Delivery Quality Drives Satisfaction and Sales
Operational Strategies for Cost-Efficiency Remain a Challenge

The competition to internalize logistics—where companies directly manage all logistics processes such as delivery and inventory management—is intensifying, not only among delivery platforms but also as e-commerce companies are joining the direct delivery race. While high delivery quality provides a positive consumer experience, voices in the industry point out that improving cost-efficiency, such as resolving high-cost structures, is becoming even more important.


The Korea Distribution Science Association held the July Distribution Forum on the 24th at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jung-gu, Seoul, under the theme "Sustainable Delivery Platform Strategies in the Era of Last-Mile Competition."


Market share trends of American delivery platforms Grubhub and DoorDash. Korean Distribution Science Association

Market share trends of American delivery platforms Grubhub and DoorDash. Korean Distribution Science Association

View original image

Choi Jayoung, president of the Korea Distribution Science Association, emphasized, "Own logistics is no longer a choice for a select few, but a survival strategy for all distribution and delivery platforms looking to endure the last-mile competition."


Lee Sungho, professor at Hanbat National University, presented on the trend of internal logistics competition by discussing the case of DoorDash, a US delivery platform that expanded its market share by actively adopting its own delivery system. Grubhub entered the US online food ordering market in 2004, providing delivery services through a brokerage system, but lost its leading position to the later entrant DoorDash in 2019.


DoorDash established an independent delivery network and provided direct delivery services, whereas Grubhub relied on restaurants to handle deliveries, which left it lagging behind in delivery speed and service scope. As of December 2024, the market share gap between the two companies has widened significantly, with DoorDash at 62.7% and Grubhub at 6.2%, a difference of tenfold. Grubhub's corporate value plummeted by 91%, from approximately 7.3 billion dollars in 2021 to 650 million dollars forecasted for 2025.


Professor Lee commented, "The cases of DoorDash and Grubhub show that whether a platform can directly control delivery quality—namely, by adopting internal logistics and delivery infrastructures—is a key factor determining survival in the market."


The Korea Distribution Association held the July Distribution Forum on the 24th at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jung-gu, Seoul, with the theme "Sustainable Delivery Platform Strategies in the Era of Last Mile Competition." Photo by Hanjin Ju

The Korea Distribution Association held the July Distribution Forum on the 24th at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jung-gu, Seoul, with the theme "Sustainable Delivery Platform Strategies in the Era of Last Mile Competition." Photo by Hanjin Ju

View original image

This trend toward establishing proprietary logistics is clearly visible throughout the entire distribution industry, including e-commerce. Global players such as Amazon, DoorDash, and JD.com, as well as domestic companies like Kurly and Olive Young, have introduced logistics internalization systems.


The driver behind expanding in-house delivery is shipping quality, as customer satisfaction can be increased by enhancing the 'last mile' delivery experience from order to delivery. According to a survey conducted by the Korea Consumer Agency on delivery app customers from 2017 to 2021—before the Korean delivery market transitioned to an in-house delivery focus—complaints related to delivery quality, such as incorrect deliveries or non-delivery, constituted the highest proportion at 33.6%.


Shipping quality directly impacts sales. In a natural experiment involving Alibaba—a Chinese e-commerce platform—where high-quality shipping options (SF Express, a type of third-party logistics similar to internal logistics) were shut down for 42 hours, hourly sales during that period decreased by 14.6%.


Professor Lee said, "As competition intensifies in the last-mile service quality (speed, timeliness, and reliability) throughout the distribution and delivery industries, the adoption of proprietary logistics—enabling stable and efficient management of logistics processes and delivery quality—has spread as a survival strategy."


However, some caution that building internal logistics capabilities does not guarantee market success and that certain conditions for sustainability must be met. Hansanglin, professor at Hanyang University, who served as the moderator of the general discussion, remarked, "Since in-house logistics involves fully internalizing all last-mile related systems, high costs for management and building systems are inevitable. Sufficient demand density, technological capability (such as AI), operational competence, and efficiency improvements are essential prerequisites."


Ok Kyungyoung, professor at Sookmyung Women's University, noted, "The high operational costs of logistics internalization—arising from building systems, managing operations, securing riders, and assuring service quality—may indirectly burden participants in the delivery ecosystem, especially consumers. While internal logistics systems allow delivery platforms to collect granular data on the consumer journey and thus positively influence service quality, considerations must be given to concerns about excessive use or leakage of personal information."



Professor Lee Sungho forecasted, "In the future, the market will continue to be reorganized around operators with appropriate levels of demand density and operational capability."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing