On July 28, the government issued an assessment that, despite the recent signing of a new nuclear cooperation agreement between the United States and Saudi Arabia, it is difficult to see this as Saudi Arabia obtaining a genuine "independent enrichment right." With Washington maintaining a strong "non-proliferation" stance, officials are also closely watching how these negotiations may impact ongoing nuclear cooperation talks between South Korea and the United States.


Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Annex Building, Government Complex Seoul, Jongno-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Annex Building, Government Complex Seoul, Jongno-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On July 28, an official from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs told reporters at the Government Complex Seoul, "Because the American company is constructing, operating, and controlling enrichment facilities in Saudi Arabia through so-called 'black box format,' while this does constitute enrichment within Saudi Arabia, it is difficult to say that it grants Saudi Arabia an independent enrichment right." The official added a caveat that, since the full text of the U.S.-Saudi nuclear cooperation agreement has not yet been released, their comments are based only on publicly known details reported by foreign media.


According to what is currently known, the United States will conduct a joint study with Saudi Arabia on the "feasibility of uranium enrichment" over a two-year period. If enrichment feasibility is not recognized through this study, Saudi Arabia will not be allowed to pursue enrichment independently or with a third country for the next 10 years. Conversely, even if the need for enrichment is acknowledged, any enrichment facilities would only be allowed in the so-called "black box format." This means that, while the enrichment facility may physically be on Saudi territory, an American company would retain full operational control. Due to this, the Foreign Ministry official stated that it is "too early to draw a definitive conclusion" on whether the agreement actually grants enrichment rights to Saudi Arabia.


Government: "Unlikely That Saudi Arabia Has Secured Genuine Independent Uranium Enrichment Rights" View original image

There were also some analyses that, since Saudi Arabia was excluded from having to join the Additional Protocol (AP) of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in this agreement, it has effectively been exempted from safeguards. However, the government has explained that this is incorrect. The official stated, "It has been announced that Saudi Arabia has agreed to a separate bilateral safeguards agreement with the United States," adding, "Although it is not clear to what degree the IAEA would be involved, the agreement is expected to include safeguards that meet U.S. non-proliferation standards and what would be required to pass the U.S. Congress."


The reason the nuclear cooperation agreement between the United States and Saudi Arabia is drawing attention is that the South Korean government is also preparing for similar negotiations with the United States. Some assessments suggest that this case with Saudi Arabia actually reaffirms the U.S. administration's strong non-proliferation stance. Regarding the potential impact on future South Korea-U.S. nuclear cooperation negotiations, the Foreign Ministry official stated, "It is difficult to comment on ongoing negotiations," but added, "There are both opportunities and challenges."


However, if the United States were to propose a similarly restrictive form of enrichment rights as in its agreement with Saudi Arabia, it would likely be difficult for the Korean government to accept. Unlike Saudi Arabia, which does not operate any nuclear power plants, South Korea currently operates 26 reactors and there is a significant gap in the level of related civilian technology. Furthermore, if safety issues were to arise at an enrichment facility, the black box operations method, as in the Saudi case, could severely limit South Korea’s ability to independently respond. Such an arrangement could also be criticized as inconsistent with the intent of the agreement reached between the two heads of state last November, which supported "procedures leading to the peaceful use of private uranium enrichment and spent nuclear fuel reprocessing in South Korea."



Meanwhile, follow-up discussions on the Joint Fact Sheet (JFS) from the South Korea-U.S. summit, which include the nuclear cooperation issue, were first held in Seoul on June 2–3. The second round of talks, expected for this month in Washington, D.C., has been indefinitely postponed. If the first major investment project in the United States is finalized and announced in August or September as expected, it is likely that progress on security agreements will also accelerate.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing