Supplementary Investigation Powers Abolished, Countermeasures Included
New "Fact Verification" Procedure Introduced for Prosecutors
Statements Obtained Cannot Be Used as Evidence
Additional Grounds for Dismissal of Prosecution
"Dismissal Determinations Take Priority, Raising Concerns of Judicial Delays and Resource Drain"

The amendment to the Criminal Procedure Act scheduled for the National Assembly plenary session by the Democratic Party of Korea on July 30 includes additional provisions such as allowing prosecutors to verify facts through interviews and set deadlines for responding to supplementary investigation requests, instead of a total abolition of the supplementary investigation authority. However, the legal community has raised concerns about its effectiveness. There is additional criticism that a new clause, which was not originally a point of contention—"dismissal of prosecution for illegal investigations"—was unexpectedly inserted, leading to claims that this is a "shield law" aimed at protecting President Lee Jaemyung in related cases.

Ruling Party's Criminal Procedure Act Amendment Includes "Prosecutor Interviews" and Expanded "Prosecution Dismissal"... Effectiveness Questioned View original image

The core of the amendment is the abolition of both direct investigations and supplementary investigations by deleting Article 196, the basis for prosecutors' investigative powers. While prosecutors can request supplementary investigations from the police, they cannot conduct supplementary investigations themselves or summon suspects and witnesses for questioning for investigative purposes.


In principle, the police must complete the requested supplementary investigation within one month from the date of the request, although the deadline can be extended by up to one more month for justifiable reasons. Prosecutors will monitor compliance while maintaining the case number, and they will be able to request removal from duty or disciplinary action against police officers who fail to fulfill these requests without valid reason. If adequate investigation cannot be expected from the initial investigating agency, a superior agency or a different investigative body may be designated.


A new "fact verification" procedure has also been introduced, allowing prosecutors to hear opinions or accept materials from suspects, people related to the case, or experts, when determining whether to prosecute, call for reinvestigation, or maintain prosecution. Complainants, reporters, and victims may apply for interviews, with acceptance subject to the prosecutor's discretion. However, statements and materials obtained in this process cannot be used as evidence in court.


The legal community criticizes that interviews lacking enforcement and evidentiary power are insufficient to fill investigational gaps. One chief prosecutor stated, "The results of interviews would do nothing more than strengthen the prosecutor's personal conviction, and if participants refuse to answer questions and only speak of personal grievances, the process could degenerate into a marketplace-like argument with the prosecutor."


There is also concern that requests for supplementary investigation will be ineffectual if the police only fulfill them in formality. Naegeon Kwon, an attorney at Law Firm Trinity Partners, pointed out, "If the police investigate request items only superficially, it cannot be considered non-fulfillment simply because the outcome is inadequate, so disciplinary requests cannot serve as an effective control mechanism."


Concerns have been raised that case processing could be delayed. An attorney who formerly served as a prosecutor said, "Even if new information is confirmed via an interview, additional evidence must still be obtained through a new supplementary investigation request to the police," adding, "Because evidence such as phone records or CCTV footage can disappear with time, victims may be further disadvantaged."


The provisions considered most problematic are Articles 327(2) and (3) of the amendment, which expand the grounds for "prosecution dismissal." The ruling party added to the court's grounds for dismissal cases where prosecutions are based on serious illegal investigations or where prosecutors have grossly abused their prosecutorial discretion. A lawyer and former chief prosecutor noted, "This shift will move the focus from substantive judgments on guilt or innocence to procedural disputes over dismissal, potentially leading to trial delays and unnecessary expenditure of judicial resources." He further remarked, "While defendants will have unlimited grounds to claim for dismissal, victims will face longer delays for redress, and there is a risk this could be used as grounds for future withdrawal of prosecution."



A judge from the Seoul Central District Court commented, "Under current law, judges have limited and clear grounds for dismissal, making decisions straightforward. But the additional grounds now lack clarity, so they will eventually require a Constitutional Court ruling, which will only prolong proceedings; it also runs afoul of the 'principle of clarity,' raising constitutional concerns."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing