"All the Usual Suspects Included"... Controversy over Vice Mayor Citizen Nomination System in Jeonnam Gwangju Special City
Key Issues Remain Unresolved, Including Medical School Integration and Military Airport Relocation
Vice Mayor Post Vacant for Over a Month
Concerns Mount Over “Popularity Contest” and “Delayed Voting” Due to SNS and Organizational Influence
The “Vice Mayor Citizen Nomination System”—implemented for the first time nationally by Jeonnam Gwangju Integrated Special City—has officially entered the citizen selection process, but its effectiveness is already being questioned.
As many of the individuals previously discussed as leading candidates within the local community have made it onto the final candidate list, there is a widespread sentiment that “the outcome was predictable.” Meanwhile, with urgent issues such as the integration of medical schools, relocation of the military airport, and organizational restructuring left unaddressed, the vice mayor position has been vacant for over a month. This has led to criticism that the process is “not citizen participation but rather a delayed vote.”
The exterior view of Muan Government Building in Jeonnam Gwangju Integrated Special City.
View original imageOn July 28, Jeonnam Gwangju Integrated Special City finalized a total of 10 candidates—five each for the industry and economy category, and the citizen governance and welfare category—through a review by the verification committee.
For the industry category, the selected candidates are: Kim Jinmyung, invited professor at Seoul National University of Science and Technology; Na Myunghwan, dean of AI Convergence College at Chonnam National University; Paik Seungjoo, former deputy director of the Asian Development Bank Institute; Lee Byunghoon, former National Assembly member; and Choi Hyungsik, former head of Damyang County. For the citizen governance category, the candidates are: Park Hyang, former director of public health policy at the Ministry of Health and Welfare; Park Hyunju, professor at Chosun University; Oh Miran, CEO of Gwangju Women and Family Foundation; Yoon Nansil, chief of innovation autonomy at the Committee for Regional Era; and Chae Eunji, former vice chairperson of Gwangju Metropolitan Council.
As soon as the candidate list was released, local political circles reacted by noting, “Most of the people who were considered strong candidates since the beginning of the open recruitment were included just as expected.”
From the start of the application process, the region pointed out that “close associates of Mayor Min Hyungbae, centered around his transition team, could make up the shortlist for vice mayor.” Except for a few individuals, this prediction has largely come to pass.
This is the background for views that the outcome was, in the end, expected.
Because of this, many argue that the original intentions of the citizen nomination system—such as “discovering hidden talent” and “open recruitment”—have been undermined.
Rather than uncovering new talent, the competition has been framed among those already mentioned in preliminary forecasts, leading to criticism that the review by the citizen jury and the online vote simply verify already narrowed-down candidates, rather than serve as a true verification process.
Given the circumstances, some are questioning whether there is any real significance to this vice mayor selection. If the outcome is already inevitable, they argue, there is no need to delay the process.
In practice, the city plans to complete the final appointment in August after going through open recruiting, verification committee review, citizen jury evaluation, online voting, mayoral nomination, and city council confirmation hearings.
However, since the inauguration of Mayor Min Hyungbae’s administration on July 1, the vice mayor post has remained vacant for more than a month. This has fueled criticism within the local community that “this is not citizen participation in practice, but just a delayed vote.”
Local political leaders have criticized, “Despite the fact that the mayor has the power of appointment, important policy decision timings have been missed because of the lengthy process,” and, “At a critical time when issues need to be resolved, vice mayor selection is being unnecessarily delayed.”
Concerns about the process turning into a “popularity contest”—which were raised from the very start—persist.
During the application process, text messages and KakaoTalk messages were widely circulated in the local community urging people to recommend specific candidates, and campaign activities leveraging personal acquaintances and networks have continued.
There are ongoing concerns that candidates with higher public recognition, more followers on social networks, or stronger organizational mobilization capabilities may have a relative advantage, rather than those with policy expertise or administrative experience.
Moreover, there is skepticism about whether the citizen jury evaluation—scheduled for this Saturday—can meaningfully scrutinize policy coordination skills, administrative track record, and integrity of a vice mayor (a position equivalent to a vice minister) given that it will be limited to short presentations and Q&A sessions.
An official from Jeonnam Gwangju Integrated Special City said, “While the goal of expanding citizen participation is positive, such a highly symbolic selection process for senior public officials should not devolve into a competition in organization and name recognition like an election.”
Meanwhile, the 10 selected candidates will participate in the citizen jury review scheduled for August 1 at the Korea Institute of Energy Technology International Conference Hall, where they will present their visions and answer questions posed by citizens. The citizen jury evaluation will be broadcast live on the ‘Jeonnam Gwangju TV’ YouTube channel.
On August 2, an online vote will be held for a group of 1,013 citizens selected in proportion to the population. Jeonnam Gwangju Integrated Special City plans to select three candidates per category based on the results of both the citizen jury review and online voting.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Afterwards, the integrated special mayor will nominate one candidate for each category, notify the city council, and proceed with confirmation hearings and subsequent procedures to appoint the final vice mayor in August.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.