Chey Tae-won and Noh So-Young Ruling Sparks 'Butterfly Effect'... Chaebol Divorce Cases Set for Major Change [Invest&Law]
Inherited Chaebol Assets No Longer Untouchable
One-Third Division Recognized, Even Excluding 30 Billion Won Slush Funds
Groundbreaking Approach to Division Ratios
A Likely Precedent for Future Chaebol Divorce Disputes
The so-called "divorce of the century," with a settlement nearing 1 trillion won, is making waves in both the legal and business communities. As SK Group Chairman Chey Tae-won has been ordered in a remand trial to pay his ex-wife, Noh So-Young, director of Art Center Nabi, a property division amount of 944 billion won (33.3% of the assets), a heated debate has erupted over how property division ratios should be determined in divorce cases. This ruling is particularly significant because it breaks with previous precedents that had treated inheritance and gifted assets of chaebol families as off-limits for division, recognizing instead an unprecedented share for the spouse. There is growing speculation that this decision may become a precedent-setting tool for more assertive division claims in future chaebol divorce cases.
33.3%, Even After Excluding 30 Billion Won in Slush Funds
The most striking aspect for legal experts is the unusual 33.3% division ratio. Since the remand trial by the Supreme Court excluded the "300 billion won in slush funds from Roh Tae-woo," previously considered a core basis for total asset formation, many within and outside the legal sector had expected Director Noh's share to drop sharply to the 15–20% range.
However, once announced, the division ratio only dropped 1.6 percentage points from the pre-remand Court of Appeals ruling (35%). The court fixed the valuation reference point at the close of arguments in the appellate trial (April 2024, with a share price in the 160,000 won range). It also stated that the steep rise in share price up to the end of the remand trial (when share prices had risen to the 800,000 won range) was considered in the division ratio as a matter of equitable distribution.
This outcome broadly recognizes Director Noh's domestic support and external activities as having significantly contributed to the group's rise in value. One divorce law specialist commented, "It is virtually the highest possible acknowledgment of an intangible contribution by a spouse."
Property Division Ratios Without a Clear Formula: Is It Fair?
However, this ruling has renewed criticism of the current system, which is largely based on judicial discretion without a transparent formula for calculating the division ratio. Article 839-2, Clause 2 of the Civil Code stipulates that the amount and method of division should take into account the value of property created through the cooperation of both parties and "other circumstances." Relevant case law says courts should comprehensively consider ▲ the contribution made to acquisition and maintenance of property (including non-economic contributions such as household work and childcare) ▲ the course and duration of the marriage ▲ the parties' ages and earning abilities. Recent court practice has shown a tendency to broadly recognize a share of 40–50% for full-time homemakers in marriages over 15 years in duration.
The problem is that the criterion of "other circumstances" stipulated by law is excessively broad. As a result, subjective interpretation by judges is unavoidable, raising concerns about potential arbitrariness. Of course, some counter that discretionary judicial judgment is essential to flexibly reflect the value of domestic labor and spousal support, which are difficult to quantify.
Inconsistent Standards Lead to Equity Controversy
The discretionary approach to calculation inevitably leads to issues of fairness compared to other rulings. An illustrative case is the "800 billion won property division ruling involving a private company CEO" issued by the Supreme Court in June (Presiding Judge Seo Kyung-hwan). Despite the husband independently building his business after marriage from scratch, the court strictly interpreted joint contributions and awarded the wife only a 20% stake. Compared to that, it raises the question of whether it's reasonable to award more than a 30% share of inherited assets in divorce, when one spouse had already inherited the property prior to marriage.
Previously, chaebol family divorces in Korea were often resolved quickly through settlements rather than through direct division of company shares. This was because divorce proceedings tend to be lengthy, and details regarding asset size could become public. For instance, even though a property division claim worth about 500 billion won was filed during the 2009 divorce between Samsung Electronics Chairman Lee Jae-Yong and Daesang Group Vice Chairwoman Lim Se-Ryung, both parties reached a settlement within a week, bringing the matter to a close without a court ruling. Specific details of the settlement were not made public.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Even when contested in court, recognition of contribution to assets acquired or inherited before marriage has generally been strict. Former Samsung Electro-Mechanics advisor Im Woo-Jae claimed 1.2 trillion won from Hotel Shilla CEO Lee Boo-jin, but the Supreme Court recognized only 14.13 billion won, about 1% of the total assets. Likewise, former Korean Air Vice President Cho Hyun-ah was ordered to pay her ex-husband only 1.33 billion won.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.