[What the N% Performance Bonus Debate Left Behind]③ Sangmin Lee, Hanyang University Professor: "The Same Principles Must Apply to Both Profits and Losses"
Interview with Professor Sangmin Lee, Hanyang University College of Business
"Residual Asset Claims Should Extend to Shareholders, Employees, and Partners"
"Demands for Recognizing Union Contribution Through Strikes Are a Positive Force"
It has been argued that the root cause of the annual conflict over performance bonuses is not the scale of distribution but the lack of underlying principles. Experts recommend establishing standards that reflect both companies' future investments and workers’ rewards for performance, and that the same rules should apply in both economic upturns and downturns to break the cycle of labor-management disputes.
In an interview with The Asia Business Daily on the 22nd at Hanyang University in Seongdong-gu, Seoul, Sangmin Lee, professor at Hanyang University School of Business, said, "If labor unions made bold demands in times of prosperity, they must also be willing to share the burden during downturns. When determining the share, keep in mind that the same principles apply in both profit and loss situations."
Professor Sangmin Lee of Hanyang University School of Business is being interviewed by The Asia Business Daily on the 22nd at the Hanyang University Business Building in Seongdong-gu, Seoul. Photo by Jinhyung Kang
View original imageProfessor Lee stressed that companies do not need to distribute all of their excess profits, as they must prepare for future risks and make large-scale investments. "We cannot predict exactly how artificial intelligence (AI) will evolve, and just as Samsung Electronics suffered setbacks due to a delayed response to high-bandwidth memory (HBM) technology, keeping up with emerging technologies requires investment and research & development," he explained. He added, "Companies should retain earnings and invest boldly when necessary. Discussions about sharing performance with workers should take place only after factoring in investment plans and the portions required for shareholder returns and social contributions."
He also emphasized that trust between labor and management is a prerequisite for recognition of retained earnings for future investments. Even if funds are genuinely earmarked for investment, it will be difficult to convince labor unions without mutual trust. He said, "Going forward, companies should disclose information transparently and, based on trust, take into account uncertainty, investments, and dividends."
He expressed concerns about the operating profit-linked compensation methods adopted by some companies. "Setting bonuses as a fixed percentage of operating profit is too simplistic," he said. "Various uncertainties, individual differences, and union contributions must be reflected. While using a fixed percentage of operating profit as a starting point may be reasonable, it cannot serve as a permanent solution. There should be a basic formula in place, but this must be adjusted every year to reflect industrial uncertainties, investment plans, and labor contributions," he stressed.
Professor Lee cited the "risk-taking" principle as the basis for distributing excess profits. "Under corporate law, shareholders have the residual claim right, which allows them to receive any remaining assets. The legitimate basis for deciding who is entitled to this claim is risk-taking, or the willingness to bear risk," he explained.
By law, only shareholders are granted the residual claim right. However, Professor Lee argued that if the logic of risk-taking is extended, employees, partners, local community members, and the government can also legitimately participate in the discussion about sharing excess profits. Shareholders bear the final loss when a company collapses. Likewise, workers invest human capital and develop skills that are only usable at a particular company, so they, too, suffer loss if the firm disappears. Partner companies supplying raw materials and production facilities customized to certain clients, as well as the government, which establishes a foundation for industry growth, and residents near production sites, all take on certain costs and risks as well.
"Partners’ Share Must Be Considered...Return Through Earmarked Taxes and Industry Funds"
Sangmin Lee, professor at Hanyang University College of Business, is giving an interview to The Asia Business Daily on the 22nd at the Hanyang University Business Hall in Seongdong-gu, Seoul. Photo by Jinhyung Kang
View original imageProfessor Lee identified as a limitation the fact that performance bonus negotiations at Samsung Electronics and SK hynix have focused only on the interests of parent-company labor and management. "Not only employees, but also a variety of suppliers have endured significant challenges and taken on risk," he said. "It is essential to compensate and share profits with partner companies and invest in technology together. Even if not directly through incentives, raising supply prices so that wages can increase is key to sustaining a virtuous and sustainable industrial ecosystem," he added.
He suggested that the portion returned to society in recognition of government support and the burden borne by the public should be structured as earmarked taxes or industry funds. "It is desirable to establish funds to support infrastructure, investment, policy finance, and parts/materials/equipment companies related to the semiconductor industry. This approach can be complemented with excess profit taxes as well as win-win funds between labor and management, and joint funds with small and mid-sized partners. These resources can be returned to society in the form of industrial support grants or unemployment assistance," he explained. He said that the specific allocation ratio should be determined by internal discussions within each company.
He assessed the very act of labor unions raising these issues positively. "By leveraging the powerful tool of strikes to raise and press these issues, labor unions have triggered serious discussions in society about acknowledging and rewarding worker contributions, and this is a significant step forward," he interpreted.
He identified a weak system for job-based pay as a deeper background issue for the current debate. "Korean society has not yet established clear practices for evaluating the value of individual jobs, despite the rapid development of capitalism," he said. "When there are no established standards for evaluating and compensating work, it becomes even harder to agree on additional performance criteria." He suggested, "For performance-based pay schemes to genuinely take root for the long term, companies and society must develop evaluation practices and capabilities around job roles. In this process, discussions about job-based pay can advance to a more mature level."
Professor Lee emphasized that this issue should not be viewed as an isolated case limited to a few companies. "Problems around distribution, weak labor-management trust, and institutional gaps regarding fairness have accumulated during Korea’s rapid growth, and these have now come to the surface. We should begin with viable systems that do not send abrupt signals to the market, and gradually work to institutionalize them over time," he said.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
About the Interviewee
Professor Sangmin Lee
▲ Currently Professor at Hanyang University School of Business
▲ M.A. in Business Administration from Seoul National University Graduate School, Ph.D. in Business Administration from University of Cologne, Germany
▲ Visiting Research Fellow, Korea Labor Institute, 2004-2005
▲ President, Korean Academy of Human Resource Management since 2026
▲ Research in human resource development, labor-management relations, and related fields
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.