Guilty of Murder, Sentenced to 14 Years and 9 Months in Prison
Elon Musk Joins Criticism: "This Ruling Is Insane"

In Italy, public criticism has been mounting that the scope of self-defense should be more broadly recognized, after a jeweler in his 70s was sentenced to a lengthy prison term for fatally shooting robbers who were fleeing with stolen jewelry.


According to Yonhap News Agency and ANSA on July 23, Mario Rozeo, a 72-year-old jeweler, was convicted of murder and other charges by the Supreme Court on July 17, resulting in a finalized sentence of 14 years and 9 months in prison.

Rozeo engaging in a physical fight while shooting at robbers in front of a jewelry store. Screen capture from social media X, Yonhap News Agency.

Rozeo engaging in a physical fight while shooting at robbers in front of a jewelry store. Screen capture from social media X, Yonhap News Agency.

View original image

Rozeo was brought to trial on charges of killing two robbers and injuring another in April 2021, after they stole jewelry from the store he operated and fled.


The court did not accept Rozeo's actions as self-defense, noting that the robbers were already outside the store and in the process of fleeing at the time he opened fire. The court stated that Rozeo shot at the robbers even after the threat to his life had ended. He was also found guilty of illegal possession of a firearm. In addition, the court upheld the ruling requiring him to pay 480,000 euros (about 800 million won) in compensation to the bereaved families of the robbers.


After the heavy prison sentence was finalized for Rozeo, there has been a heated debate, especially among conservatives in Italy, arguing that his actions should be recognized as self-defense. Carlo Nordio, Minister of Justice of the Brothers of Italy party led by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, initiated a pardon process for Rozeo. Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Infrastructure and Transport Matteo Salvini also criticized the guilty verdict, stating that he would consider granting Rozeo immunity. He even visited Rozeo in prison in person. The right-wing coalition party led by Salvini announced plans to introduce legislation that would recognize all forms of self-defense for homeowners and shopkeepers who respond to armed attacks.


The appropriateness of the large compensation order against Rozeo is also under debate. In Italy, if a perpetrator is injured or killed during the commission of a crime, civil damages can be limited if the other party acted in legitimate self-defense. Prime Minister Meloni argued that the damages ruling was "unfair." She pointed out, "If someone attacks me and I defend myself, do I then have to compensate the attacker? That is not fair." She further emphasized, "Someone who breaks the law should not expect to receive compensation from the person who defended themselves."



Elon Musk, CEO of SpaceX, joined the controversy on July 20 by sharing a post on social media criticizing the verdict against Rozeo. He strongly condemned the decision, writing, "The people who should be convicted in this case are the judge and the prosecutor. This is insane."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing