['N% Performance Bonus' Debate]④"The Term 'Excess Profit' Is Inappropriate... There Is No System to Offset Excess Losses"
Interview with Youngmyon Lee, Professor Emeritus at Dongguk University
Unprecedented Scale of Performance Bonuses Beyond Convention
Lack of Transparency Causes Workplace Confusion
Cash Payouts Are Also Rarely Seen
Don't Kill the Goose That
How to distribute corporate performance is now a pivotal topic for the entire industrial sector, moving beyond the realm of traditional labor-management negotiations. The debate over performance-based bonuses linked to operating profit, which began in the semiconductor industry, has spread to the automotive, shipbuilding, and IT industries, and has even extended to subcontractor unions demanding a share from parent companies. However, the conversation remains focused solely on the question of how much more to receive, with little to no discussion or social consensus on who distributes the profits, under what principles and procedures. While American-style performance-based compensation is often cited, supporting employment flexibility or industry-wide criteria are largely absent from the debate. The lack of principled performance distribution is increasingly likely to fuel not only internal corporate disparities, but also broader conflicts within the industrial ecosystem and society at large. The Asia Business Daily explores the challenges posed by the "N% Performance Bonus" debate to our society, featuring insights and arguments from various experts through interviews and columns.
"It may be true that the company achieved excess profit according to its internal management plan. However, when an outsider claims that the company has generated huge profits, is it really appropriate to determine a particular point as 'acceptable' and to designate any profit beyond that as 'excess'? There is a growing argument in society that, once excessive profits are earned, they should be returned to society through performance bonuses—I'm not sure if the concept of 'excess profit' itself is even appropriate."
Professor Youngmyon Lee, Professor Emeritus at Dongguk University, is being interviewed on the 23rd at the Asia Business Daily Education Center in Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Dongju Yoon
View original imageYoungmyon Lee, Professor Emeritus of Business Administration at Dongguk University, made these remarks during an interview at the Asia Business Daily Education Center in Jung-gu, Seoul, on the 23rd. He added, "If a company incurs excessive losses, society does not step in to bear them. Therefore, we need to carefully consider whether using the term 'excess profit' is really appropriate."
Professor Lee is a scholar who has studied labor-management relations, HR management ethics, and wage systems for about 30 years. He has served as president of the Korean Academy of Management, president of the Korea Business Ethics Association, vice president of the Korea Employment and Labor Relations Association, and as a public interest commissioner on the Central Labor Relations Commission, continuing research in the fields of HR management and labor policy.
Professor Lee stressed the importance of critically examining the process by which the "N% Performance Bonus", a recent trend rapidly spreading in the labor sector, is determined. He explained, "The current controversy arose because the scale of these bonuses has gone far beyond precedent and lacks transparency," adding, "This is an entirely new phenomenon, so a societal discussion is absolutely necessary."
Globally, such a structure for performance-based bonuses is hard to find. He noted, "In the United States, the concept of a bonus is almost nonexistent, and most compensation is salary-based," and continued, "Salaries are determined individually, and even extraordinary bonuses are calculated on a personal basis, so there is little collective demand."
Performance bonuses paid in cash are also rare. According to Professor Lee, "In the United States, companies like Tesla and Nvidia have provided significant rewards to employees mainly through stock options," and, "In Taiwan, TSMC paid the equivalent of roughly 100 million won per employee in performance bonuses to around 90,000 employees, as decided by the board of directors."
On May 20, at the Gyeonggi Employment and Labor Office in Jangan-gu, Suwon-si, Gyeonggi-do, Yeomyeonggu, Head of the People Team for Samsung Electronics DS (Device Solutions - Semiconductor Business), and Seungho Choi, Chairman of the Samsung Electronics Branch of the Samsung Group Super Union, signed a tentative agreement after completing wage negotiations. They are taking a commemorative photo with Younghoon Kim, Minister of Employment and Labor. Photo by Yonhap News.
View original imageProfessor Lee emphasized that it is not irrational for workers to demand a share of the profits to which they contributed. Regarding the N% performance bonus issue, he said, "The real problem was that, without a pre-established distribution standard or upper limit, post hoc profit-sharing became an issue," analyzing that, "As the debate has taken on the nature of a distributive conflict over bonuses, public attention has become fixated only on distributed profits once realized."
He particularly pointed out that what caused the greatest problem was the government’s decision to break with established practice in the process of setting performance bonuses. According to Supreme Court rulings, bonuses that are paid according to after-the-fact profits and determined on a variable basis are considered post hoc profit sharing, not wages, unlike regular fixed bonuses. Because they are not wages, these bonuses are not subject to compulsory collective bargaining, and in principle, demands for such bonuses and related strikes are deemed unlikely to be justified under the law.
However, Professor Lee said, "The Ministry of Employment and Labor, as the government authority in charge, was too quick to focus solely on mediation during the settlement process, without providing clear legal guidance on whether the strike was unlawful," and, "By interpreting special performance bonuses as a welfare benefit rather than wages, the government has in effect signaled acceptance of strikes related to such bonuses." Strikes are legally permitted over welfare matters. Professor Lee added, "This ambiguous attitude has led to misunderstandings in the industry, creating the impression that special performance bonuses can also be won through strike action, which in turn is causing even greater conflict and confusion."
Professor Lee insists that, in principle, labor and management should determine performance bonuses collaboratively. He argued, "According to textbook wage management principles, performance-based bonuses should be seen as a comprehensive issue where labor and management agree in advance on clear calculation formulas to foster motivation and productivity," adding, "Labor and management must work together to develop these formulas through negotiation." He further stated, "Although the semiconductor sector is enjoying a boom right now, an economic downturn is certain to come sooner or later, so investment must continue actively to ensure sustainable management," and, "Just because you have a goose that lays golden eggs, you shouldn't kill it."
Professor Lee also argued that it is unreasonable for the government to force companies to make social contributions. He explained that corporate social responsibility should not be legislated, but instead encouraged on a voluntary, mutually beneficial basis.
Professor Lee noted, "Corporations serve society primarily by paying corporate tax (up to a maximum rate of 27.5%) for national infrastructure and public contribution," and, "It is against the principles of a market economy for the government to demand that companies surrender any remaining profits above and beyond tax obligations simply because they have exceeded targets." However, he added, "Aside from legal compulsion, large corporations must feel responsible because they have a range of stakeholders, including suppliers in their partner ecosystem, local communities, and consumers."
Professor Lee referred to Samsung Electronics’ gratitude festival for partners and local communities as a voluntary example, noting, "While this is a positive example, it needs to be developed into a more systematic and sustainable mechanism for returning value to society."
Going one step further, he suggested that the current debate over performance bonuses should not just patch over short-term labor-management conflict, but should evolve into governance innovation worthy of a global leading company.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Professor Lee stated, "Samsung Electronics operates a Compliance Committee, which, as the name implies, is the minimum-level body for ensuring compliance with the law," and, "If the company wants to become a global leader and maintain sustainable management, it cannot simply settle for basic compliance. As the U.S. Business Roundtable (BRT)—a policy council composed of CEOs of America’s leading companies—has declared, the purpose of a corporation should extend beyond maximizing shareholder value to fulfilling responsibilities to all stakeholders." He recommended, "The Compliance Committee should be upgraded to a Stakeholders Committee, so that executives, union representatives, partner companies, local community members, and outside experts can all participate in carefully considering reasonable principles when unexpected large profits or losses occur."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.