[Law Sosi Gae] The Dystopia After Case Dismissal View original image

"When those in power place an order for an investigation, the prosecution delivers a customized probe to fit their needs."


Such an assessment still hounds the so-called Yoon Suk-yeol group of prosecutors who specialized in special investigations. Harsher accusations follow as well: "They seemed to view investigations as a game, with victory as the goal, or entertainment that had to be won at all costs. It was a manhunt."


No one defends these investigative practices as being proper. It was an era rampant with targeted, retaliatory, and ordered investigations—marked by repeated subpoenas and separate, unrelated charges, as well as search and seizures that dragged on for over a year, wearing down suspects. The pinnacle of this was during the investigations into the government corruption and judicial manipulation scandals of 2016 and 2017. This period sparked significant self-reflection within the prosecution, with many acknowledging that the organization had been damaged. Against this backdrop, the core aim of the 'Prosecution Future Committee for the Respect of Human Rights’ (the Future Committee)—established to correct wrong investigative customs in the prosecution—is understandable.


Yet, several questions remain. Was there nothing wrong with the “orderers”—those who handed investigative cases over to prosecutors? Since the adjustment of investigative powers between prosecutors and police in 2021 limited direct investigations, the trigger for probing politicians has mainly been the complaints and accusations filed by rival political parties. Special division prosecutors are tasked chiefly with cases such as bribery, defamation via dissemination of false information, abuse of authority, and obstruction of business. The complaints for these cases are mostly prepared by the legal committees of each party. The number of complaints filed is viewed as an achievement for them. Even now, a senior member of the opposition party holds a briefing in front of the National Police Agency about the submission of complaints every two weeks and sends out press releases. Eight out of ten cases are not even transferred for prosecution and lack merit. This is how the political sphere has actively utilized or misused special prosecutors for its advantage.


That raises the question: Are the selection criteria and judgments for “abuse of prosecutorial investigative authority” defined by a committee made up of people with “uniform political leanings” appropriate? Couldn’t these individuals themselves become future “orderers” if they gain power? In other words, it is entirely possible to envision scenarios in which politics could exploit the prosecution’s “non-prosecution authority” in the opposite direction. Orders could be given to cover up or downplay cases, and investigative bodies could dutifully deliver on these instructions. Imagine, for instance, a situation in which a directive to cancel the indictment of a powerful figure is handed down under the respectable cover of a “recommendation from the Future Committee.” The political independence and impartiality of the prosecution—an institution with quasi-judicial functions—would suffer a fatal blow. Public outrage and criticism would pour in: “Why do you cover up cases for those in power, yet indict people like me?”



The power of “non-prosecution, non-trial”—meaning courts cannot review a case if the prosecutor decides not to indict—remains formidable and valid. There is always room for certain political powers to exploit this. Whether it is Yoon Suk-yeol-style aggressive investigations that target individuals, or investigations that deliberately close their eyes to wrongdoing, both are equally dangerous. We must not forget: Just as “customized indictments” that manufacture crimes out of nothing undermine judicial justice and the rule of law, so too do “customized exonerations” that conceal genuine wrongdoing become a deadly poison for the justice system.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing