From Restricting Margin and Credit Transactions to Delisting
Focus on Whether the Government Conducted Sufficient Review Before Listing

Although the government has announced supplementary measures to protect investors in single-stock leveraged products and to mitigate volatility, there have been calls for a variety of additional measures, such as a ban on margin trading and making pre-investment education a regular requirement.


At the discussion forum titled "Is the Korean Stock Market Okay? The Rollercoaster of Samsung Electronics-SK hynix Leveraged ETFs," held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building on July 21, participants proposed various alternatives to mitigate the volatility caused by single-stock leverage and to protect investors.


On the 21st, a discussion forum on leveraged ETFs hosted by People Power Party members Su-Young Park, Jongwook Lee, and Jangkyum Kim was held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building. Photo by Youngwon Kim

On the 21st, a discussion forum on leveraged ETFs hosted by People Power Party members Su-Young Park, Jongwook Lee, and Jangkyum Kim was held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building. Photo by Youngwon Kim

View original image

Kim Daejong, a professor in the School of Business Administration at Sejong University, who served as the presenter, stated, "Just 40 days after listing, the government admitted its failure," adding, "Although the government announced measures such as increasing the deposit requirement on July 16, these are ultimately only stopgap solutions."


Professor Kim argued that 'debt-based investing' should be restricted specifically for leveraged ETFs. He said, "Let’s require that leveraged products can only be purchased with cash," and suggested banning both margin and credit transactions as alternatives.


Jodonggeun, Professor Emeritus in Economics at Myongji University and the moderator of the forum, described the single-stock leveraged products as "the worst blunder, increasing stock market volatility," and pointed out, "On July 8 alone, transactions of Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and derivatives accounted for 83.1% of all trades—a shockingly distorted ratio."


He explained, "Because derivative trading in Samsung Electronics and SK hynix is so active, a physical delisting is difficult. Realistically, mitigating the products is the only option." He suggested, "If the products track up to only 1.1 times rather than double the underlying, the market impact could be minimized." He also mentioned raising the deposit requirement further, from the current 10 million won to 100 million won.


Yoon Jaehong, Senior Researcher at the Research Center of Mirae Asset Securities, said during the discussion, "Although some supplementary measures were announced recently, I feel that more meticulous investor education would have been a welcome improvement." Yoon recommended shifting to periodic refresher training and education using real profit and loss scenarios and compounding loss simulations, so that investors can better understand potential risks.


He also mentioned the idea of imposing a cap on the proportion of each individual’s investment in leveraged products, rather than a simple investment amount limit. Yoon explained, "It's not about a strict investment cap, but setting a 'proportion limit'. By limiting the proportion of leveraged products within an individual’s total assets, it is possible to more reliably control allocations to these higher-volatility assets."


There was also criticism that more thorough review and consideration were needed during the government’s process of launching the product. Pyun Eunbi, legislative researcher at the Fiscal and Financial Affairs Office of the National Assembly Research Service, said, "Given the composition of domestic investors and the state of the local market, I question whether adequate safeguards were established from the beginning." She continued, "While labeling the products as non-ETFs was a step, the actual first contact investors have is through marketing and advertisements, not product names. In such an environment, it is unrealistic to expect general investors to calmly comprehend in just one hour of training that single-stock leveraged products carry risks distinct from ETFs, and then invest accordingly."


Pyun went on to emphasize, "As the government will continue to introduce new products in response to investor demand and market changes, the important thing is not only designing systems to meet policy objectives, but also sufficiently reviewing in advance whether the structure truly fits our market environment and what impact it might have."



Jeong Uijeong, president of the Korea Stock Investors Association, strongly advocated for delisting. He stated, "Delisting harmful products as quickly as possible is in the national interest, as they negatively affect the majority of citizens." He called for formulating a roadmap for delisting, implementing a 30-minute single-price trading session, and immediately banning margin and credit transactions. He also argued that, if necessary, the government should compensate investors for their losses.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing