Competitor Closures Drive Significant Spillover Benefits

There are expectations in the securities industry that Emart’s corporate value will rise as a result of Homeplus, a competitor, suspending its operations.


According to Hana Securities on July 30, research analyst Park Jongdae initiated coverage the previous day with a "Buy" investment rating and a target price of 110,000 won, stating, "The closure of competitor stores is driving up same-store sales growth at discount retailers."

Q2 Operating Profit Forecast at 61 Billion Won

First, the shutdown of Homeplus operations is translating into revenue growth for Emart. Analyst Park explained, "With the closure of 59 Homeplus stores, sales at nearby Emart locations have increased by 10%, resulting in a 2 percentage-point improvement in overall same-store sales growth. As all Homeplus stores suspend operations starting in July, same-store sales growth at discount retailers is expected to improve by 4 percentage points."

"Emart Gains from Homeplus Suspension... Starbucks, SSG.COM, and Construction Remain a Burden" [Click eStock] View original image

He estimated Emart’s consolidated operating profit for the second quarter of this year at 61 billion won, representing a 182% year-on-year increase. Both Traders and Emart Everyday continue to show growth, and specialty store No Brand is also delivering stable earnings improvement by streamlining underperforming categories. Park noted, "Chosun Hotel & Resort is likely to achieve over 60 billion won in operating profit this year, while Shinsegae Property is expected to generate annual profits exceeding 70 billion won."

Uncertainty Over Subsidiary Performance Remains a Burden… Acts as a Discount Factor for the Stock Price

The uncertainty regarding the performance of major subsidiaries is an issue that needs to be addressed. Analyst Park commented, "Starbucks Korea faces significant uncertainties in its performance due to the humidifier recall issue and marketing controversies. SSG.COM is expected to post an operating loss of 70 billion won this year because of sluggish sales and resultant fixed cost pressure."


He also pointed out that Gmarket is expected to inevitably record equity-method losses of around 40 billion won per quarter, as marketing expenses continue to rise in pursuit of top-line growth. He identified provisions for unsold apartments and commercial space at Shinsegae Construction as unpredictable one-off costs that serve as a discount factor for the stock price.



Park underscored, "Starbucks is expected to recover its performance in the third quarter, and e-commerce losses are manageable at the parent company level. If only the uncertainties surrounding Shinsegae Construction are resolved, the stock price could gain strong momentum." He added, "Currently, Emart is trading at a 12-month forward price-to-earnings ratio (PER) of about 21 times, but its price-to-book ratio (PBR) is at an absolute undervalued level of 0.2 times."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing