Island Nations Aspiring for World Heritage Listing: Their Main Obstacle Was Not Disaster
UNESCO Adopts the Small Island States World Heritage Strategy 2026-2034
65.5% of Responding Countries Cite "Financial Shortfall as Top Challenge"
USD 12.7 Million to Be Invested Over Eight Years... Effectiveness of Convention Operations Remains to Be Seen
Among the thirty-nine Pacific island nations aspiring to list their sites as World Heritage, three have not even been included on the tentative list yet. The obstacle was not disaster or bureaucracy, but rather a lack of funding.
The 48th session of the UNESCO World Heritage Committee, underway in Busan, recently adopted the "Small Island Developing States (SIDS) World Heritage Strategy 2026-2034." Naif Al-Fayez, UNESCO Assistant Director-General for Culture, described this as "a reaffirmation of the principle that no country should be excluded from the benefits of the World Heritage Convention." The plan calls for an investment of USD 12.7 million over eight years in 39 countries across the Caribbean, Pacific, and the Atlantic, Indian Ocean, and South China Sea regions. Currently, there are thirty-seven inscribed World Heritage sites in 24 countries, and 104 properties from 32 countries are included in the tentative list. Some countries, however, have neither. Nauru, Niue, and Timor-Leste, despite having ratified the Convention, have no inscribed properties or tentative lists.
The results of a UNESCO survey reflect the deep disparity. Among the 26 countries that responded, 65.5% cited the lack of financial resources as the top priority. This was followed by a lack of human, institutional, and technical capacity (44.8%) and the absence of effective management plans (34.5%). While 56.7% of countries with inscribed properties reported that their funding was stable in the medium term, only 16.7% were confident in its long-term stability. Furthermore, 66% indicated that they had no disaster response plan whatsoever, and 76% had not conducted an official risk assessment in the past five years.
The harsh reality has also been confirmed on the ground. At consultations with UNESCO field offices, financial instability was identified as the root cause of all other issues. In particular, the Haiti office reported that their heritage had suffered severe damage due to lack of funds, despite having skilled professionals available. There was also concern that excessive reliance on external aid and foreign governments made these structures vulnerable to shifts in global affairs. The cost of preparing proposals, requirements for joint investment, and lengthy approval procedures often exceed the capacity of small administrative organizations.
The challenge extends beyond individual countries' fiscal difficulties. The operational structure of the World Heritage Convention itself disadvantages small island states—a point acknowledged in the new strategy. Specifically, the steps from preparing nomination dossiers, establishing management plans, conducting impact assessments, and fulfilling periodic reporting requirements are a heavy burden for small administrative teams. Due to limited local expertise, there is little choice but to depend on external consultants, while maintaining procedural continuity across several years is far from easy. Furthermore, the specialized terms and conceptual frameworks of the Convention are difficult to grasp without sustained exposure and mentoring.
Based on these concerns, UNESCO has established four priorities. The first is building environmental and climate resilience, with initial tasks focusing on baseline surveys of climate and disaster risk, localization of disaster preparedness and recovery systems, and integration with climate adaptation plans. The second is strengthening governance, policy, and management. This includes updating national tentative lists and supporting preliminary evaluations, conducting thematic research to identify serial and transboundary heritage properties, legal reforms reflecting customary law and traditional knowledge, and applying the Historic Urban Landscape (HUL) approach. The third focus is developing human, technical, and financial capacity, centering on training in heritage monitoring using satellite imagery, 3D modeling, and drones, as well as establishing a "Small Island States World Heritage Expert and Mentoring Pool" modeled after efforts in the Pacific region. The fourth priority is expanding community engagement, with a focus on youth-led digital initiatives and the integration of Indigenous and customary knowledge systems in heritage management.
The implementation will proceed in three phases. The first phase (2026–2028), with a budget of USD 3.54 million, will aim to build the necessary foundation, introducing standardized risk assessment methodologies, training country teams, and conducting baseline surveys for at least fifteen priority heritage properties. The second phase (2029–2031) is the largest, allocating USD 5.4 million to complete risk assessments for over 65% of inscribed properties, conduct disaster response training in over twenty countries, and launch preliminary evaluations and nomination procedures in at least ten states. The third phase (2032–2034) devotes USD 3.76 million to institutionalization, with a goal that by 2034, more than 80% of inscribed properties will have climate risk assessments and disaster preparedness systems continuously incorporated into management frameworks.
Though the strategy is uniform, the circumstances faced by each region differ markedly. In Africa, conflicts between the use of traditional materials (such as lime) and environmental regulations, as well as a lack of management plans, are prominent. In the Asia-Pacific, incompatibilities between formal legal systems and customary practices, and challenges in negotiations due to perceptions of land as an ancestral connection, have been identified. Pacific nations have even called for the term "Large Ocean Spaces" instead of "small island nations," reflecting the regional perspective that culture and nature should not be separated. In the Caribbean, sea level rise, increased hurricane severity, coral bleaching, and the spread of invasive species are regarded as common threats.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
These distinct realities have raised fundamental questions about the Convention's core concepts. Some have argued for a critical re-examination of how "Outstanding Universal Value (OUV)" is defined and interpreted, while others have called for traditional and Indigenous knowledge systems to be integrated equally in the evaluation and management of heritage. Whether the eight-year strategy will ultimately address these calls remains to be seen.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.