Comparison of the Ministry's Draft and Legislative Review
Cluster Designation Principle Altered Again
"Priority Consideration" Replaces Preferential Treatment for Non-Metropolitan Regions
Concerns Over Retreat from Balanced National Development

[Exclusive] Government Retracts 'Metropolitan Area Exclusion'... Non-Metropolitan 'Preferential Treatment' in Semiconductor Special Act Enforcement Decree Changed to 'Priority Consideration' View original image

It has been confirmed that the government once again revised the regional support principle during the process of preparing the enforcement decree for the Special Act on Semiconductors, which is set to take effect next month. The government, which had originally excluded the Seoul metropolitan area from support, withdrew this stance following protests from areas like the Yongin National Industrial Complex and Incheon. Furthermore, the principle of “non-metropolitan area preference” included in the draft notice was also eased during the Ministry of Government Legislation's review process to merely “priority consideration.” As the principle of supporting non-metropolitan areas is continuously relaxed, concerns have been raised that the original intent of the special law to promote balanced national development may be undermined.


Policy Revised Once Due to Metropolitan Area Protests... and Adjusted Again During Legislation Review

According to a comparison obtained by The Asia Business Daily on July 30, between the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy’s legislative notice draft and the version reviewed by the Ministry of Government Legislation for the “Enforcement Decree on Strengthening Competitiveness and Support for the Semiconductor Industry,” the standard for designating semiconductor clusters was changed from “non-metropolitan areas shall be given preference” to “areas outside the metropolitan region shall be given priority consideration.”


While “preference” strongly implies that non-metropolitan areas would receive extra points or differential support during the designation or support process, “priority consideration” essentially means that non-metropolitan areas should be reviewed first as one of several factors. Legally, both are mandatory provisions, but both the legal and administrative fields generally interpret “preference” as a much stronger policy commitment.


Compared to the initial draft, which entirely excluded the metropolitan area from designation, the legislative notice phase adjusted the direction to include the metropolitan area but put more weight on the non-metropolitan areas. During the Ministry of Government Legislation’s review, this was further relaxed to broaden the administrative body's discretion.


An official from the Ministry of Industry, who has frequently been involved in lawmaking, explained, “‘Priority consideration’ is certainly still a legal obligation, but it gives the authority greater discretionary scope than ‘preference,’” and added, “‘Preference’ is generally regarded as a stronger expression of intent to support non-metropolitan areas.”


[Exclusive] Government Retracts 'Metropolitan Area Exclusion'... Non-Metropolitan 'Preferential Treatment' in Semiconductor Special Act Enforcement Decree Changed to 'Priority Consideration' View original image

Regions Say “Intent of Balanced Development Fading”... Concerns About Impact on Semiconductor Competition

This enforcement decree has been at the center of regional conflict since its drafting. After the Special Act on Semiconductors passed the National Assembly, the government began working on the accompanying lower-level regulations and clarified the requirements for designating semiconductor clusters. The initial draft, developed through consultations among relevant ministries, effectively limited cluster designation exclusively to areas outside the metropolitan region.


Immediate backlash erupted in Yongin—which is home to the world’s largest advanced system semiconductor cluster under construction—and Incheon, which is promoting the development of post-processing, components, and materials industries. They argued that excluding the metropolitan area from support solely based on location was inconsistent with the law’s objective of strengthening national semiconductor competitiveness. In particular, Gyeonggi-do noted that all domestic semiconductor production bases—Yongin, Pyeongtaek, Hwaseong, and Icheon—are located in the metropolitan area; it argued, “Excluding the metropolitan area would result in undermining the competitiveness of the semiconductor ecosystem itself,” and called on the government to revise the enforcement decree. Incheon City also reportedly conveyed that, given its free economic zone and plans for a Songdo bio/semiconductor cluster, a blanket exclusion of the metropolitan region would be unreasonable.


Ultimately, during the legislative notice process, the government deleted the clause excluding the metropolitan area and opted for a compromise. The new principle stipulated that “non-metropolitan areas shall be given preference” in cluster designation and support. The intention was to include the metropolitan area as a possible designation target, yet to provide a stronger legal basis for more active support for non-metropolitan areas in the interest of balanced national development.


However, with the Ministry of Government Legislation review further softening even the preference principle to “priority consideration,” there are criticisms that the underlying aim of balanced national development embedded in the special law has been somewhat undermined. For regions outside the metropolitan area, the biggest policy incentive for the special law could now be diluted. An official from a non-metropolitan local government remarked, “Attracting semiconductor companies is directly linked to the future industrial base of the region, so we expected the non-metropolitan area preference clause to be not just symbolic, but a substantial policy basis. By easing the provision to simple priority consideration, we are concerned that the distinction non-metropolitan regions can actually feel during cluster designation or government support processes could diminish.”


Coordinator from National Heritage Administration Added to Committee, and Major Revisions to Infrastructure Regulations

A representative from the Ministry of Government Legislation commented, “In the review process, we judged that the term ‘non-metropolitan area preference’ was somewhat ambiguous and consulted with the Ministry of Industry. The Ministry confirmed that, in substance, the intent was to give priority consideration to areas outside the metropolitan region when designating semiconductor clusters, so we revised the wording for clarity.” The official continued, “Both expressions share the same legislative intent—to give first consideration to areas outside the metropolitan region—and the change was not meant to expand administrative discretion or relax the regulations.”


Meanwhile, the enforcement decree underwent significant revisions beyond just the regional support principle during this review. The original draft’s 46 articles were reorganized into 41, and the head of the National Heritage Administration was newly added as an ex officio member to the Semiconductor Industry Coordination Committee. This reflects the frequent need to address cultural heritage surveys and preservation during the construction of semiconductor clusters. Furthermore, the scale and ratio of infrastructure support were made subject to enhanced procedures, requiring the Minister of Industry to consult relevant provincial or municipal governors and then coordinate with the Minister of Strategy and Finance.


The regulations regarding infrastructure redundancy were also changed. While the draft notice explicitly listed wastewater treatment, gas and chemical supply, and information communication networks in addition to power and water grids, the final reviewed version newly added roads and designated the rest of the facilities according to the Minister of Industry’s notification. This is interpreted as a move to allow for flexible policy implementation in response to changing circumstances, rather than specifying detailed facilities in the enforcement decree.



The government plans to submit the final version of the enforcement decree, after concluding the Ministry of Government Legislation’s review, to the Vice Ministerial Meeting and the Cabinet Meeting soon. Following the President’s approval and official promulgation, the enforcement decree is expected to come into effect together with the Special Act on Semiconductors on August 11.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing