Israel Founded by Zionists
Leaning Further to the Right Without Full Jewish Support

Accusing Israel

Accusing Israel

View original image

"Among all the religions in the world, Islam and Judaism share so many commonalities that they have the greatest potential for mutual understanding and reconciliation."


This is a statement by Jacob Neusner, the late American Jewish scholar and rabbi who passed away in 2016. However, in reality, groups and nations that uphold Islam and Judaism are among the most fiercely in conflict. Even now, Israel is waging war against Iran with the backing of the United States. How did Islam and Judaism—two religions so closely related—end up as adversaries?


Yakov Rabkin, a Jewish historian who authored "Accusing Israel," traces the root cause to Zionism. Rabkin points out that Zionism is not a traditional Jewish belief, but rather a political tool shaped by the influence of 19th-century European nationalism. Through his book, he aims to break the conventional wisdom that Zionism equals Judaism, and that Israel represents all Jews across the world.


Nineteenth-century European nationalism led to the unification of Germany and Italy, and spurred the independence of various nation-states such as Greece and Romania. The ideal of national self-determination—that peoples should decide their own political fate—became a logic of liberation for those under imperial rule. However, as the nineteenth century drew to a close, nationalism increasingly morphed into exclusive statism, emphasizing national superiority and territorial expansion. Coupled with imperialism and militarism, it became a major cause of the two world wars.


Rabkin emphasizes that Zionism is a product of this distorted modern European nationalism. Citing the Talmud, he argues that Zionism is, in fact, at odds with the teachings of traditional Judaism. According to Rabkin, the Talmud contains a pledge not to return en masse or by force to the land of Israel, and also a commitment by Jews not to rise up against the other peoples of the lands where they reside.


Rabkin explains that the declaration of Israel's establishment in 1948 was carried out by a Zionist minority, and that many Jews actually opposed it. Albert Einstein was one of those who objected to establishing a Jewish state in Palestine. In a 1946 essay, Einstein argued, "It is not reasonable for us (the Jews) to claim political dominance in Palestine, where two-thirds of the population are non-Jews."


Having failed to secure consistent support from all Jews, Israel displayed an increasing tendency toward right-wing politics in its effort to consolidate internal unity. At the same time, it sought new political alliances with right-wing and far-right forces around the world. As a result, certain white nationalist and evangelical groups in the United States, Islamophobic forces in Europe, and Hindu nationalists in India all currently support Israel, though each for different reasons.


However, Rabkin raises doubts about whether this rightward turn can be a sustainable strategy for Israel in the long term. He draws attention to the fact that, last year, Zohran Mamdani, a Muslim, was elected mayor of New York. Despite his vocal criticism of the Gaza war and the Israeli government, Mamdani received support from young Jewish voters.


Rabkin notes that while young Israeli generations are becoming increasingly right-leaning, young American Jews are actively engaging in pro-Palestinian causes. If this trend continues, the emotional divide between Israeli society and the American Jewish community will widen, and generational and political factional conflicts within the United States over its Israel policy may intensify.



Through this book, Rabkin ultimately stresses that Zionism and Judaism must not be conflated. He explains that, for Jews, religious community identity has long outweighed that of an ethnic nation. Having lived dispersed across many countries for thousands of years, their identity as a people defined by shared territory and nationhood was relatively weak. Rabkin argues that Zionism implanted a misplaced sense of nationality in Jews, which became the seed of the many tragic conflicts playing out in the modern Middle East.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing