[Tax System Must Change] "Across-the-Board Tax Increases Stifle Transactions... Not the Right Mix for Market Normalization"
"Property Tax System, Side Effects Surge Due to Market Intervention"
Used as a Policy Tool Amid Volatile Markets Since the 1960s
Large Discretion for the Administration Leads to Policy Swings by Political Leaning
Expected Tax Law Reforms: Higher Holding Taxes, Lower Transaction Taxes
There has been criticism that after industrialization, the government’s inconsistent application of tax policies based on real estate market conditions has increased uncertainty. While authorities have actively intervened in the real estate market through the tax system, these property-related tax schemes have not been systematically designed, which has reduced tax acceptance among the public and affected trust in policy. As the government is set to overhaul the entire tax code, including those on real estate, experts are advising that reforms should be guided by principles of predictability and continuity.
The first case of the government responding to surging property prices through tax policy dates back to the 1960s, during a period of major development projects. When land prices soared by more than 50% annually due to the construction of the Gyeongbu Expressway and the development of Gangnam, the government introduced the Real Estate Speculation Restraint Tax. In the 1970s, heavier taxes were levied on luxury properties, including land and housing, and the capital gains tax was introduced. In the 1980s, the capital gains tax rates were shifted to a progressive scale, and the Excess Land Profits Tax was implemented, reflecting the concept of public ownership of land.
When the market slumped during the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis, the government responded with policies to stimulate housing demand, including easing non-taxation and exemptions, and reducing various capital gains and acquisition taxes. The Comprehensive Real Estate Holding Tax, introduced in 2005, was also intended as a measure against a heated market, and its stringency has fluctuated depending on the administration.
Lee Dongsik, a professor at Kyungpook National University School of Law, said, "It was inevitable for the government to use fiscal measures to address certain outcomes of market failures, but the problem is that policy missteps compounded market failures and ultimately made matters worse."
Despite principles such as equality, fairness, and neutrality that should guide tax policy, the property tax system has often been reactive, undermining these principles and failing to achieve its intended effects. For example, the Moon Jae-in administration tightened capital gains taxes for owners of multiple homes, only for the Yoon Suk-yeol administration to suspend those rules, and then for the Lee Jae-myung government to revive them again. Such unpredictability, with policies frequently changing depending on political leadership, has undermined predictability.
The current structure, in which the government sets official property prices and the fair market value ratio—the basis for property taxes—also introduces the risk of arbitrary application depending on the administration’s stance. Lee Sangmin, Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Fiscal Strategy, commented, "The greatest problem with the real estate tax system is not simply the level of tax rates but the excessively frequent changes in the system driven by short-term real estate policy objectives. Real estate taxes should not be used either as a weapon to control housing prices or as a tool to penalize specific taxpayers or induce certain transactions."
Another issue is that the combination of real estate taxes has not been designed to promote market stability. According to research by Park Jinbaek, Associate Research Fellow at the Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements, when the capital gains tax was increased during a market downturn, transaction volumes fell by about 22–36%, illustrating unintended consequences.
Park explained, "An across-the-board tax increase may appear effective for stabilizing prices in a rising market, but it excessively dampens transactions, so it is not the right mix to normalize market activity. Furthermore, the fact that acquisition and property taxes are overseen by the Ministry of the Interior and Safety, while comprehensive property and capital gains taxes fall under the Ministry of Economy and Finance, creates a structural flaw that makes coordinated tax policy design impossible."
Experts argue that it is necessary to revise the tax system in a predictable way to increase tax acceptance. Park Hoon, a professor at the University of Seoul, emphasized, "Instead of focusing solely on revenue or market regulation, we need a comprehensive approach that step-by-step rebuilds property tax policy based on consistent standards such as predictability, tax equity, and taxpayer acceptance, and that institutionalizes protections for taxpayers."
Song Seunghyun, CEO of Urban & Economy, noted, "In a market where speculative energy rapidly spreads across asset classes when supply-demand uncertainties arise, it is impossible for the government to entirely abandon the regulatory and guiding functions of taxation. However, tax measures should act as subtle regulatory signals that do not severely disrupt the market’s price mechanism, linking policy in a flexible and sophisticated manner rather than being used as blunt instruments."
Apartments in the Gangnam 3 Districts viewed from Lotte World Tower in Songpa-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News
View original imageWhile there is broad consensus on the current government’s overall direction to increase holding taxes and decrease transaction taxes under President Lee Jae-myung, there are many proposals regarding the concrete design of these policies. Yang Jiyeong, Senior Specialist at Shinhan Premier Pass Finder, pointed out, "Incentives are needed for genuine homebuyers who are moving to better homes, for seniors downsizing, and for people relocating to other regions, since these types of moves bring existing stock onto the market. Rather than imposing taxes that stifle transactions, policy should facilitate necessary transactions and impose appropriate burdens on excessive asset concentration."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Chung Sae-eun, a professor at Chungnam National University, commented, "Since the acquisition tax for single-home owners is not very high, it could remain at its current level for now. Because the fair market value ratio is governed by enforcement decrees, undermining the effectiveness of holding taxes, it would be better to abolish this system and instead use cap regulations to prevent excessive increases in tax burdens."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.