[Chip War 3 Years On]② Vice President Hutchison: "The Greatest Bottleneck in AI Semiconductors Is Talent, Not Chips... The Biggest Risk Is Geopolitical"
115,000 New Jobs Projected in the Semiconductor Industry by 2030
Concerns Over a 58% Workforce Gap Among Technicians and Engineers
Geopolitical Risks Emerge as Major Variables
HBM Reshapes the Memory Cycle
"The next bottleneck for the AI semiconductor infrastructure is not chips, but people."
As the competition in AI semiconductors intensifies, market attention has focused on technical bottlenecks such as high bandwidth memory (HBM), advanced packaging, and power efficiency. However, Dan Hutchison, Vice President of TechInsights and a renowned authority in semiconductor supply chain and industrial cycle analysis, diagnosed that the greatest bottleneck for the AI semiconductor infrastructure will not be technology or resources, but talent.
58% of New U.S. Semiconductor Jobs Face Talent Gap Concerns
Vice President Hutchison noted that the semiconductor industry association SEMI plays a role in coordinating industry, government, and educational institutions to address the shortage of skilled workers, but pointed out, "There are limits to what SEMI can do." He added, "While the overall workforce is growing at about 1% annually, the semiconductor industry is expanding at a double-digit pace several times faster."
This talent bottleneck is even more pronounced in the United States, where AI competition is at the front line. According to a 2023 report by the Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) and Oxford Economics, employment in the U.S. semiconductor industry is projected to grow from about 345,000 to 460,000 by 2030. This means that about 115,000 new jobs will be created by 2030, but if current graduation trends continue, about 67,000 of these positions (58%) are expected to remain unfilled. The talent shortfall is expected to comprise approximately 26,400 technicians, 27,300 engineers, and 13,400 computer science professionals.
Deloitte, in its 2022 report, projected that the global semiconductor industry will need to secure over 1 million additional skilled workers by 2030—a scale that requires more than 100,000 new hires each year. Deloitte has maintained this outlook, noting that the shortage has only worsened due to ongoing expansion of production facilities and AI investments worldwide.
Talent Shortages and Geopolitical Risks: A Double Burden for Korea's Supply Chain
Geopolitical risks are another variable that cannot be ignored. Vice President Hutchison stated, "The biggest risk facing Korean semiconductor companies over the next five years will be geopolitical in nature," and added, "This includes bottlenecks like the Strait of Hormuz, China's push to unify Taiwan and the possibility of physical conflict, as well as North Korea."
Korea's semiconductor industry is linked with multiple countries for its raw materials, energy, equipment, production bases, and major customers. Instability in the Strait of Hormuz could drive up energy and logistics costs, while a conflict in the Taiwan Strait could shake the entire advanced semiconductor supply chain. The North Korea risk also weighs on the stability of domestic production sites and on investor sentiment. In other words, a single geopolitical shock could simultaneously strain production, logistics, and demand.
Despite this, the strategic value of Korean companies in the AI semiconductor supply chain remains significant. Vice President Hutchison evaluated, "Korean semiconductor companies are like the crown jewels in the AI semiconductor competition due to the complementary structure of logic and memory," emphasizing, "AI and HBM will undoubtedly present the greatest opportunities for Korean semiconductor firms over the next five years."
HBM Reshaping the Memory Cycle
Vice President Hutchison drew a line against the view that the power center of the AI semiconductor industry has shifted completely from logic chips to memory. He explained, "Logic and memory are in a perfectly complementary relationship—this is the essence of computing architecture."
Addressing the claim that the memory industry is moving beyond its cyclical nature because of AI and HBM, he remarked, "It is still, fundamentally, a cyclical industry." However, he assessed that, since HBM is not a commodity product, the volatility in the memory market could be more moderate than in the past.
Vice President Hutchison explained, "Traditionally, memory has been a pure commodity that could be easily replaced, like different brands of rice." However, he stressed that "with the advent of AI and HBM, the market landscape has changed—HBM memory is customized to work with specific AI chips. This structural reality is reshaping the market."
HBM features a high level of technical integration between customers and suppliers, with product development and supply plans spanning over extended periods. Thus, unlike commodity memory, it is less likely for orders to fluctuate dramatically in response to price and inventory changes. While the cyclical nature unique to the memory industry does not disappear, as long as demand for AI persists, the current growth could last much longer than in the past.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.