[Economy Pulse] Who Should Decide on AI Semiconductor Investments? View original image

Amid the intensifying U.S.-China hegemonic rivalry, ongoing wars, and the geopolitical fragmentation triggered by COVID-19, the weakening of the global value chain has accelerated, exacerbating both inefficiencies in production and associated costs. On top of this, rising fiscal deficits across various countries are contributing to a macroeconomic environment of structurally higher real interest rates. In this era when capital is increasingly expensive, equity investment—which mobilizes large-scale capital by sharing risk with shareholders—has emerged as the key method of raising funds in advanced technology competition, overtaking traditional debt-based financing. In response to the surging global demand for AI, the government recently announced an 800 trillion won investment plan focused on three key areas—semiconductors, physical AI, and data centers—in the southwestern region, as well as an 81 trillion won investment to develop the Chungcheong region as a package manufacturing hub. It is highly appropriate for the government to proactively and nationally respond to this major industrial transition by establishing large-scale infrastructure. The real challenge, however, lies in what comes after: who will decide on the deployment of this colossal amount of capital and through what procedures.


Yet, the process of allocating funds and making investment decisions should not replicate the old 'government-led' framework. Government committees or bureaucratic decision-making are inherently unable to fully aggregate decentralized market information, inevitably hitting the limits of information asymmetry. Although Korea's R&D investment relative to GDP ranks second in the world and the national R&D program boasts a nominal success rate of 98%, the proportion of these achievements actually commercialized in the market remains low—the so-called 'R&D paradox,' which exposes a fundamental weakness. This is due to a rigid evaluation structure that encourages 'success for the sake of success' rather than prioritizing market potential or innovation. In contrast, Israel has, from the very start, relied on the private sector to rigorously screen for market potential, driving the successful commercialization and transfer of technology. The lack of any prominent success stories among various national funds set up under government leadership attests to widespread skepticism about government-driven investment decision-making. Investment should ultimately be led by corporations, with government limited to supporting infrastructure. Above all, the model must ensure that only projects passing objective market evaluation and strict discipline—underpinned by private capital's willingness to risk its own assets—are carried out.


Within private corporations, then, who is the ultimate decision-maker when it comes to multitrillion-won investments? The answer is obvious: the board of directors. Unfortunately, public perception of Korean corporate governance remains outdated. When the country announces large-scale investment plans, the leaders of related conglomerates often pledge their commitment and publicly proclaim massive investment schemes. The problem is that these grand investment plans are often presented as if they result from the individual decisions of company heads, with formal board approval only following as a mere procedural step, rather than stemming from rigorous debate and independent resolution by the board. Frontier investments involving tens of trillions of won demand not the intuition of a single owner, but careful deliberation and independent approval by the board representing shareholder interests. Ironically, this practice persists even under the current administration, which has bolstered board independence and authority through amendments to the Commercial Act—clearly illustrating just how far Korea's capital market remains from global standards, stuck as it is in an outdated paradigm of owner-centric management at major conglomerates.


In today's era of geopolitical fragmentation and historically high opportunity costs for capital, even a single major investment misstep could be fatal for both a nation and its corporations. The days of relying on owner-driven 'bold investments,' fueled by abundant liquidity, are over. In the fierce frontier war of advanced industries, including AI semiconductors, neither bureaucratic desk strategies nor unilateral declarations by corporate owners will suffice. The answer to the question, "Who should decide?" is clear. Only rigorous validation by market professionals and transparent, rational decision-making by corporate boards can ensure the sustained leap forward for our economy.



Professor Nohsun Kwak, Department of Economics, Sogang University (Former President, Korea Money & Finance Association)


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing