Two Men Confirmed Switched at Birth
Lawsuit Filed Against Hospital After Settlement Talks Fail
Similar Cases Have Emerged in the Past

In the United States, it was discovered through a home DNA test that two men who were born on the same day at the same hospital were switched at birth and raised for 36 years by each other's biological parents. Now 38 years old, the two men and their families have filed a lawsuit for damages, declaring, "The hospital stole the lives we were meant to live."


On July 23, Yonhap News TV, citing AP News, introduced the case of the American men who were switched at birth and have now filed legal action. Kyle Byrin and Jeremy Morrison were both born on January 26, 1988, at Unity Medical Center in Grafton, North Dakota, USA. At that time, they were the only newborns delivered at the hospital, but for unknown reasons, they were discharged to the wrong parents. The secret, buried for 36 years, began to unravel after one of them received a home DNA test kit as part of a Christmas gift exchange.

Jeremy Morrison (left) and Kyle Byrne. Photo by AP News

Jeremy Morrison (left) and Kyle Byrne. Photo by AP News

View original image

When Byrin registered his test results on a genealogy information platform, he discovered he was closely related to a woman he had never heard of before. This woman turned out to be Byrin’s biological aunt, and her nephew was none other than Morrison. After being contacted, Morrison also took a DNA test. On seeing photos of Byrin’s siblings, he noticed an astonishing resemblance to himself, and further genetic analyses effectively confirmed that the two men had been switched immediately after birth.


The man who grew up as Kyle Byrin is, biologically, the son of the Morrison family. It has been reported that he still keeps the hospital bracelet he wore at birth, which, by mistake, bore the name “Kyle Byrin.” Evelyn Newton, who raised Byrin as her son, said that even after learning the truth, "Kyle is still my son, and that will never change."


However, she expressed deep sorrow over missing out on key milestones—her biological son’s first steps, teaching him to drive, his wedding, and many other irreplaceable moments. Morrison also stated that he still considers Elizabeth O'Toole and Terry Morrison, who raised him, to be his parents. He said, “I grew up loved, I played sports, and had a happy school life. A DNA test cannot erase 38 years of memories.” Both eventually met their biological parents. While the meetings were warm, there was also considerable awkwardness, as they were not familiar with one another. Byrin and Morrison have spoken on the phone but have not yet met in person.

Lawsuit Filed After Settlement Talks Fail...Similar Past Cases Emerge

The two families attempted to reach a financial settlement with the hospital for about a year, but after failing to reach an agreement, they recently filed a lawsuit in the North Dakota court. The lawsuit involves both men and their families and claims that, due to the hospital’s negligence, parents and their children were separated for an extended period, suffering lasting psychological harm and irreparable damage to family relationships.

Kyle Byren and his biological mother. AP News

Kyle Byren and his biological mother. AP News

View original image

Unity Medical Center did not deny that the two men were separated from their biological parents after being born on the same day at the hospital. However, the hospital stated that there was no evidence proving that the babies were switched due to staff error. The hospital said, “Nearly 40 years have passed, so medical and staffing records from that time no longer exist, and the staff involved in the deliveries do not work here anymore. While we deeply empathize with the shock experienced by the families, we have not found evidence to support claims of responsibility on the part of the hospital or its personnel.”

The 'Secret of Birth' Revealed by DNA

This is not the first time a “switched at birth” case has come to light decades later due to DNA testing. Previously, in Norway, it was confirmed through DNA testing in 2021 that two women who were born at the same hospital in 1965 grew up switched. Notably, it emerged that local health authorities became aware of the possibility of a mix-up as early as 1985 but failed to inform the families involved, leading the women and their families to file human rights lawsuits against the state and local governments in 2024.


In West Virginia, USA, it was established through DNA testing that two men who were born on the same day in 1942 were raised in each other’s families for about 80 years. They filed a lawsuit in 2020 against the Catholic diocese that once ran the maternity hospital. Similarly, at a hospital in Manitoba, Canada, DNA tests revealed that two pairs of indigenous men born in 1975 had been switched. After two such incidents were confirmed at that same hospital, in 2016 the Canadian government launched an independent investigation.



Meanwhile, the Joint Commission, the organization that accredits hospitals in the United States, currently classifies newborns as a group at high risk for mistaken identity compared to general patients. The Commission recommends that hospitals use at least two types of patient identifiers and apply distinct naming systems and multiple identification bands and barcodes for newborns.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing