High Hurdles in Preliminary Feasibility Studies... "Economic Evaluation Must Improve for Transport-Disadvantaged Areas"
Seoul Holds Grand Forum on Reforming the Preliminary Feasibility Study System
"Government Reforms Must Fully Reflect the Realities of the Metropolitan Area"
"Discussions Focused on Equitably Assessing the Value of Public Investment"
There has been a call for further improvements to the government's preliminary feasibility study system to more closely reflect the circumstances of the Seoul metropolitan area. Although the government adjusted factors such as the weight of economic feasibility in May, there are still limitations to implementing projects with high public value.
On July 22, the Seoul Metropolitan Government held the "Preliminary Feasibility Study System Improvement Forum to Alleviate Transport-Disadvantaged Areas in the Seoul Metropolitan Area" at Sema Hall in the Seoul Museum of Art.
A scene from the "Pre-Feasibility Study System Improvement Forum for Resolving Transportation-Disadvantaged Areas in the Seoul Metropolitan Area" held at SeMA Hall, Seoul Museum of Art, on the 22nd. Seoul City
View original imageMore than 100 participants, including experts and academics in urban planning, transport, and economic analysis, as well as citizens, attended the forum. They had in-depth discussions on additional institutional improvements needed to enhance the effectiveness of the preliminary feasibility study system and secure the future urban competitiveness of the metropolitan area.
The first keynote speaker, Professor Hyunwoo Tak from Korea National University of Transportation, focused on the government's revision of the preliminary feasibility system from May 2026 and its future impact in his presentation, "Analysis of the 2026 Preliminary Feasibility Study System Reform." The government had previously revised its guidelines by lowering the weight of economic feasibility by 5%, as continuously suggested by the Seoul Metropolitan Government, and introducing a new 5% weight for balanced growth in the metropolitan area, among other improvements to assessment items and analysis criteria.
Professor Tak evaluated these revisions as positive steps towards making the system more realistic. However, he pointed out that "it is still difficult to fully reflect the complex urban problems faced by the metropolitan area." Even after the reforms, up to 70% of the evaluation of projects in the metropolitan area is still determined by economic feasibility (B/C), making it challenging to promote highly public projects such as light rail in transport-disadvantaged areas, regardless of their policy necessity.
The second keynote speaker, Professor Gilgon Ko of Seoul National University, addressed "the limitations of the preliminary feasibility study system and directions for improvement." He argued, "To overcome the current limitations of the system, it is essential to structurally transition from an evaluation centered on economic feasibility to a comprehensive assessment of public value." He also suggested that the system should better account for balanced regional development effects within the metropolitan area by adjusting the weight and criteria of policy-related items.
He further emphasized, "The current dichotomous evaluation framework divides the country into the metropolitan and non-metropolitan regions, and assumes the metropolitan area is always the more developed. This creates limitations in improving infrastructure in underdeveloped parts of the metropolitan area." He stressed that interpreting national balanced development solely as a non-metropolitan issue must change, and the regional disparities within the metropolitan area should also be recognized as a national challenge.
Subsequent discussions featured eight expert panellists, including academics and professionals. The panel was chaired by Professor Hyun Park of the University of Seoul, and included Dr. Dongseong Kim from the Seoul Public Investment Management Center, Dr. Daehyun Seo from the Incheon Public Investment Management Center, Dr. Hoyoung Lee from the Gyeonggi Public Investment Management Center, Kwangyeol Ahn, Director-General for Transport Policy at the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, and Yoonha Kim, Director of the Balanced Development Policy Division at the Seoul Metropolitan Government.
The experts collectively pointed out, "The excessive focus on economic feasibility and the low weighting given to assessments of balanced regional development create structural disadvantages for expanding infrastructure in underdeveloped areas within the metropolitan area." They agreed on the need to revise the evaluation system and adjust the weighting of policy and regional balance indicators to reflect regional disparities, congestion, and future demand within the metropolitan area.
The experts also added that national issues such as low birth rates, population aging, carbon neutrality, and digital transformation cannot be judged solely by cost–benefit analyses. They suggested that a broader range of factors—including social benefits, urban resilience, safety, and environmental value—should be incorporated into assessments.
The Seoul Metropolitan Government plans to continue proposing improvements to the system to the central government, based on the results of this large-scale forum and academic research projects. The main elements of these recommendations are expected to include: reducing the weight of economic feasibility evaluations, re-examining and discovering new benefit categories, and newly establishing evaluation criteria for the efficiency of transport systems.
The Seoul Metropolitan Government has been making continuous efforts to improve the system to match the realities of the metropolitan area, having already submitted suggestions for reforming the preliminary feasibility study system to the government in July 2024, and previously holding the "Grand Forum for Improving the Preliminary Feasibility Study System for Balanced Development and Efficiency in National Finance" last year with academics, research institutions, and citizens.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Sukkyoon Kang, Director-General of the Balanced Development Headquarters at the Seoul Metropolitan Government, stated, "In order to strengthen the nation's competitiveness amid a rapidly changing urban environment, a fundamental reform of the preliminary feasibility study system is necessary." He further promised close cooperation with experts and the central government to ensure that the system develops beyond simple economic evaluations into one that can equitably assess the value of public investment for future generations.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.