Court Finds No Willful or Gross Negligence by Management
Penalty of Over 200 Million Won Imposed Only for Breach of Prior Consultation Duty

Overseas subsidiaries' inventories were treated as losses under Korean International Financial Reporting Standards (K-IFRS), resulting in changes to company performance. As a result, a domestic venture capital (VC) firm sought to recover its principal investment, but the court did not accept their claim.


According to the legal community on the 29th, the 21st Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court (Presiding Judge Jeong Yong-shin) ruled in a lawsuit filed by VC firm A, which manages a venture investment fund, against the target company B and its management for the payment of the purchase price. The court ordered B to pay A 211.18 million won along with delayed damages. Although A had sought approximately 1.74461 billion won, the court recognized only the penalty for breach of contract, dismissing the remainder of the claim.

[Invest&Law]Changes in Investee Performance After K-IFRS Adoption...VC Unable to Recover Principal View original image

Performance Fluctuations Due to Loss Recognition of Vietnamese Subsidiary’s Inventory Assets

Previously, in March 2024, Company A acquired 17,500 redeemable convertible preferred shares issued by Company B for approximately 1.4 billion won. The contract included a “representations and warranties” clause that required the financial statements and due diligence materials to be truthful and accurate, as well as a put option clause allowing the investor to sell shares back to B or its management in the event of a breach.


The issue arose from the inventory assets of B’s Vietnamese subsidiary. The external auditor determined that while the amount was recognized as inventory under local accounting standards, it could not straightforwardly be recognized as assets according to K-IFRS. Company B reflected these inventory assets as inventory shrinkage losses and amended its financial statements and audit reports. Inventory shrinkage loss refers to treating a loss in cases where the recorded inventory cannot actually be verified or is deemed unrecoverable.


Company A argued that the revenues and profits reflected in the materials provided before the investment and in the revised audit report differed, claiming that Company B had violated its representations and warranties obligations.

Principal Recovery Blocked by Treasury Stock Regulation…Only Penalty Recognized

The first-instance court found that the management did not intentionally or negligently provide false information. The court stated, "The difference in data seems to have arisen from the application of K-IFRS during the process of consolidating the financial statements of Company B and its Vietnamese subsidiary," and added, "Company B notified that there could be changes in revenues and such during the preparation of the consolidated financial statements, and Company A was able to be aware of this."


The court also noted that a criminal complaint for fraudulent and unfair trading against the management was dismissed by law enforcement authorities (not guilty), which was a basis for the judgment. The court stated, "It is difficult to see that there was an intentional or grossly negligent violation of the above representations and warranties."


The decisive reason for dismissing the principal recovery claim was the statutory restrictions on acquiring treasury stock under the Commercial Act. According to the contract, if Company B were to repurchase shares directly from Company A, it would amount to Company B acquiring its own shares. However, Company B did not have the distributable profits necessary to buy back shares, and the contractually stipulated purchase method did not meet legal requirements under the Commercial Act.



However, the court acknowledged liability for breaching the promise that Company B would consult with the investor in advance regarding the board of directors and regular shareholders’ meeting agendas and then notify the outcomes. The court stated, "The consultation right itself indeed granted some shareholders superior rights," but also held that, "Given the special circumstances justifying this, this clause cannot be regarded as an invalid provision violating the principle of shareholder equality." Accordingly, the court ruled that 15% of the investment, amounting to 211.18 million won, should be paid as a penalty for breach of contract.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing