The Supreme Court of Korea has ruled that the three-line graphic used on the packaging of the 'Jam Baeki Energy Caffeine Health Booster' product is not similar to the claw mark-shaped trademark of Monster Energy. Although both graphics consist of three jagged lines, the Court cited differences in the direction and form of the lines, as well as in the images they evoke.


On June 5, the Supreme Court’s Special Division 2 (Presiding Justice: Kwon Youngjun) upheld the lower court’s ruling in favor of Kim, the representative of J Bio (legal representative: patent attorney Lee Kwan-yong), in the lawsuit for cancellation of the scope-of-rights-confirmation trial decision (2023Hu10118) against the U.S. company Monster Energy Company.


Monster Energy Drink and JamBaeki Energy Health Booster products. Official websites of each company.

Monster Energy Drink and JamBaeki Energy Health Booster products. Official websites of each company.

View original image

[Facts and Lower Court Decisions]

Mr. Kim, who manufactures and sells the 'Jam Baeki Energy Caffeine Health Booster,' filed a petition with the Korean Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board in December 2020, seeking a decision that the Jam Baeki Energy product packaging is not similar to Monster Energy’s registered trademark and therefore does not fall within the scope of its trademark rights.


The Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board dismissed Kim’s petition in August 2022, stating that the Jam Baeki Energy product packaging and Monster Energy’s registered trademark and product were identical or similar. The Board thus ruled that the packaging fell within the scope of Monster Energy’s trademark rights.


However, in December 2022, the Patent Court’s Division 4-1 (Presiding Judge: Lee Sookyeon) overturned the Board’s decision. The court found that, while both graphics consisted of three jagged lines, their concrete appearance and the images they elicited were different.


The court explained that the Monster Energy graphic, when combined with the word 'MONSTER,' was recognized as stylizing the initial letter 'M' in the form of a monster’s claw marks. In contrast, the Jam Baeki Energy graphic was merely three parallel lines extending from the lower left to the upper right and were not connected, making it difficult to interpret as an 'M.'


[Summary of Supreme Court Decision]

The Supreme Court concurred with this reasoning. The key points from the ruling are as follows:


- The similarity of a combination mark, consisting of two or more letters or figures, must in principle be judged based on the overall appearance, pronunciation, and conceptual meaning of all its components.


- However, if there is a component within the mark that leaves a strong impression on general consumers or independently serves the function of indicating the source of goods, that component (a “key element”) may be the focus of comparison in order to draw an appropriate conclusion for overall assessment.


- The claw-mark graphic in Monster Energy’s registered trademark and the slanted line graphic on Jam Baeki Energy’s product packaging differ in the direction and form of the lines, resulting in differences in both appearance and conceptual impression. Since it is difficult to ascribe a clear pronunciation to either graphic, pronunciation cannot be compared.


- The Monster Energy graphic and the ‘Jam Baeki’ letter portion on the Jam Baeki Energy product packaging also differ in appearance, pronunciation, and conceptual meaning, and thus are not similar.


- In conclusion, the two marks are not similar, meaning that the Jam Baeki Energy product packaging does not fall within the scope of Monster Energy’s registered trademark rights.



Reporter Jae Myung An, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing