[Hyuk Woo Lee's Beyond the Frame] The First Step Toward a Responsible Assembly: Put a Legislative Nameplate on Every Bill
“Let’s Just Pass It” — Silence on Flawed Legislation
Minshik’s Law, the Anti-Tada Law, the DanTong Act...
Who Is Behind These Absurd Bills?
Sponsors Must Be Held Accountable for Supplementary Investigation Authority Outcomes
In the U.S
Who sponsored the amendment to the Criminal Procedure Act that abolishes supplementary investigation rights? Who initiated the “Yellow Envelope Law” (amendments to Articles 2 and 3 of the Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act), which expands business operator liability and eases unions' obligation to pay damages? What about the so-called “Min-sik’s Law,” which mandates the installation of CCTV cameras and a 30 km/h speed limit near school zones; the “Tada Ban Law” that effectively forced Tada out of the market; or the Terminal Device Distribution Law (commonly known as the “Dantong Law”), which, since 2014, has burdened citizens with higher costs to purchase mobile devices? Who actually leads the drafting of these far-reaching, sometimes outrageous bills that directly affect our daily lives?
The first plenary session of the July extraordinary National Assembly held at the National Assembly on the 21st. Photo by Hyunmin Kim
View original imageThe National Assembly’s “legislative omnipotence” is not a new problem, but rather a long-standing practice. According to the Good Regulation Citizen Forum, there were 17,311 bills proposed during the first half of the 22nd National Assembly (from May 30, 2024 to May 31, 2026). This averages around 23.7 bills submitted each day. Over 10 lawmakers have added their names as joint sponsors to more than 1,000 bills, and some boast of having introduced hundreds of bills themselves. Such figures can hardly be considered reasonable legislative activity. Among them are bills outside the jurisdiction of the proponent’s committee, and many are those that should have been left alone. This indicates that the so-called “principle of restraint”—the self-restraint lawmakers should exercise—is simply not at work.
As seen most recently with the proposed revisions to the Criminal Procedure Act regarding supplementary investigation rights, lawmakers routinely cross the line on key legislative issues. Instead of calmly and deeply deliberating across party lines, individual parties and lawmakers flood the National Assembly with separate bills, seek out press conferences and interviews to sway public opinion, and then move on to public hearings filled only with those who agree with them. Bills are labeled as “reforms,” given tight deadlines, and their impact on the public is magnified. As a result, the necessary process of re-examination is often skipped, and calls for more thorough debate are dismissed as simple obstruction. Accusations of “standing in the way of reform” have long become a common National Assembly scene.
What we must pay attention to and question is why, amid this legislative flood, the names of those who actually initiate these bills are so hard to find. There is a structural problem at play. In standing committees, procedural practices such as “reflection-abolition-consolidation" are used to bundle numerous bills into new combined versions, eliminating individual accountability. In the end, the burdens of flawed legislation fall entirely on the public, while those who should be held responsible seem to vanish “by magic.” Lawmakers, each a government official in their own right, use these mechanisms to hide within the collective, making it hard to criticize or even praise individual contributions. The result is a disappearance of individual accountability, whether the outcome is positive or negative.
This behavior by the National Assembly undermines the “primordial principle of responsibility” that naturally emerges in any society where people live together. When something is created, it’s natural to ask who made it and why. But under this system, finding the answer becomes impossible. People tend to be prudent when they know they will be held accountable for their actions; risks are avoided, and a sense of responsibility leads to more careful decision-making. Sometimes, this serves as the driving force behind the best outcomes. When responsibility disappears, brazen attitudes remain. Even after a major blunder, lawmakers highlight only their successes and move on; crises go unpunished, and voters have observed these scenes many times before as lawmakers easily return to the National Assembly.
From this perspective, legislative real-name accountability is absolutely necessary. This means using the name of the original lawmaker who proposed the bill as its nickname. Returning to the first question: The “Yellow Envelope Law” was sponsored by Assemblymen Lee Yongwoo, Shin Jangshik, and Yoon Jongoh; “Min-sik’s Law” by Kang Hoonshik and Lee Myungsoo; the “Tada Ban Law” by Park Honggeun; and the “Dantong Law” by Cho Haejin. The amendment to the Criminal Procedure Act was introduced in different versions regarding how to handle supplementary investigation rights: Assemblymembers Kim Yongmin and Park Eunjung sponsored one version; Kim Hankyu (abolition), Hong Giwon (partial retention), and Jeong Jeomsik (expansion) each sponsored others. In Korea, at least 10 lawmakers must endorse a bill for submission, and the main sponsor is typically the lawmaker with primary responsibility. Thus, the principal responsibility for any bill should most appropriately rest with its main sponsor.
Uniquely, in Korea, the nickname for a bill often emphasizes its intention or references the party that prompted its introduction—for example, the “Yellow Envelope Law,” “Min-sik’s Law,” and “Kim Yonggyun’s Law.” Conversely, some nicknames highlight negative side effects, such as the “Liptulmakk Law” or the “Tada Ban Law.” Such customs help fuel debates and clarify partisanship, and once a catchy name arises, it spreads quickly through politics and the media.
Seungwon Kim, Chair of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee's Subcommittee No.1, is presiding over the 2nd meeting of the Subcommittee No.1 of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee held at the National Assembly on the 13th. The subcommittee discussed partial amendments to the Criminal Procedure Act and other bills. Members of the People Power Party who are boycotting the National Assembly schedule in opposition to the organization of the committees were absent. Photo by Hyunmin Kim
View original imageIn this light, it is critical to establish a legislative real-name accountability system as standard practice. If abolishing supplementary investigation rights results in the feared consequence of a surge in offenders, responsibility must first be sought from Assemblymembers Kim Yongmin, Park Eunjung, and Kim Hankyu. Likewise, if a bill expanding supplementary investigation rights passes and leads to renewed prosecutorial abuse, Assemblyman Jeong Jeomsik should have to answer for it. For the “Yellow Envelope Law,” “Min-sik’s Law,” “Tada Ban Law,” and “Dantong Law,” each of whose side effects have already surfaced or been confirmed, the main sponsor for each bill should be clearly identified as responsible. Making primary sponsors accountable for the reckless proliferation of bills will allow the public to get answers about their impact and side effects. It will enable people to assess whether their representatives performed appropriately and ensure their record is preserved for historical judgment.
At a deeper level, these problems stem from the National Assembly’s “naivety,” rooted in the abandonment of responsible politics—the foundation of democracy itself. Lawmakers flood the assembly with so-called “reform” bills, yet it is nearly impossible to know who led and sponsored them, while the harm inflicted on the public is ignored in favor of grandstanding. Citizens, therefore, must accept reality, enduring both the discomfort of flawed laws and the mystery of who conceived them. But it is time to establish a new paradigm that can put an end to this cycle.
The U.S. Congress sets a positive example. In the U.S., all major bills carry the sponsor’s name as a nickname. This demands individual accountability and leaves a historical record for future judgment. “The Pendleton Act,” named after its sponsor George Hunt Pendleton, is honored for establishing merit-based civil service; while the “Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act,” led by Reed Smoot and Willis C. Hawley, is infamous for worsening the Great Depression. American students read such evaluations in their textbooks. As the 22nd National Assembly enters its latter half, it is certain that more bills with major public impact will soon follow. In this context, it is all the more urgent for legislative real-name accountability to take hold in Korea’s National Assembly as soon as possible.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Lee Hyeokwoo, Professor of Public Administration at Paichai University, Chair of the Regulation Monitoring Committee at the Good Regulation Citizen Forum
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.