[K-Beauty's Breakneck Pace]③"Even the Model Is Identical"... Amazon's No. 1 Brand Faces 'Copycat' Controversy
Yubin Son of Arencia Claims “Infringement of Brand Assets”
Biodance Remains Silent on the Issue
Concerns Grow Over “K-Beauty Fatigue”—Growing Pains for the Industry?
As K-beauty continues to make waves around the globe, a growing number of side effects are emerging. The so-called “copycat” controversy—where successful K-beauty brands are directly imitated and sold—shows no sign of abating. Industry insiders are concerned that if these controversies persist, they could lead to “K-beauty fatigue,” ultimately weakening the overall competitiveness of the K-beauty industry.
According to the cosmetics industry on July 29, Arencia Vice President Son Yubin recently posted a lengthy statement on her social media, alleging that the K-beauty brand Biodance had released a product copying Arencia’s “Booster Shot.”
Biodance is an indie K-beauty brand that gained traction with its “gel mask,” particularly at Olive Young and Costco in the United States. From 2024, Biodance’s gel mask topped the mask category on Amazon’s Cyber Monday for two consecutive years. Arencia, meanwhile, grew its overseas profile with innovative products such as “Rice Cake Soap” and “Fresh Cleanser.” The recent copycat controversy centers around Biodance’s eye cream product.
Vice President Son publicly raised the issue, stating, “I received messages from several clients and industry colleagues saying that Biodance seems to have launched a product extremely similar to Arencia’s.”
She added, “While packaging, color, or layout can each be common in the industry, in this case, the packaging, color, saturation, post-processing, message design, the same model, and even the shooting style all overlapped at once. Actual clients and consumers were the first to express confusion.” She continued, “I have also heard from some overseas buyers that Biodance offered a lower supply price at the same retail price. If a culture that does not respect each other’s creations and brand assets prevails, ultimately, the healthy competition and creativity of the entire K-beauty industry will be undermined.”
Currently, the problematic eye cream has been deleted from both Biodance’s official online store and website. Biodance’s side commented, “We are fully aware of the issue,” but added, “for now, we do not have an official statement.”
The drive to rapidly release new products has resulted in packaging, advertising concepts, and even models resembling those of competitors, sparking debate in the beauty industry about the boundaries between “trend borrowing” and “brand imitation.” Some consumers expressed concern that identical packaging, advertising images, and models can confuse buyers, while others argued that such design elements are common and should be seen as part of trend adoption in the cosmetics industry.
This controversy is seen as reflecting a structural issue within the broader K-beauty industry, rather than merely a dispute between certain brands. As the K-beauty market grows and trends change rapidly, instances of popular product concepts and designs being closely emulated have become more frequent. For example, COSRX previously filed a lawsuit last year against foreign sellers on Amazon and Temu for distributing counterfeit versions of its flagship product “Snail Mucin.”
Industry insiders expect disputes over the “overall impression of a brand”—an area not protected by design or trademark rights—to continue. In cosmetics, not only product ingredients but also packaging, brand image, and advertising visuals greatly influence consumer choices. Even if individual elements are generic, when color, packaging, photography concepts, and models are combined in a way that brings a specific brand to mind, copycat controversies are likely to arise.
There are also concerns inside and outside the industry that continued controversies could intensify “K-beauty fatigue.” As the pace of product launches accelerates and companies repeatedly adopt proven concepts for short-term hits, the competitiveness of the entire industry could suffer.
An industry source commented, “In the past, K-beauty was seen as fresh and innovative, but now, as trends and product cycles speed up, the market is flooded with similar products and concepts, leading to both overseas buyers and consumers feeling fatigued. While this may boost sales in the short term, over the long term, it could erode the overall competitiveness of K-beauty.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Meanwhile, Beauty Selection, the company behind Biodance, posted sales of 248.1 billion won last year, up 82.8% from the previous year. Operating profit during the same period rose from 26.8 billion won to 40.3 billion won, a 50.6% increase. Arencia reportedly achieved sales of 65 billion won in 2025.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.