[What N% Performance Bonuses Have Left Behind]⑥A Plea for Performance Bonuses
Whether Performance Bonuses Count as Wages, Are Subject to Bargaining,
and Constitute Labor Disputes Are Distinct Issues
Profit Distribution Should Be Determined Through Labor-Management Negotiation, Not by Government
The controversy over performance bonuses is intensifying. Labor unions are demanding that a certain percentage of operating profit be paid as bonuses, while management argues that the distribution of company profits is not subject to collective bargaining. Recently, the President stated that "performance bonuses equivalent to N% of operating profit" are not subject to labor disputes. However, there are three distinct questions mixed into this debate: Is a performance bonus considered wages, is it subject to collective bargaining, and can disputes over performance bonuses constitute a labor dispute?
The term "performance bonus" alone cannot be used to uniformly determine whether it constitutes wages. If the payment and calculation criteria for the bonus are predetermined in work rules or collective agreements and are closely linked to the quantity or quality of work provided, performance bonuses can also be considered wages. In a recent Supreme Court ruling, the court recognized the wage nature of Samsung Electronics' target incentive. By contrast, for performance incentives funded by excess profits, the court denied the wage nature since payment was not proportional to the amount or quality of work and was heavily influenced by external factors beyond the worker's control. In other words, whether a performance bonus is considered wages should be assessed based on the obligations and standards for payment, and its relationship to the work provided, not on its name alone.
Even if a particular performance bonus is not considered wages, this does not mean it is automatically excluded from collective bargaining. While "wages" are relevant to whether a payment should be included in the calculation of severance pay or statutory allowances, the question of collective bargaining concerns whether labor and management can collectively consult and decide on matters affecting workers’ economic and social status. The two questions serve different purposes and normative functions. As long as a performance bonus system exists, the eligibility for payment, funding sources, calculation metrics, payment rates, and timing determine employees’ actual compensation.
In particular, if performance bonuses account for a significant proportion of total compensation, excluding them from bargaining would allow employers to unilaterally decide crucial parts of workers’ compensation that have a major impact on their livelihoods. While the introduction of a performance bonus system may be up to the employer’s discretion, once such a system is in place and used as a tool for rewarding labor, labor unions should also have the right to negotiate over its criteria and distribution methods.
Legal changes must also be examined. Until the revision of the Trade Union Act in September last year, labor disputes were limited to “disagreements over determination of working conditions.” However, the revised act now includes “disagreements over business management decisions that affect working conditions.” The revision does not mean that all management decisions immediately become subject to collective bargaining. However, it is now clear that the impact such decisions have on employment conditions cannot be excluded from the scope of labor disputes simply because they are managerial decisions.
However, just because an issue is subject to labor dispute does not automatically justify a strike or mean that a strike must be planned. Labor disputes can be resolved through various procedures such as autonomous negotiations between labor and management or mediation by the Labor Relations Commission. Industrial action, such as a strike, is a last resort that may be chosen if no agreement is reached after such processes. Therefore, to declare from the outset that disputes over performance bonuses are not subject to labor disputes does not simply limit the possibility of a strike—it also potentially reduces the legal space allowing unions to effectively negotiate or seek mediation on matters affecting working conditions.
Of course, it cannot be said that labor unions' demands for bonuses are always reasonable. Excessive demands could affect a business’s investment capabilities and employment, and there is also the possibility that companies may scale down or abolish the performance bonus system altogether. However, the possibility that demands could be excessive and the act of excluding such demands from negotiation, mediation, or disputes are entirely separate issues. The appropriateness of such demands should be determined during negotiations and mediation, considering the impact on a company’s sustainability and employment.
Corporate profits are not generated solely from capital, technology, management decisions, or market conditions. Labor is also an essential factor in generating corporate profits. Therefore, deciding how much of these profits should be distributed to workers, and according to what criteria, should be a matter for negotiation between labor and management, not a unilateral decision by the employer or a prohibition by the government. This does not mean that a specific amount of bonus must be paid unconditionally. Rather, it is about protecting the workers’ right to express their views, to bargain, and to seek mediation regarding the results of their labor.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Eunjung Park, Professor in the Department of Law at Korea National Open University
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.