"Self-Help Organizations Operated with Members' Contributions"

"Will the Government Be Accountable if Investment Returns Decline?"

The inclusion of multiple mutual aid associations on the list of institutions slated for relocation to Jeollabuk-do has led to strong opposition from their members.


On the 21st, Donggeun Shin, Chairman of the Federation of Government Employees' Unions, issued a statement expressing serious concerns about the proposed relocation of the mutual aid associations to Jeollabuk-do, emphasizing, "The assets of the mutual aid associations belong to the members, not the government or the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport."


Chairman Shin stated, "The mutual aid associations are not ordinary public enterprises operated with government budgets. They are self-help organizations that manage assets based on contributions and reserves paid by the members, and then return the results of that management to the members themselves." He further explained, "The reason the headquarters are located in Seoul is not simply due to regional preferences. Rather, it is because the key infrastructure needed for investment—such as domestic and international financial institutions, asset managers, and investment advisory firms—is concentrated in the Seoul metropolitan area." He added, "For institutions managing tens of trillions of won in assets, accessibility to information, securing highly qualified professionals, and prompt consultation with investment partners are essential to competitiveness."


Location Map of the Planned Financial Hub in Jeollabuk-do

Location Map of the Planned Financial Hub in Jeollabuk-do

View original image

Chairman Shin also voiced concerns about the inclusion of mutual aid associations as relocation candidates without sufficient verification. He pointed out, "If investment professionals leave, if it becomes difficult to recruit top talent, or if investment decision-making efficiency decreases and yields fall as a result, ultimately, the members will bear the cost." He further questioned, "If investment performance worsens after relocation, who will be accountable? Will the government compensate for the members' losses?" He argued, "If no one can take responsibility, then relocating the mutual aid associations simply allows policymakers to gain political justification, while the real risks are borne by the members."


Chairman Shin also cited a recent statement by President Lee Jaemyung regarding the claims of neglect against Jeollabuk-do in the context of the Honam Semiconductor Cluster. Recalling President Lee's remark that political considerations should not be added to corporate economic decisions and that fueling conflict with irresponsible comments is the worst behavior, Shin emphasized, "This principle should be applied to the current debate on relocating the mutual aid associations as well."


However, he was careful to specify that he does not deny the need for balanced national development. Chairman Shin said, "Easing the concentration in the Seoul metropolitan area and expanding the foundations for regional growth are important tasks for the country." He continued, "But institutions like mutual aid associations, which are operated with members' funds and where investment results are directly connected to the members' wealth, must be approached differently from ordinary public institutions."


Donggeun Shin, Chairman of the Federation of Government Employees' Labor Unions

Donggeun Shin, Chairman of the Federation of Government Employees' Labor Unions

View original image

He stressed that the relocation issue should not be unilaterally decided by the political sphere or government ministries. Instead, the actual owners of the mutual aid associations—the members—should be fully informed of the reasons for relocation, its economic effects, and potential risks, and their consent should be sought in advance. He continued, "Continuously raising the possibility of relocation without verifying the members' intentions only increases anxiety within the associations."



Finally, Chairman Shin called on the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, saying, "Rather than simply listing mutual aid associations as 'institutions to be relocated,' you must first provide a clear answer to the members." He demanded that the government clarify the expected impact of the Jeollabuk-do relocation on profitability and competitiveness, measures to prevent staff departures, and who would be responsible if losses occur. He concluded, "Pushing ahead with the relocation of the mutual aid associations without such review and explanation is not a policy for balanced national development, but could turn into a policy experiment that puts members' assets at risk. The government must first listen to the voices of the members and fulfill its responsibility to protect their assets."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing