President Lee: "Even Public Interest Donations Could Be Considered Third-Party Bribery"... Calls for Clear Legal Enforcement Standards (Comprehensive)
President Lee Presides Over Cabinet Meeting
During Corporate Social Contribution Talks:
"A Structure Where Any Job-Related Link Triggers Charges"
Vice Minister of Justice: "There Have Been Past Indictments... The Burden Is Real"
"Re-ex
President Lee Jae-myung stated on July 21 that the current investigatory and prosecutorial practices, which could punish government agencies for encouraging corporations to make donations to public interest organizations through third-party bribery charges, must be reformed. He emphasized that merely connecting corporations to social contribution projects by public officials should not expose them to criminal liability, warning that such risks could stifle public interest projects themselves and urging the establishment of clear law enforcement standards and guidelines.
President Lee Jae-myung is speaking at the Cabinet Meeting held at the Blue House on the 21st. July 21, 2026. Photo by Yonhap News Agency
View original imageAfter receiving a report on measures to promote corporate social contribution at the Cabinet Meeting held at the Blue House that day, President Lee said, "Currently, prosecutors work on the assumption that if any work-related connection exists, discussions with corporations that result in donations to third-party public interest organizations will always be deemed guilty under third-party bribery laws," adding, "This situation absolutely has to be resolved."
His remarks came as Minister of Unification Jeong Dongyoung shared exemplary cases of corporate social contribution. Minister Jeong explained that Hyundai Motor Group supported Yeomyung School, which educates children of North Korean defectors, by providing 6 billion won out of the total construction cost of 16 billion won for a new school building on a closed school site in Gangseo-gu, Seoul.
President Lee then quipped that "there is a high probability this could be considered third-party bribery," before pointing out, "Under the current legal interpretation, if ministries communicate with companies even slightly related to their work and facilitate donations to third-party public interest organizations, all such acts would constitute third-party bribery."
He further criticized, "The criminal punishment system has been managed with political aims, and that is how we've reached this point," adding, "If you converse with people related to your duties and they give something to a public interest organization, and if the company's pending issues are related to the ministry's work, then under the current interpretation everything becomes an offense." Lee continued, "If authorities want to prosecute, they can find grounds," warning, "Since public officials undertaking public interest activities themselves can become problematic, we must eventually establish clear guidelines."
Vice Minister of Justice Lee Jinsu responded, "There have been instances in the past where prosecutors indicted similar cases under third-party bribery charges," acknowledging, "Although the charge of third-party bribery under the law requires improper solicitation as an element, current interpretations in practice impose a real burden."
However, under current case law, the mere existence of a relationship between a public official's duty and a corporate donation does not automatically constitute third-party bribery. For third-party bribery under Article 130 of the Criminal Act to be established, a public official must receive an “improper solicitation” in connection with their official duties and cause a third party to receive money or benefits. Although such improper solicitation does not need to be explicit, there must be a common understanding or agreement between the parties that there is a quid pro quo between the handling of official duties and the provision of benefits to a third party. The Supreme Court has also ruled that simply requesting a donation by a public official or the actual donation by a corporation does not necessarily constitute an improper solicitation.
President Lee’s remarks are therefore interpreted as raising the issue that more detailed standards are needed to distinguish between public interest donations and indirect bribes that have a quid pro quo related to official duties, if corporate social contributions are to be revitalized. The government is expanding platforms that link corporations and public interest organizations, but it must also clarify the boundary of criminal liability that can arise when public officials’ requests for donations are tied to corporate licensing or regulatory issues.
Additionally, given that President Lee himself has been indicted on charges of third-party bribery in the Seongnam FC sponsorship case and the SBW North Korea remittance case, his remarks could be interpreted as a message aimed at the prosecutorial legal doctrine and investigative practices previously applied to him. While prosecutors determined there was a quid pro quo between resolving corporations’ issues or supporting Gyeonggi Province's projects with North Korea and providing money to third parties, President Lee’s side has countered that these were political indictments targeting public interest or policy projects as crimes.
According to senior presidential spokesperson Kang Yoojung, during the succeeding closed-door meeting, President Lee stated that a review of the abuse of authority provision is needed to establish proactive administration as an everyday culture among public officials. Emphasizing the need for criminal code revision, he asked the chairman of the Board of Audit and Inspection, "I understand that the Board can now provide advance opinions before policy decisions are made—what new systems have been introduced?" and asked for efforts to ensure the systems are properly adjusted.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
To Prime Minister Han Seongsook, Lee requested, "Please consider ways to relieve public officials of the burden of punishment so that they can work voluntarily, proactively, and actively." In response, Jo Wonchul, head of the Korea Legislation Research Institute, explained, "We have established a new Legal Advisory Bureau within the Institute, and are providing legal advice on various inquiries received from multiple ministries."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.