HUG Fails to Refund Guarantee Fees to Tenants, Undercharges Specific Companies
Regular Audit by the Board of Audit and Inspection
Refunds Missed for 1,699 Cases of Duplicate Guarantees
Tenant Share Not Returned in 454 Guarantee Claims
Historical Credit Ratings Applied in Violation of Internal Rules
3.82 Billion W
The Korea Housing & Urban Guarantee Corporation (HUG) failed to refund a total of 17.3 million won in guarantee fees to tenants who held duplicate subscriptions for rental guarantees and Jeonse deposit guarantees. In contrast, it was found that HUG received 2.77 billion won less in guarantee fees from a specific corporate landlord by applying a previously higher credit rating in violation of its internal regulations. Criticism has surfaced that the public agency responsible for protecting the deposit funds of ordinary citizens has neglected tenant rights while granting exceptions outside of regulations to select corporate clients.
On July 30, the Board of Audit and Inspection (BAI) released the results of its "Regular Audit of the Korea Housing & Urban Guarantee Corporation," revealing these issues. The BAI identified 13 matters requiring stronger management, as well as six violations or unjust issues. In total, 20 corrective actions were recommended, including disciplinary measures for related personnel.
HUG allows both rental guarantee (for landlords) and Jeonse deposit guarantee (for tenants) to be purchased for the same lease contract. If the duplicate Jeonse deposit guarantee is canceled, the guarantee fee corresponding to the overlap must be refunded to the tenant. However, HUG only issued refunds when tenants themselves requested contract termination. Contracts that ended automatically at the end of the guarantee period were excluded from refunds.
The BAI reviewed 18,427 canceled duplicate Jeonse deposit guarantees between 2021 and the end of June 2025, confirming that in 1,699 cases, a total of 17.3 million won in guarantee fees was not returned to tenants. Tenants bear 25% of the rental guarantee fee; even after a guarantee incident, the tenant’s share of the fee was not refunded. Of 471 guarantee incidents occurring under duplicate contracts during the same period, 454 were resolved through Jeonse deposit guarantees. In these cases, rental guarantees were not actually used, yet tenants were not reimbursed the fees they had paid for those guarantees.
Meanwhile, there were also instances where internal regulations were bypassed to reduce guarantee fees for certain corporate clients. HUG is required to calculate the guarantee fee rate using the company’s credit rating on the date the guarantee certificate is issued. The credit rating of one corporate rental business fell from AA to BB+ in May 2025, and the guarantee fee rate should have increased accordingly.
According to the BAI, the company concerned claimed that the review process had dragged on, causing the credit downgrade, and requested that HUG apply its previous AA rating from the time of the guarantee application. Senior executives at HUG, including the general manager and division head, prepared a response allowing regional branches to apply the past credit rating, providing a basis for handling the matter contrary to regulations.
As a result, HUG applied the previous AA credit rating to 12,752 units, rather than the current rating. While 3.63 billion won should have been collected as guarantee fees, only 860 million won was obtained, resulting in 2.77 billion won in under-collection. The BAI recommended disciplinary action of at least a light penalty for the relevant division head and general manager to the HUG president.
The review of Project Financing (PF) guarantees was also found to be inadequate. Development companies submitted materials with arbitrarily adjusted construction payment schedules to inflate their Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR), and HUG accepted these figures at face value. As a result, 382 billion won in PF guarantees was approved for three sites that would have been denied if proper screening had taken place. For two of those sites, review grades were miscalculated, causing 1.64 billion won less in guarantee fees to be collected. The BAI notified HUG to develop measures to recover the insufficiently collected fees.
There were also gaps in HUG's debt collection work following guarantee incidents. Over the past five years, HUG has paid out 15 trillion won on behalf of guarantee holders, but 12 trillion won remains uncollected. The BAI audited the property investigations of seven regional management centers in 2024 and found that, out of 9,003 target debtors, there was no record of property investigations for 2,915 individuals. The implementation rate of property investigations varied enormously between centers, from 21.6% at the Northern Seoul Center to 99.8% at the Western Seoul Center, but oversight by headquarters was inadequate.
Cases were also found where large amounts of debt recovery were delayed due to an inability to identify heirs of deceased debtors. Among deceased debtors with debts over 1 billion won, 1,541 billion won in debt recovery procedures was delayed because the heirs of nine individuals had not been identified.
Efforts to manage landlords who failed to purchase guarantee coverage were effectively meaningless. In a sample survey in the Busan area, there were 6,431 rental homes that became liable for fines due to the failure to renew rental guarantee coverage despite ongoing lease contracts, but only 45 such homes were actually fined. This was because HUG only notified local governments of guarantee cancellations, but not whether the relevant contracts were under review for renewal, making it difficult for local governments to identify non-compliant landlords.
The criteria for levying fines also lacked fairness. For example, in Busan, a corporate landlord with 69 properties lacking rental guarantees was fined 6.5 million won, whereas an individual landlord with only one uncovered property was fined 18.5 million won.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
In response, the BAI directed HUG to establish a system for refunding unreturned guarantee fees to tenants and to strengthen procedures for debt recovery, including property investigations and the attachment of financial assets. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport was instructed to revise the relevant enforcement decree to impose fines in proportion to the number of uninsured dwellings, and to improve systems so that HUG can obtain information on heirs and properties of deceased debtors.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.