventures on site. The Korea Teachers’ Credit Union is preparing to open a New York office this year. The National Pension Service is considering establishing its fifth overseas office, possibly in China or India. Additionally, in July, Korea Investment Corporation (KIC) launched a Tokyo branch, marking its sixth overseas outpost. An investment banking source commented, "Overseas offices are not expenses—they are an investment infrastructure that enhances returns."


The three key trends—governance, rebalancing, and globalization—are evident in all seven institutions. However, the specific situations vary. For example, the Korea Military Mutual Aid Association reported a net income return of 7.4% last year based on its income statement, but a comprehensive income return of 13.4%. The share of alternatives also differs depending on whether it is measured against total assets (46.2%) or investment assets (74.8%). Even the same indicators may yield different figures and implications depending on the criteria, so each institution must be examined individually.



<Fund and Mutual Aid Association In-Depth Series Order>

② National Pension Service

③ Korea Teachers’ Credit Union

④ Private School Teachers’ Pension

⑥ Korea Local Finance Association

⑦ Korea Military Mutual Aid Association

⑧ Police Mutual Aid Association


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing