[The View] The Economics of Apology and Remorse
Does an Apology Really Warrant Leniency?
Moral Value Recognized, but Lowers Expected Costs
Recently, the baseball team of Paichai High School received a six-month suspension from competitions after chanting hate speech during a game. However, thanks to their apology, self-reflection, and the leniency shown by the victim school, the suspension was reduced to one month. The moral response shown by both the offending and victim schools is commendable and deserves praise. However, does reducing disciplinary action due to an apology, repentance, and the victim’s forgiveness help to prevent future hate speech, or does it actually encourage it?
Although hate speech is not defined as a criminal offense under current law in Korea, sentence reductions as a result of apologies are fairly common in the judicial system. There are no academic papers directly proving that sentence reduction due to apologies and remorse increases future crimes. Even if the recidivism rate did decrease after such leniency, it is impossible to determine whether the drop was actually due to the reduced sentence, or because the offenders, being less likely to reoffend, expressed remorse and thus had their sentences reduced in the first place.
While there is no direct research on this causality, an indirect answer can be found based on various economic theories and empirical studies. Sentence reduction due to apology is unlikely to decrease recidivism. If an offender truly repents, then regardless of a sentence reduction, they would not reoffend. However, if an apology is merely a strategic move to obtain leniency, previous research suggests that the recidivism rate rises by as much as the sentence is reduced.
Gary Becker, recipient of the Nobel Prize in Economics, introduced the economic model of crime. According to his theory, potential offenders compare the expected benefit and expected cost of committing a crime before deciding whether to commit it. The higher the sentence, the greater the expected cost, and the less likely someone is to commit a crime. There is also supporting empirical evidence. In a natural experiment conducted in Italy, it was found that for each additional month of sentence, the recidivism rate fell by 0.16 percentage points.
If sentence reduction based on apologies becomes established as a norm, the expected cost perceived by potential offenders decreases. This cost reduction works via two main mechanisms. First, if making an apology ensures a lighter sentence, the expected cost is lowered. Thus, the rational course of action may be to commit the crime first and then apologize afterward. This behavior is typically explained by the concept of "moral hazard" in economics. Moral hazard refers to the tendency of people to take more risks when the negative social consequences of their actions do not weigh heavily on them. For example, just as subscribers to indemnity health insurance are more prone to take health risks and visit hospitals more frequently because their out-of-pocket costs are lower, a "sentence reduction upon apology" acts as a social insurance mechanism, making it easier to commit offenses.
Second, sentence reductions for apologies also reduce the certainty of punishment, which further lowers the expected cost of crime. According to multiple economics studies, the certainty of punishment is far more effective than the severity of punishment in deterring crime. In other words, even with a lower sentence, consistently punishing offenders regardless of apologies or contrition is more effective at preventing crime. Conversely, if the likelihood of being punished is uncertain—no matter how harsh the sentence is—the probability of committing a crime increases. Thus, once there is the possibility that an apology could lead to no punishment, the deterrent effect drops sharply.
In the case of Paichai High School’s baseball team, there are two further mechanisms by which apology-driven reductions lower the expected cost. First, both the incident and subsequent disciplinary action were directed at the group, not individuals. Not everyone participated in chanting hate speech, but the responsibility of those who did was diluted within the group, and the apology was made collectively. This means the actual perpetrator may secure sentence reduction without taking real responsibility or changing their behavior. In a system where both the cost of misconduct and the benefit of sentence reduction are shared collectively, there is increasingly less need for an individual to refrain from further misconduct.
Second, research shows that hate speech signals to supporters that such expressions are widespread, lowering the perceived cost of further hate crimes and thereby increasing similar crimes among other groups. Sentence reduction due to apologies can signal, not only within the Paichai High School baseball team but to other groups as well, that even after making such remarks and actions, apologizing will shield them from punishment.
Economics does not deny the moral value of genuine apology and repentance. However, it explains that as soon as such actions result in sentence reduction, the expected cost is lowered, making it much less likely that future behavior will change as a result.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Suh Boyoung, Professor at Indiana State University
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.