TikTok Fined 10.3 Billion Won, Apple 250 Million Won for Unauthorized Use of User Behavior and Voice Data (Comprehensive)
Personal Information Protection Commission Issues Fines and Orders Corrections and Disclosure
TikTok Collected User Behavioral Data Without Consent
Failure to Properly Inform Users About Overseas Data Transfers
Apple Used Voice Recordings to Improve Siri Without User Consent
TikTok: "Will Announce Position After Receiving Decision... Committed to Data Protection"
TikTok and Apple have been fined a combined total of 10.6 billion won for collecting users’ activity records without consent and using the data for personalized advertising and improving their own services.
The Personal Information Protection Commission announced on the 23rd that, at its 14th plenary session held on the 22nd, it had imposed a total of 10.558 billion won in fines on two affiliates of TikTok and Apple for violating the Personal Information Protection Act. In addition, corrective orders and public disclosure orders were issued.
According to the commission’s investigation, both companies collected, utilized, or transferred users’ personal data abroad without proper legal grounds.
TikTok was fined 10.36 billion won and received improvement and public disclosure orders. TikTok collected behavioral data such as users’ browsing activity without properly notifying them. In delivering advertising and content performance analysis services, TikTok distributed behavioral data collection tools to other businesses. These tools gather activity records (such as clicks and purchases) of users who visit third-party websites or apps.
Using these tools, TikTok collected behavioral data from 9.45 million domestic users, as of December last year, including device identifiers, and then linked this data to TikTok accounts for use in targeted ads. Throughout this process, TikTok did not clearly notify users about the data collection. The commission explained that consent was obtained as a mandatory item during registration, essentially forcing users to agree to the collection of third-party behavioral data.
It was also found that TikTok’s lighter version, “TikTok Lite,” failed to notify users about the transfer of their personal data. When users withdrew cash from points earned through an app-tech service provided on TikTok Lite, their personal information was transferred to affiliates, but the specific types of data transferred were not disclosed to or notified to users.
A representative from the commission stated that the relatively large fine for TikTok was due to “the significant revenue generated from personalized ads utilizing user behavioral data,” explaining that “the fine was calculated based on the related revenue.”
Apple Used Voice Data to Improve Siri… TikTok: “Will Respond After Receiving the Official Decision”
Jaehyung Lee, Director of the Investigation and Coordination Bureau at the Personal Information Protection Commission, announced on the 23rd at the Government Seoul Complex in Jongno-gu, Seoul, that TikTok and Apple were each fined 10.36 billion won and 252 million won respectively for collecting and using personal information without legal grounds. Photo by Yonhap News
View original imageTwo Apple affiliates (ADI, ASPL) were fined 252 million won and received orders for corrective measures. Until August 2019, Apple collected users’ voice recordings and transcripts through its Siri voice assistant and used them to improve voice recognition and search results without properly informing users. The commission’s investigation found that Apple did not obtain separate consent from users. While Apple has obtained user consent for the use of voice recordings to improve services since October 2019, transcripts were still used for service improvement without legal grounds.
Additionally, when transferring users’ personal data to Apple’s headquarters in the United States, Apple did not provide sufficient details in its privacy policy regarding the types of data being transferred, the purposes for which the receiving party would use the data, or the retention and usage period.
However, during the investigation, Apple enhanced privacy protection by enabling users to choose whether to share transcripts and implementing filtering of personal data within transcripts. Apple also amended its privacy policy and addressed the identified violations. A commission official explained, “A certain level of fine reduction was applied in consideration of Apple’s corrective actions.”
Furthermore, as Siri is a free service, it is difficult to calculate related revenues, which was also reflected in the decision. Since the violation occurred in 2019, before the transfer of personal information regulations from the Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization and Information Protection, etc. to the Personal Information Protection Act, the former act was applied. The maximum fixed fine stipulated by that law is 400 million won.
The commission emphasized the significance of warning that overseas companies must also ensure transparency in their handling of personal data and guarantee users’ right of self-determination regarding their information.
TikTok is planning to discuss a response. A TikTok representative stated, “Protecting users’ personal information and information security is one of our highest priorities, and we are doing our best to comply with relevant laws and regulations in Korea,” adding, “We will review the decision thoroughly after receiving the official notice and announce our position accordingly.”
Apple has stated that it will accept the decision. An Apple representative said, “We are committed to ensuring the safety and protection of domestic users’ personal information, and we will continue to cooperate with the Korean government in this regard.” According to Apple, since 2019, only user voice recordings from those who opt-in have been utilized for the improvement of the Siri service.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
A commission official commented, “We will continue to monitor the status of personal information handling by overseas businesses and respond strictly to violations without discrimination between domestic and international companies,” adding, “We will do our utmost to ensure that the personal information of our citizens is protected safely and transparently, even as it crosses borders in complex environments.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.