Uniform Distribution of Performance Is Unfair
Discussion Needed on Compensation Systems That Enhance Competitiveness

[What the N% Incentive Debate Reveals] ⑦A Counterargument to Incentive Pay View original image

The debate over "N% of operating profit performance bonuses," which originated with Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, is now spreading throughout the industrial sector. On the surface, it may appear to be a question of how much to pay in performance bonuses, but at its core, this issue highlights key challenges facing our industry and labor market. This debate is not simply about splitting a certain percentage of operating profits. We must view it simultaneously through five perspectives: protection of core technical talent, fairness as demanded by Millennials & Gen Z, balance among stakeholders including shareholders, industrial structure between large corporations and SMEs, and future investments.


I have direct experience operating a "Merit System" in a domestic securities company. At the time, performance bonuses were not determined solely by the company's operating profits. We conducted a comprehensive evaluation of individual and departmental performance, risk management, customer contribution, compliance, and long-term corporate value. Based on this experience, granting a uniform percentage of operating profit as performance bonuses runs counter to the true nature of meritocracy.


Operating profit is not generated solely by workers’ efforts. It is the result of a combination of research and development, facility investments, management strategy, capital and risk undertaken by shareholders, partners’ technological capabilities, as well as variables like exchange rates and global economic trends. Thus, equating operating profit with labor performance is an oversimplification of corporate activity. Furthermore, fairness as advocated by Millennials & Gen Z is not rigid equality but compensation commensurate with contribution and responsibility.


This debate has been meaningful in that it has drawn attention back to the importance of fostering science and engineering talent, especially amid the current medical school preference. However, training talent alone is not enough. A competitive compensation system must be established to ensure that key R&D personnel can fully demonstrate their capabilities within domestic industries.


Of particular note is the situation where Chinese DRAM manufacturer CXMT (ChangXin Memory Technologies) is moving to pursue a Kexingban listing and accelerating its semiconductor self-sufficiency strategy. China is simultaneously striving for technological independence and securing key talent through national support and capital markets. As global competition to secure core technical talents intensifies, long-term incentives, stock compensation, and special bonuses are not privileges but strategic investments in national competitiveness. This does not mean allocating a fixed share of operating profit to all employees.


The achievements of a company are not solely due to employees, but also to diverse stakeholders such as shareholders, partners, customers, and local communities. Operating profit is both the outcome of their collaboration and a future resource for R&D, capital investments, new businesses, and talent development. The competitiveness of Korean conglomerates is built on the commitment and technological strength of supply chains spanning first, second, and third-tier providers. Therefore, a company’s success should also be shared with its partners. However, this needs to take the form of sustainable, mutually beneficial models—such as guaranteeing fair procurement prices, joint R&D, technological collaboration, and performance sharing based on productivity improvements—rather than a simple distribution of operating profit.


In the end, performance bonuses based on "N% of operating profit" are less about a merit-based system and more akin to straightforward profit sharing. True meritocracy involves rewarding individual and organizational labor achievements, innovation, accountability, and the creation of long-term corporate value—not mechanically distributing a set percentage of operating profit.


A culture of sharing results is necessary. Yet, distributing all achievements uniformly is not true fairness. Appropriate rewards must be given for actual contributions, strategic protection provided for core technical talent, and just performance sharing ensured for partners. Now, as a society, we must look beyond the percentage of operating profit to be divided and instead discuss how to design a performance compensation system that enhances national competitiveness. The purpose of performance bonuses is not simply to divide operating profits, but rather to invest in people, technology, and the future.



Jongcheol Park, Director of Woori Management Research Institute (attorney-at-law, United States)


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing